A Playa Hangs Up His Jersey

Before I got into a serious relationship, I was what females would call a dog. I used to play girls left and right. When I first met a girl I liked, I would be around her all the time, but once I got what I wanted, I’d want to get to know someone new. Sometimes I would mess with one of her friends if they were pretty enough. I’m sorry to say it, but this was my specialty.
It got to a point where girls started buying me things thinking it was love when for me it was just a game. As bad as it may sound, I didn’t think I was doing anything wrong. I felt like because I have a certain love for so many females I shouldn’t have to be with just one. (No excuses, I’m serious.) So when girls started getting heartbroken from me, I never understood why. I thought it was all good to love females this way. I never tried to be a player or a dog, that’s just the way I was.
Every now and then I did think about finding one female to be in a relationship with. But whenever I thought about it, I felt like that would be giving too much of myself to just one person. That’s something I thought I really wouldn’t feel comfortable doing because I feel like I gave too much of myself to my mother and I tried too hard to make our relationship work, but she just didn’t seem to care one way or the other.
You see, I trusted my mother on many occasions and each time she betrayed me. She wasn’t there for me while I was growing up, and when I returned to her from foster care, she promised she would be different, but she wasn’t.
Then I Met Her
I know that having a romantic relationship takes trust, but since my mother has always betrayed my trust, I felt like who can I trust if I can’t trust my own mother. So instead of looking for love, I just had fun.
Also, I have almost never seen a good relationship, except for elderly couples who’ve been married longer than I’ve been living. And I’ve noticed that people in relationships argue a lot. I ain’t feeling that. After all I’ve been through, I want calm, not conflict.
Then I met a girl who I wanted to settle down with, somebody who I thought would be worth it. I met her at my job working with computers, which gave me the idea that she was smart. We started talking and holding real good conversations. We also had a lot in common. Our favorite color was blue, we both had turbulent relationships with our parents, we were both in foster care, and we both loved icy white Nikes. I told her about my past and she told me hers. We were alike in so many ways I thought I was dreaming. Next thing you know she became my wifey.
During our first month together I was still seeing other girls because that was a habit of mine that needed to be broken, but soon I decided to give commitment a shot because I liked this girl so much. I thought this girl wanted me to be with her only, and I wanted to make her happy. I also wanted to see what a relationship had to offer.
I Decided to Be True
I made it clear to my wifey that I was faithful to her, though I never did tell her about the way I usually was with girls. I didn’t want to give her that perception of me. A player was hanging up his jersey.
Things couldn’t get any better in the beginning of our relationship. We’d spend hours on the phone and went to the movies on the weekends. I would even come up out my wallet just so she could have a good time. (That was something I never did for any of the girls before her.)
Being faithful wasn’t even all that hard. Once I met my girl, I didn’t even look at other girls the same. Before, I would get a girls’ number and call her sometime that week. Now I was getting girl’s numbers just to see if I could, but I wouldn’t call. I felt good about myself for staying faithful to my wifey.
Then I found out she was still seeing her ex. By chance, one of my friends was talking about his ex-girlfriend and it turned out to be my girl. He bragged about how he was going out with her again. He didn’t know I was going out with her and I didn’t tell him. I wanted to see just how much my girl would lie to me.
When I asked her about her ex, she told me she was completely through with him. I decided to take a chance and trust her about it. I thought maybe they were just having some closure on their old relationship, but that wasn’t the case.
Betrayed
Turns out, she was acting as if he was still her man. On her birthday he took her to get her hair and nails done. Traditionally, the boyfriend is supposed to do that.
Also, I had respected the fact that she made me wait to make with her. Then she wound up making out with him. I know, because he showed me the panties and I recognized them as hers.
But I never told her what I knew, even to this day. Maybe then she would’ve tried to cover it all up better, and I wouldn’t have been able to tell if she was still cheating on me or not. I would be played even more. I also felt like since she was cheating on me, she had all the power in the relationship. I felt that not telling her what I knew gave me some power back.
But obviously, I started to look at her differently. I began questioning whether I could trust her like I wanted to.
Arguing All the Time
Soon we started to argue all the time about things that weren’t even important. She would lie to me about things there was no reason to lie about, such as what time she had to be home, or she would say that she didn’t have any money when she did. In the meantime, she was still seeing her ex because the hickeys on her neck were never mine. She’d try to say they were mine, but when I asked my man he’d tell me the exact spot where he gave her a hickey.
Then she said she didn’t think I was being faithful to her because her past boyfriends told her the same thing and they were all lying. She looked at me like I was one of them when I really was being faithful.
Where Did We Go Wrong?
I didn’t understand how a relationship that started off perfect became the exact opposite in just two months. If being faithful was a problem for her, she could’ve suggested it be an open relationship. I would not have had a problem with that. This would’ve erased all the BS.
But I think the real problem was that neither of us knew how to trust much, or how to say honestly what we wanted. If she trusted me to stick around always, she could have been honest with me and told me she didn’t want to see me and only me. If I had trusted her to be honest with me, I could have told her that I knew she was still seeing her ex. In a perfect world, telling each other what we wanted and being honest would have brought us closer. But I didn’t think she could handle that, so I didn’t bother trying.
Still, I liked this girl so much, and I felt we had so much in common, that I really wanted to make it all work out. I was so into her that I lost interest in almost every other woman out there, except Halle Berry, of course.
The Outcome
Eventually I got tired of going through all the drama with her. Dealing with her lying made me stressed. I knew I was good to her, too good to deserve this, although part of me couldn’t be mad at her because all she was doing was putting me through what I’d made other girls deal with. I was now seeing with my own eyes how it felt to be played.
I started thinking that my life was better before, when I messed around with lots of girls. I never argued with any of those girls because we weren’t that close.
So after seven months together, I told her I wouldn’t feel comfortable in the relationship unless she changed. I told her that I knew she lied to me about little things, like what time her curfew was, and if she couldn’t stop doing that then we couldn’t be together.
Giving Up on the Dating Game
She said she was happy with who she was, so there was no changing for her. We ended it like that. However, we still remained friends and we still talk about the few good times we had. We have a much better relationship as friends than we did as lovers. Now we never argue and everything is smooth. I think it’s because we have nothing to hide from each other and nothing to lie about since we’re only friends.
She’s in a new relationship and has told me that she’s playing her new man because he has money. Now I’m sort of back to my old ways, as well. But even though I mess around, I don’t even deal with girls like I used to. Now that I know how it feels to be played. I’ll let girls know from the start that it’s not a relationship, it’s a friendship, or a one night stand, if possible. Even if I did meet a girl who I feel strongly about, I’d rather put all those feelings into a friendship. If one day I ever do get into another relationship, I’d prefer it be an open one. That way, no one has to worry about being lied to.

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.