A couple months ago, I met my boyfriend through my foster sister and her husband. They were trying to match him up with someone who wanted a serious relationship and who knew what she wanted to do with her life. In a nutshell, he wanted someone like me.
Like me, my boyfriend is quiet, family-oriented, faithful, and works hard to make his relationships work, which is what I love about him.
But when we’re together, I’m often unsure how to act or what to say. I wonder if I should be old-fashioned and serious, or if I should act funny, playful and outgoing, like I am with my sisters? Should I express my deepest feelings and fears? Or should I be like my mother-cold, unemotional and aggressive? I don’t know if these different sides that I show are all parts of me, or if they are only mirror images of the people who raised me.
It’s also hard to be myself because I’ve always been afraid of people’s reactions. I’ve never known what it was like to have complete trust in someone. My mother was a very unpredictable woman. You never knew when she was about to blow.
And moving from foster home to foster home, I felt like I had to adapt my personality to each foster mom’s liking or she wouldn’t put up with me. Instead, she might say, “Forget this, I don’t have to put up with your mess,” and call my social worker, and off to another foster home I’d go.
Like a Chameleon Changing Form
Molding myself to fit in with each foster mother kept me in a constant state of fear. They could set a limit to what they would put up with, and not knowing exactly what these limits were made me fearful that I would cross them.
Over the years, I began to lose my sense of self. My foster families’ ways of thinking and acting became my ways of acting and thinking, and I forgot who I was. Now I change my personality so much that it’s almost second nature, like a chameleon always changing color.
I act so many different ways that it’s hard to know how I want to respond in certain situations, especially with my boyfriend. When he tells me, “Be yourself,” I don’t know what that really means.
I’ve never trusted anyone enough to even try to be myself. But that’s no way to live any kind of life.
I want to feel what it’s like to be in love for the first time, and I want my boyfriend to see me and love me for who I am. How can he truly love me if I don’t let him know the person I am? And how can I express who I am if I don’t even know myself?
The Roots of My Insecurity
Growing up, my relationship with my mother wasn’t stable. At times, my mother could be the most caring person. Once she tried to make me believe in Santa Claus, and she put a little bit of a white fur coat on a cup, saying it was part of his beard. I thought it was sweet that she wanted to give me hope. Sometimes she also talked to me about boys and dance, and told me that I was her beautiful little girl.
But other times she seemed out of control, like she could explode at any moment. If I spoke back or voiced my opinion too loud, or in a tone she didn’t like, I had to prepare to feel the wrath of her hand.
Living with my mother, I’d only feel joy for a moment when something good happened. Then came the sadness, anger, pain, frustration and dissatisfaction. I’d ask myself, “What’s wrong with me? Does everyone feel this way?” I felt so alone.
Controlled by Mom’s Fears
I was a scared, nervous little girl and I hated school because I was picked on by other children. My mother was very fearful of letting me stray too far from home, so while most children played outside or learned how to ride a bike, I was home with my mother watching soaps, waiting for the monthly welfare check.
When I got old enough to ask why, my mother told me of her visions. I didn’t know how to absorb what I heard.
“Visions?” I said.
“I had a vision of you being kidnapped and left for dead in the woods,” she told me. I often wondered if she was just being paranoid or if she really had the gift of sight. Either way, growing up with a paranoid mother made me a bit fearful of the world and the people in it. And my mother’s inability to control her anger made me unable to express my emotions without fearing that I’d lose all control, like she did.
Bounced from Home to Home
For years, my mother was in and out of the hospital. She had cancer. I was 12 when she went in for the last time. When I visited she looked bloated from the medication, her hair was thin and she could barely speak a word. When I told her about performing in a dance play, she just cried. I didn’t understand the reason for her tears until a couple of months later when she died. And that’s when I started to get bounced from home to home.
I lived with my grandmother, until she died a year later, then with an aunt. Finally, I went to a foster home where I felt more at ease than I ever had living with family, and than I ever have since. When I first moved in, I was nervous and quiet. I wanted to be on my best behavior, and I wanted my foster mother to see me as the perfect child.
But outside the house, I changed. I decided I was going to be the exact opposite of the shy and scared little girl I had been. I wanted people to see me as spontaneous, sexy and free.
Hiding the Real Me
At first, I was just trying to be something I was not in order to be liked and popular. But as I grew older, pretending to be flirtatious became a cover-up, because I didn’t want people to know who I was inside. I believed that if people really knew me, they wouldn’t want to be around me. Acting flirtatious allowed me to come out of my shell without having to express the real me and risk getting rejected.
Still, I secretly hoped that the guy I was with was The One. I wanted something stable in my life. I had changed home addresses and schools and I didn’t have any strong relationships with any of my friends. But I didn’t find the stability I was looking for, because I picked guys who I couldn’t depend on.
One boyfriend was overprotective. At first I thought it was cute than he wanted to be around me 24/7, but later he started to become more aggressive and angry. When I told him I was on punishment for staying out late with him the night before, he smashed his Walkman and glasses on the ground and stomped on them.
Then I found someone who was funny and friendly. He was easy to talk to and we had a lot of fun together. Unfortunately he was sexually active and I was not, so after three months we went our separate ways.
During that time, I also found out that acting carefree came at a price. One day my foster mother called me into her room and confronted me about the way I acted with boys. She said other people viewed it as disrespectful and wrong. I felt ashamed and confused that some people had misunderstood the person I pretended to be.
After that, I didn’t date for five years. During those years, I moved through four different foster homes, and I didn’t feel like I could really trust anyone.
‘Do I Do Anything Right?’
My first foster mother and I started arguing, and I had to leave. I already felt sad about moving. Then my second foster mother made me feel worse.
She’d say, “Why you always wear baggy clothing? What are you trying to hide? Bend your knees when you walk. You walk like a robot. Hold in your stomach, you look like you’re pregnant. Stand up straight, you’re slouching. Stick out your chest. Don’t eat too fast.”
I began to wonder, “Is there anything I do right?”
I stood in the mirror counting the many flaws I had and thinking, “How can I lose my stomach?” or, “Am I standing up straight?” Soon I was criticizing everything about myself. My days and nights I spent daydreaming, envying other girl’s bodies, wishing I had their looks and popularity.
Comparing myself to others and living in fear of making the wrong move made me feel angry, stressed and depressed. I would often sit in my room by myself, or sleep. I never wanted to go anywhere with my friends because by the time I dealt with everything I had to go through at home I was too drained to do anything else.
Feeling like I had no one to confide in made me feel alone and isolated. And moving around made me feel even more afraid to trust others. How could I trust someone who would give up on me so easily? When I trust someone, I’m putting my emotions on the line, and that isn’t easy to do when you’re constantly getting hurt by the people who claim to care about you.
Finding Someone I Can Trust
Finally, I moved to a home that’s not perfect, but where I do feel a lot safer. My foster sister makes me feel so relaxed. She is outspoken and honest about her feelings and non-judgmental when she listens to what I have to say. That makes me want to be more open with her about thoughts and feelings.
When I tell her about my life before I came into care, I tell my story in detail, explaining how I felt in each situation, and it feels like my sister is reading my mind. She knows what I’m about to say before I say it, or she’ll give me examples of similar situations she’s been through. She is like a diary where I can express what I really think and feel. That’s a big relief to me.
My sister also shows me what a trusting relationship can be like. When she’s around her husband, she seems so relaxed and true to herself. Even though they argue at times, they also share in each others’ lives and they understand one another like best friends. That’s the way I want to be with my boyfriend. I would feel relaxed if I had that kind of relationship.
But, I don’t know what it will take to get to that point with my boyfriend. It’s like when you’re a little girl and your dream is to become an actress or a rap star-you don’t think about the process of getting there, you just imagine yourself there.
How Open Do I Have to Be?
My sister says it takes trust, openness and honesty to make a relationship work. I wonder, “How trusting, open and honest do I have to be? Should I tell him of my past and my struggles to find my identity?”
I did tell him that my mother used to hurt me. But I never told him what I meant by that, and he didn’t ask. I wish he would. I wish that he would tell me personal things without me asking him, and that he would ask me personal questions as well.
Other than that, I haven’t shared much with him. I’m not that comfortable with him yet. Maybe I need to take the risk, but I’m afraid. I do take a lot of risks, like making friends, choosing a college or entering a relationship. Somehow those risks are easy to take. But I’m not willing to risk communicating my feelings. I don’t want him to think that I’m a nutcase, or worse, pity me.
And often, I don’t even know what my feelings are. It’s never been safe for me to say how I feel, so many times I can’t tell if something makes me happy or sad. How can I know who I am if I can’t even recognize how I feel? I need to start asking myself how I feel, before I can share my feelings with someone else.
My foster mother told me, “Slowly, without even noticing it, you will become closer and closer to him.” When I think about all the times we’ve spent together, it’s true that we’ve become closer. Maybe it’s just going to take time for me to get to know myself better, and how I really feel, to become more trusting and open.
If my boyfriend was a little more open with me, I’d feel more comfortable expressing myself. But maybe it’s something he can’t help me with, it’s just something I need to work on. I hope that someday I feel more comfortable expressing myself and more confident about who I am.
SIDEBAR: Dance Freed Me To Be Myself
The only time I felt comfortable with myself was when I danced. I felt free and beautiful, like no one could hurt me or tear me down. Dancing made me feel like I could do anything. It gave me a burst of confidence that on my own I couldn’t achieve. I felt like my true self when I danced. Through dance, I also met friends who made me feel less isolated. They talked to me about what they went through, and whenever I had doubts about life, one friend would tell me, “You never know what God has in store for you. Everything that we go through in life is preparing you for your destiny.” Her words made me calm. Around my dance friends I felt comfortable and relaxed for the first time in my whole life. I could talk to them about the feelings I had inside and the nightmare I lived through when I went home. They gave me the mental strength to deal with the criticism. But when I got accepted to a dance company, my foster mother said her children don’t stay out all day and only come home to eat and sleep. To stay in her house I had to give up the one thing I loved and made me who I was. From that moment on the little bit of trust I had in foster mothers was demolished. When I gave up dance, I stopped seeing my friends, too. Even now I still feel a charge of anger and regret that my foster mother stole more than just my love for dance. She took away part of my identity.
Finding the Real You Talking with therapist Kate Dunn
Growing up, I never felt it was safe to express myself. My mom was ready to explode at any minute, and my foster moms were always ready to say “forget it!” if I crossed their limits. I started to feel like a chameleon, adapting myself to whatever they wanted. Now, at 21, I’ve realized that I’m not really sure who I am anymore. So I interviewed therapist Kate Dunn, who works with foster youth through the Child Psychotherapy Project in New York, about how foster youth like me can begin to discover our true selves.
Q: What can hurt a person’s sense of self?
A: Kids look at their parents to start to see if what they’re feeling and thinking is OK. If a parent reacts violently to a child, it starts to shut the child down, because she gets the feeling that something is wrong with her. That right there shakes a person’s developing sense of self. Young children are spontaneous, they don’t think about what they do. If they’re mad they yell, if they’re sad they cry. But if a child comes up against someone who reacts in a violent way then they’re going to be inhibited. It really shakes a person’s sense of security to move. Kids respond well to having a stable environment. Routine, and knowing how parents will respond to them, makes them feel safe. Moving from foster home to foster home is almost like traveling to another country. If you’re moving around and exposed to a lot of different families with different expectations and ways of doing things, you never get that secure base. You’re never sure how someone will respond to you. Some kids react by acting out. Other kids react by becoming very passive. That can be an effective way of protecting yourself. If your mother responds to you by being angry, you may learn that the way to avoid getting into trouble and not getting hurt is to keep very quiet and passive. It’s a way of keeping yourself safe.
Q: How can you get to know who you really are?
A: In adolescence, almost all people are unsure of who they are. They’re definitely not who they used to be. Everything is up in the air. Over time you’re going to have a clearer and clearer sense of you are. I don’t think it’s something that happens over night. You may not even notice it, you’ll just start to get a more solid sense of yourself. Paying attention to your own responses is the way you start to develop a sense of who you really are. Pay attention to things you like and don’t like. If people make fun of you, or make a joke when it’s seriousÉ anytime you put something out there and get a response that doesn’t feel good to you, that’s a sign that you need something different, someone who is there with you and listening. You want to be around people who make you feel good, who treat you as someone worthy. As you get older you can choose the people you want around you-people who are supportive and who you can trust. And you can take the risk to express yourself to see how it goes. Or risk getting angry at someone and see that they stick around. When kids have been in a lot of different placements, they learn how to adapt. They get really good at paying attention to other people and how they respond. Use that skill to pay attention to friends and how they treat you and how it feels. Therapy can help, because therapy is a safe place to express yourself. Keeping a journal and writing to yourself might also be good ways to get used to explaining your feelings to yourself. You can write people letters, if you’re not comfortable telling them how you feel. Then you’ll be more likely to get what you want from relationships, because people can hear you. Writing is a step along the way; eventually you can start to talk to the person. Writing is not as free-flowing as talking. It feels really good to be able to speak your mind, it gives you a real feeling of strength and self. It makes you feel that you’re out there and brave and true.
