At 16, I’m proud to be an outspoken young female. But from my days as a toddler, my mouth has caused trouble with my mother.
My mother, who’s originally from Barbados, grew up in a house with six older brothers and five older sisters. Her parents put her on a tight leash, so she had to be very careful about what she said and did. If she attempted to talk back, she’d meet swift punishment from them with the belt.
My father was born in Guyana and grew up under similar rules.
My parents lived separately, and growing up I lived primarily with my mother, spending weekends and school vacations with my father.
Once I was able to pronounce syllables clearly enough for adults to understand, I began to regularly question or refuse to do what I was told.
A Defiant Child
My remarks of “I don’t want to!” and “But why?” bothered my mother and her family, but they thought I was a young child who didn’t know any better. So I wasn’t harshly punished.
But with age, my vocabulary grew, and so did my snappy replies and rude remarks. Once, when I was 6, my mother was speaking to an adult friend of hers who’d dropped by, and I loudly corrected her on the language she used. My mom smacked me on the top of my head and sent me to my room. I felt so embarrassed.
There was another time when we went out and I relentlessly insisted that she buy me a particular pair of sneakers. She did nothing in the store when I was acting up, but when we got home, I sure did get a beating.
Thankfully, my father and his family weren’t that bothered by my speaking out. They found my attitude cute, and if I ever went overboard, they just gave me an uneasy smile to let me know I’d crossed the line. I usually got the point and reined the attitude in.
My Rebellious Attitude
My mother usually punished me when she felt like she was letting me get away with too much or when my talking back was too much to bear. Even though I knew what the consequences could be and was certainly afraid of getting smacked, I still felt like I had to say what was on my mind.
My feistiness partially existed because I wanted to rebel against what I thought were unfair restrictions. There were times when my mouth clearly got out of hand. Once when I was 10, my friends were going out and, of course, I wanted to go with them. My mother wasn’t home yet and my grandmother didn’t want to make the decision herself, so I got upset.
I continued to ask her why and then lashed out.
“I am sick of this house and especially sick of you!” I said loudly. “I just simply dislike you!” Then I went straight out the front door.
I came back 15 minutes later because I loved my grandmother so much and couldn’t believe what I’d said to her. I went to the dining room, where she was, and as I began to say sorry, her belt lashed out at me. It was a little too late to apologize and I understand to this day why she gave me a beating. I stepped way out of line.
Mom Had Similar Attitude
My grandmother must’ve gotten plenty of practice giving beatings to my mother, because, according to her siblings, my mother had quite a mouth also. My aunt told me about a time when my mother got in trouble in primary school. She received a spanking from her teacher for what she felt was no reason. (In Barbados, teachers were allowed to beat the children if they felt the need.)
After her lashes, my mother mouthed off at the teacher and then threw a chair, which didn’t hit anyone. My mother then got more licks from her teacher and another set of lashes from her parents at home. And from what I hear, even though she got a whipping, my mother was still happy that she stood up to the teacher.
My mother gets upset when people tell her that I inherited her mouth. She just argues and says she got out of place growing up only once or twice. But I don’t believe her. She snaps at any and everyone for little things. Her patience is short.
Mom Won’t Admit To Having Sassy Mouth
I think that my mom won’t admit to having a sassy mouth when she was growing up because she fears I might throw it back in her face when she’s attacking my attitude. The closest she gets to admitting it is when she says, “The difference between you and I is I am an adult and you aren’t.”
I thought my mother wanted me to not talk back because she considered it the more ladylike thing to do in front of others. And since she was trained to control it, she thought I should be as well.
And for some years, she got her wish. My mother placed me in a private school in 1st grade, where I was around teachers who seemed to believe that children were there only to listen-no questioning, no debates, no fun. The teachers were strict about how children should conduct themselves, and made me feel like I had to be a neat-freak perfectionist.
I Piped Down More
By the time I turned 8, I’d started to pipe down more at home. My school environment left me feeling like there was something wrong with being outspoken. And I was also tired of dealing with the lashes. But there were times I still spoke up, particularly if I felt very strongly about something.
After 2nd grade, I attended different schools because my mother and stepfather moved around a lot. Even though I met lots of different people, I was afraid to speak up because I feared they wouldn’t like the real me.
By 4th grade, we settled in Canarsie and I enrolled at P.S. 114. School surprised me. On the first day of school, there were so many different people. At the other schools I’d gone to, most of the students were White and not very outspoken.
But this school was filled with all sorts of ethnicities. And personalities. There were quiet children, loud children, brave children, rude children and a whole lot of self-centered children. I could not believe my eyes.
Made Loud Friends
I remained quiet, but made loud friends. I was drawn to them because they were outspoken; in contrast, they enjoyed my silent, cool attitude.
Even though I was beginning to realize that it was OK to be outspoken at school, I still felt pressured to be silent at home.
But, by the age of 12, thanks partially to the influence of my friends, I decided to go with the personality that felt more Ashley-the outspoken one. Of course, that caused a lot of punishments and beatings from my mother, stepfather (who’s also from Barbados) and other adults on my mother’s side of the family.
Had Debates With Teachers
I started showing more of my opinionated self at school. If a teacher was teaching something and I disagreed with her, the class turned into a debating session between me and my teacher.
Unlike my private school instructors, these teachers didn’t discourage my testy attitude. They didn’t seem to mind taking on my continuous questioning and comments.
I also felt free to get into it with my friends. Once, in school around Christmas, I was singing “Joy to the World.” My friend told me that the words I was singing were wrong. We began to argue and then I went to a teacher to prove to her that I was right, and I was. I was glad I’d spoken up. I never liked to be wrong.
People Respected Me, Except Mom
By the time I turned 14, I realized people generally respected me for my snappiness. They saw that I stood firm for what I believed. I listened to adults, but my feelings meant a lot to me and I wanted to speak up on matters that were important to me.
My mother thought I should’ve been far more submissive than I was and listen to her with little feedback. She often talked to me about my friendships with boys. She didn’t want me around guys because she didn’t want me to become a teen mom.
One day, I got tired of the talks and told her that she needed to trust me to do as she said. She began to yell at me and then smacked me. I cried all night because I knew that I was standing up for something that I thought my mother should’ve had for me-trust.
Held Grudge, but Mom Explained Herself
I was pretty upset with my mother after this incident and still hold a grudge. We didn’t spend much time with each other for a while, and I refused to share information about my life with her that I didn’t have to.
But to my surprise, my mother gradually began to understand my perspective. Teachers in high school told her they admired me because they thought that I was such an outspoken and smart student. They said they liked how I stood up to people who tried to make me look stupid.
My father shared with me recently that he sees and saw a powerful attitude in me that he thought was something I needed to survive in the world. He wanted me to be tough, because women are often viewed as the weaker sex.
By my second year of high school, my mother also saw that my attitude could help me. As a sophomore, I found myself talking more with her. We spoke about my outspokeness a lot. She said that she could accept my attitude as long as I didn’t speak out simply because I wanted to be right.
She pointed out that sometimes I was going to be wrong and that I had to accept that. And she added that she was scared that one day my mouth might make it difficult for me to keep a job.
She also shared that she thought I already had a strike against me being a young woman of color, and that a bad attitude was just another stereotypical trait that many expected from me.
Relationship With Mom Improved
At first, I felt confused. I felt like she’d put me through years of hell based on her fears. And I was mad because there were other ways she could’ve tried to shape my attitude other than hitting me. After all, I got the point with my dad without his punishing me harshly.
Had she told me years ago what she told me that day, maybe I would’ve been less feisty since I wouldn’t have felt the need to rebel and we wouldn’t have had to go through all that arguing.
But I soon felt empathy. I realized she was just trying to protect me from the negativity the world may bring my way. I found myself opening up more to her about things that were going on in my life. Plus, we were able to talk in ways that she and her mother weren’t.
Will Be Better for Younger Siblings
I also feel like I’ve broken the ice for my younger siblings. They see that they can have a better relationship with our mother because now she’s up for listening. I’m happy that they can grow up speaking more freely than I could.
I now share many things with my mother, but there are some things I keep to myself because I can’t tell her all my secrets. I’ve also forgiven her for some of the things I went through.
My mom still gets on me about my mouth, but she limits her chastising. And I hold my tongue more than I did as a child because I’ve realized sometimes you have to give others respect and the satisfaction of being right.
Silenced
About These Stories
YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.