James Earl Hardy, who wrote for New Youth Connections in the 1980s, is best known as the author of the B-Boy Blues series, which follows the romantic relationship between Raheim “Pooquie” Rivers and Mitchell “Little Bit” Crawford. In Love The One You’re With, the fifth installment in the series, Raheim and Mitchell reach their second anniversary.
The couple’s dealt with everything from jealousy to domestic violence. They’ve weathered their ups and downs, which has helped them maintain and strengthen their love.
In Love The One You’re With, successful model and great dad Raheim begins to forge a career as an actor in Hollywood, leaving Mitchell, who’s a teacher, in New York. Since Raheim is leaving only for the duration of his movie shoot, they both believe they can sustain the long distance relationship.
Has ‘Married Man Syndrome’
But their passionate sex life dwindles away to semi-satisfying, tawdry telephone talk. That doesn’t seem to be enough for Mitchell, who soon has to fight the urge to find comfort in the arms of another.
Everywhere he goes, guys approach him, from a teenage supermarket employee to the parent of one of his pupils. Mitchell chalks it up to “married man syndrome,” where people suddenly become interested in a person who’s spoken for. He’s flattered by the affection and basks in the attention from his array of admirers, but keeps a certain distance.
But there is one guy who gets Mitchell’s eye; jazz singer and UPS worker Montgomery Simms. He shares the same passion for music as Mitchell, and he’s quite attractive. Taking Montgomery up on an invite to hear him sing, Mitchell starts to feel as if Raheim may not be the only guy for him.
Doesn’t Rely on Stereotypes
The novel explores the monotony of monogamy, and explores how difficult it is for men to be devoted to one person only. (The characters have been a bit promiscuous through the series.)
Hardy’s strength is his portrayals of “same-gender-loving” men. His characters are overtly gay. They’re also caring and genuine, with personalities that don’t rely on stereotypes or flamboyance.
Montgomery puts a twist in this tale because he’s bisexual, and Raheim’s sexual preference isn’t clear either. He’s yet to come out to his family, and he has a child with a woman.
I’m left wondering, does Raheim ever intend to tell his family, or is he planning to live a double life forever? It’s clear he likes men, but is Raheim still uncertain of his sexual identity? It’s a question that reflects reality for many.
Anti-White Tone
But the book’s intrigue and liveliness is sometimes lost among the long passages on political and racial topics. The tone seems way too anti-White. I found myself offended, even though I’m not White, since all of the White male characters are written about in a unflattering way.
Hardy’s world also seems, well, too gay. Hardly any characters are straight; it’s as if Mitchell doesn’t come across straight people in his life.
And the musical references are excessive; Hardy constantly mentions songs playing in the background. They’re tunes from an era I can’t relate to. (I don’t know who Phyllis Hyman is, and I vaguely remember Stephanie Mills only because my mom listened to her back in the day.) The songs will connect more with a person in their 30s or 40s, or someone really into jazz.
Mind-Widening Perspectives
Still, Love The One You’re With opened me up to perspectives from gay Black men that I hadn’t considered.
This book is also a great read because it’s not your traditional romance novel formula.
There is no happy ending or Prince Charming that comes to rescue Mitchell. As in real life, there are no answers waiting around the corner, but unresolved feelings that create new emotional dilemmas.
With His Man Away, Will Mitchell Play?
About These Stories
YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.