Paying for the Past

On December 8, 2000, my 15-year-old son was discharged into my custody after spending a long time in a residential treatment center. I thought everything would be good. After all, I had wanted him to come home for so long. But then his anger overwhelmed me.
My children were taken from me on November 6, 1992, because of my drug addiction. My son had a problem with anger all the years he was in foster care and his anger just grew and grew. Mainly he was angry because he was not with the mother who raised him and loved him and because he was separated from his siblings.
He was angry at the system, and he was angry at me, too, because he depended on me and I let him down. I said I would never be like my own mother, who’d neglected her children out of frustration with my father, an alcoholic. But trying to hide the scars of my past, I slipped and allowed myself to fall deep into a life of drug abuse, which in turn hurt my children.
Mad at Me and the System
My son was taken from me when he was 5. He ran away from a foster home for the first time when he was 10 years old and managed to find his way home.
I welcomed him back, because I didn’t want him to be in the system. Unfortunately, police officers came to get my son at 3 a.m. That night he looked at me for comfort and asked, “Mom, why do I have to go with these men?” But he was also mad at me for allowing the authorities to take control of the situation. He felt like as his mom, I should have been able to handle them.
By the age of 12, he was fighting and threatening kids because that anger kept growing. Instead of taking his anger out on the system or me, he took it out on other children.
Ready to Explode
When he was 13, he began to calm down because I was finally succeeding in conquering my drug addiction, and he realized that if his behavior improved, he might have a chance of coming home. He started doing everything that he was told to do-he went to therapy, counseling, and followed the rules at school.
He kept saying that since he was finally coming home, he would behave. In preparation, I attended family therapy with my son and his anger was the topic we discussed most of the time.
For the first few months that my son was home, everything did seem OK. But then, suddenly, my son became very rebellious. He felt he could stay home, not attend school and smoke marijuana. And his anger was explosive. He would push holes in the wall and destroy property in my home. Even when he stayed to himself, I could feel that he was about to explode.
When I tried to tell him that he couldn’t keep behaving this way, he didn’t listen. Maybe he thought he had come home to the same old mother he knew before he was taken from me, the mother who got high and allowed him to do whatever he wished.
Trying to Stay on My P’s and Q’s
I felt so devastated. I tried to remember everything I’d learned in therapy. So even though I was stressed and felt angry and guilty, I stayed on my P’s and Q’s, clean and sober.
I also tried to understand why my son was so angry. He would always say that he missed his sisters who I had lost parental rights for. I told him I would help him telephone them, but he would say, “You’re probably just lying to me like the system did,” then storm away.
Probably, though he didn’t say it, it was also hard for him to be home without the system to put all his anger on. He must have still just felt angry at life, and also at me, and he probably didn’t know what to do with all those feelings.
His anger was also influenced by my eldest daughter, who at the time also lived with me. My daughter was also very angry at me for my past ways. No matter what I said to her in terms of discipline, she wouldn’t listen. The anger she and me son felt toward me independently combined to create a very explosive situation.
Was the System the Answer?
As our home became crazier and crazier, with yelling and even some physical fights, I began to feel very angry at them for not letting me be a parent to them and very guilty, too. Honestly, I felt trapped by my children. At times I seriously thought they were out to get me and were plotting some kind of revenge. Now they were going to make me pay for my past mistakes.
Eventually my son’s rebellion had me so overwhelmed that I thought the system might be the only answer. I really did not want to place him back into care. I’d had to fight too many years to get him back, and I was afraid he would think I was giving up all hope in him. But my main concern now was that my boy was riding on a path to devastation.
So I came up with a compromise. I didn’t ask for my son to go back into care, but I did tell the caseworker honestly some of the problems I’d been having with him.
Time for Tough Love
Eventually the authorities came on their own to pick up my son because of his failure to attend school. My son was convinced that I was responsible. I acknowledged that I had talked to his caseworker, but I also told him that the greatest reason he was going back into care was his rebellious behavior.
That day, as he walked out the door, I held back painful tears and sorrow. I stopped the worker as he was taking my son and said, “Luis, I love you and I’m just trying not to allow the streets to take control of my son the way it took control of Mommy. We’ve tried for a whole year to work on our relationship, but you have your own way of discipline, which does not include me. Now is time for tough love.”
That day I watched out the window while the assigned worker and two counselors put my son in their car. I thought maybe he would look up and glance at me but he didn’t. I understood. What was happening to him was his worst nightmare. It was mine, too. It felt like my past was repeating itself and I was losing one of my babies to the system once again.
Could He Forgive Me?
After my son went back into care, a lot of people let me know that they disagreed with my decision to allow it. Part of me felt so guilty and blamed myself. But I had to tell myself that if I didn’t do it, I would be holding myself hostage for my past mistakes instead of doing what I needed to do for his sake and my sake in the present.
I felt so bad when he was gone, but I had to talk to convince myself that my son going back into care was a way for him to get the discipline he needed. Still, I could not help but think about him. I also hoped that one day he would forgive me.
Then one day, after he had been in care a few months, I was at the home of a close friend. I had heavy thoughts about my son on my mind when the phone rang. My friend handed me the phone. It was Luis.
I was happy but not surprised. I knew that even though my son seemed to hate me, he also loved me. When I got on the phone, I caught myself repeating the same words I had imagined saying to him the night before: “Luis, please understand that I love you and you have to abide by my rules. We tried for a year and nothing changed, so now I we have to try a different way. I cannot help you if you do not tell me what’s wrong.”
He Went AWOL
He replied, “Mom, so how long will it take you to come see me?”
I said, “Well this weekend I want you to do some soul-searching and think things over and I promise you a visit next week.”
Four days went by and there was another ring. It was the social worker. My son had just gone AWOL at a little after 12 that afternoon. I was not surprised. I knew my son was unhappy. Still, I felt heart-broken. I felt like I was losing my son more and more.
A short time later he showed up at my house. I kept trying to talk some sense into his young mind. Finally he said, “Mom, I respect what you are saying, but I still will not be returning to the system. I am going to take care of myself.”
Suffering in the System
I wanted to tell him about all the time I spent “taking care of myself,” when I’d stepped into the streets to see all that life had to offer and got caught up with some wild kids who were dangerously violent at the sound of a heartbeat. I wanted to teach him about the many times I put my life in danger just to get back at my mother. I was angry at her and I wanted her to feel pain, and the only way I knew how to do that was to make myself suffer. I didn’t want my son to suffer because he couldn’t deal with his anger at me.
But he wasn’t going to hear a lecture from me. So I made my last statement. I said, “Luis, you are my son and I am your mother. Just remember I will always love you no matter what circumstances stand in our way. Sometimes we have to let go and let God decide; take that with you. I love you.”
Then I turned and walked in the other direction, hoping he would follow me, but he didn’t. When I looked back he had disappeared.
A month and a half went by without a word from my son. Then one cold night he appeared at my friend’s house. I came to the stairs and saw my son dragging his body up the stairs. I thought he seemed intoxicated-though really I think he was just exhausted. The feelings that came over me made me stand still, numb, not knowing what to say to him. I just stared and had a flashback of my own life as a young girl in the streets.
‘Mom, Do You Love Me?’
My son said to me with a staggering voice, “Mom, I love you, I miss you. Do you love me? What did I do wrong?” He kept repeating these words over and over again. I felt so overwhelmed that I didn’t know what to say or do. Then he said, “Can I have a hug?” I held him close to my body and embraced him with a motherly hug as I cried silently, holding back tears.
I wanted to help my son, but I was in too much pain myself, seeing him this way, and I didn’t want to give in to that feeling and take my son back without any promises that he’d change. Deep within I had decided that it was time to hold him accountable. I asked him to come upstairs and I asked my friend, “Please talk to my son, I cannot stay. I have to go.”
About a week later, I received a call from the preventive worker that my son had requested a meeting. When I arrived, he said to the worker, “I want my mother to give up all her rights to being my mother.” Then he turned to me and said, “So what will it be?”
We’d Make It Work
I just stared at him. I knew he was hurt and angry, but his words also hurt me. I replied, “My son, my rights will terminate the day I die. Until then you are stuck with me.” After that, he stormed out of the office.
After a couple of months he had a court date scheduled. I did not expect him to show up, and he wasn’t there when the judge called us into his chambers. But then, I heard him whisper behind me, “Mom, is it over? What did the judge say?” I looked back at him and he looked frightened.
The worker turned to me and said, “Remember, be calm and talk to him. Tell him how you feel and what you would like from him. I have faith in you.”
The preventive worker talked to my son for a little while. She suggested that I walk and talk to my son. We left the courthouse and I asked him if he wanted to walk alongside me to Chinatown. He agreed.
I said, “My son, I was once your age and if you are trying to compete with the lifestyle I once had a share of, sorry, the trophy still remains on the shelf and it will continue to collect dust. I refuse to pass it down to any of my children.” At first he only said a few words here and there in response, but after a while he broke down and told me what he was up to and of course it was no good. The most painful piece was when he confessed he was sleeping on the train, with no place to go and no one to turn to, just the negative associates he met along the way.
Again I wondered if I should teach him a lesson of tough love. But I knew and still know the dangers of the streets. This time around, I decided, my son and I were going to make it work, even if I died trying.
Getting to Know Each Other
He came home soon after, on March 4, 2002. For the moment, our relationship is better and so is his behavior. Every night when he comes home we talk about how his day went. He says he’s working helping out a friend with cars or distributing fliers. I’m not sure I always believe him. He might be, but he also might just be playing around with his time. Still we’ve made an appointment for him to start a program to get his GED and to get drug counseling, and I hope that will give him some structure in his life.
There are times when he still breaks the rules. In the past, when he left his stuff around the house, I’d get mad, but now I’ve learned not to be bothered. When he breaks other rules, like coming home late or smoking pot, we talk about it and usually he apologizes.
After doing some soul-searching, I’ve also had to realize that there’s a huge gap in our relationship created by those eight years that my son was in foster care. Living with my son is like starting all over again. My son has had to get to know me and I’ve had to get to know my son.
Hurts Take Time to Heal
When parents and children are reunited, both sides usually have to face more than what we bargained for. If you hurt your children before they went into care, they may still have that hurt.
As parents, we have to deal with our children being angry at us for allowing the system to take them away and for failing to be someone they could always rely on. Those feelings do not go away easily. And we also have to deal with the anger we sometimes feel toward our children, even though we don’t want to.
I still worry that my son is being pulled into the fast lane, that he needs yield, slow down, yield. I fear losing my son to the streets. But he has to be willing to make the change himself.
Still, even if it means I have to be tough on him, I am going to continue being there for my son, just like I told him I would.

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.