(All names and some details have been changed.)
I’ve been the child of divorced parents for almost as long as I can remember. My parents separated when I was 3 years old and were officially divorced by the time I turned 6. My father eventually remarried, and as a result, I’ve been both an only child and a sibling, which has sometimes been a major challenge.
Though the original custody agreement states that I’m supposed to be with my dad every other weekend, every Thursday night and for dinner on Tuesday, I now only see him once a week for dinner due to my busy schedule with gymnastics and school.
My only memory of both my parents and I living in the same house is hiding behind their bed nibbling on fish food while they fought without noticing me. After that, I remember thinking I was of great aid as I “carried” a desk with them from underneath, down the stairs into a moving truck.
We moved from Staten Island to Queens, where each of my parents had an apartment five minutes away from each other by car. I was pleased with the visitations, but sometimes felt lonely and uncomfortable at my dad’s house because I was more accustomed to my mom’s.
At her house, I had my own room, where I was surrounded by the pink and green Minnie Mouse walls and bed sheets I’d chosen. At my dad’s, I slept in the only bedroom, with its plain white walls. The Sesame Street sheets were the only things that were mine.
My dad slept in the living room, and I wasn’t sure if I was taking his bed because he was being nice and didn’t want me to feel like a stranger in his house or because the room was actually mine. I felt bad, like I was stealing from my dad’s comfort. I stuck it out though, because I enjoyed my time with my dad.
Lived as Only Child
I was an only child for three years, never feeling lonely or over-attended to. When I wasn’t playing or talking with my parents, I entertained myself by stretching my imagination to its limits in books and playing dress up.
I also enjoyed spending time with my babysitters watching daytime TV, my favorite show being The Price Is Right. I didn’t miss having more people at home with me because I’d never had them.
Then, when I was 6 and visiting my dad, there were some people over. He reintroduced me to Elizabeth and her daughter Katherine (Kat), who was 9.
Meeting Daniel
I’d met Kat and Elizabeth in years past, because Elizabeth and my dad worked together. I had no idea that there was something going on between my dad and Elizabeth, but everything was made clearer when my dad then introduced me to a baby.
He was just like, “Hi. So here’s your brother. His name is Daniel.”
“HOLY MOTHER OF GOD! I HAVE A BROTHER!” I shrieked.
Dad and Elizabeth shrugged it off. He was nothing new to them. But I was stunned because he was proof that my dad and Elizabeth were not only colleagues, but were also romantically involved.
They’d had Daniel a year before. (Elizabeth had Kat from a different man.) I didn’t meet my dad’s new family for so long because the divorce had yet to be finalized when my brother was born, and my dad feared that if I knew about him, my mom would find out and be able to use his apparent affair in the case.
Excited About New Family…
When I got back to Mom’s, I told her about my new family because I was so excited to have the kind of family I’d seen on TV. She seemed excited for me too, even though now I imagine she was probably angry. Though she didn’t say so at the time, she knew of his affair, so his new family didn’t come as a shock to her.
A couple weeks later, my dad married Elizabeth. He moved into her apartment soon after. And that’s where I visited them every other weekend and on Thursday nights. From then on I would have to learn how to juggle being an only child at my moms, and a visiting half-sister at my father’s.
…But Also Shocked
Now, when I visited my dad, I had a stepmom, sister and brother. It was a shock to suddenly have new members of the family who were supposed to be a full-fledged part of my life.
But I never expressed this shock to anyone because I thought I should be able to handle anything I was going through. I wanted to tough it out alone. I also thought too highly of my dad to question him.
Still, my parents understood that I may have been upset about it, and had me see a psychologist at school. These sessions continued for three years. I don’t remember much about their outcome, but I do remember playing games a lot. The psychologist must’ve been studying my behavior through these games.
Felt Like an Outsider
I didn’t feel at ease at my dad’s for a while. His family was polite to me, but I didn’t feel that they were particularly excited or enthusiastic about me joining the family. No one ever reached out or seemed to want to read or talk to me. This made me reluctant to try to integrate myself with them.
I remember asking for a nightlight when we went to bed each time I visited, and then hearing Elizabeth complain to my dad about my being a baby. “There’s nothing I can’t stand more than a whiner,” she said.
That really hurt me. Elizabeth had made it clear through her actions that she didn’t consider me one of her own, but hearing her actually say something about my irritating her intimidated me and made me scared to speak while at my dad’s.
Hard to Get Along With Siblings
It was also difficult to get along with Kat and Daniel at first because their bond was based on living together, while I only visited. They were very close, and I wanted to be part of their sibling clique.
Daniel idolized Kat, so he listened to her when she told him to say mean things to me, like, “You’re ugly!” or “You’re fat!” I was hurt, because I thought siblings were supposed to be together all the time, even in rivalry, and not gang up on another sibling.
But later that year, we took a one-week family trip to the Dominican Republic, where my dad’s from. I’d been going at least once a year for my whole life, so I was used to taking the trip. Still, I was sad to leave my mom, and nervous about being with my dad’s new family for a whole week.
Seen as ‘Real’ Family Abroad
I was surprised by the reaction we got. That week, we appeared to be a normal family to everyone we met. Elizabeth is very light-skinned, like me. Daniel is dark, like my dad, and Kat is perfectly in the middle.
It was surprising but understandable when strangers asked Elizabeth about her daughter in reference to me, or did the same with my dad and stepsister. I grew accustomed to us being perceived by strangers as a “regular” family of two parents and three kids.
That was unlike here, where everyone I met seemed aware of our four-parent (my mom and dad, Elizabeth and Kat’s dad), not-totally-related deal. I often felt overlooked as a real family.
Thankfully, feeling like a traditional family in the Dominican Republic made Kat and I behave more warmly towards each other. Once I was closer to Kat, Daniel didn’t have so many mean things to say and Elizabeth was nicer to me.
Back to Being Only Child
When we returned home, it was back to my mom’s for me and to being an only child. Even though I liked having siblings, and cared about them very much, I still enjoyed being alone with my mom.
She was a great playmate too! We played lots of theater games because she’d been an actress. We also played board games (my favorite was Disneyland) and read.
And when she was busy, I entertained myself. I liked, and still do like, having my own space. I especially enjoyed my freedom to have peace and quiet or to create chaos by blasting music if I liked.
Accepted as a Sibling
When I was at my dad’s, I shared a room with Kat and we watched TV together, which helped break the ice between us. After we became closer, Kat and I behaved the way I thought sisters should, telling stories and giving advice, playing around with cosmetics and having secrets.
As Daniel got older and grew beyond teething and rubber balls, we played Gameboy and card games, and watched Nickelodeon together.
I felt accepted and confident as part of a sibling unit. Though I was spending more time with Kat and Daniel, I still spent a lot of time with my dad. Not only did we meet once a week separately from his family for dinner, we also worked on projects together on the weekends, like when we made a little go-cart.
Best of Both Worlds
By the time I was 8, I felt comfortable in each situation and believed I was getting the best of both worlds. I had siblings to talk to and be around, while also having space to myself.
When Kat entered adolescence, she told me exciting stories about being a big bad teenager. I eagerly listened to her boy problems, envisioning myself as cool as her in the years to come. She sometimes did my hair and then I went home to my mom feeling all grown up.
And when I thought I was getting too old to play Daniel’s games (though I’m never really too old for games), I still played with him because it made me feel like I was fulfilling my duty as an older sister. I was giving my brother the attention he deserved and assuring him that he could depend on me.
Religious Differences
Once I was closer with the siblings, Elizabeth was more accepting of me. I tried extra hard to have at least one good conversation with her each time I visited. Still, there were some major differences in our lifestyles.
While I was raised Jewish by my mom, Daniel and Kat were raised Christian. Sometimes when I visited them for the weekend, Elizabeth wanted to go to church with the family, and either Kat or my dad stayed home with me.
The family always said grace before meals and I felt silly putting my head down because the prayer didn’t mean anything to me. And each Christmas brought about some low blow about how I didn’t celebrate.
Put Down at Christmas
I remember one year when Elizabeth talked to Daniel about me in a sing-songy voice, saying “She doesn’t really celebrate Christmas because she just doesn’t know what it’s about.”
I pretended I was invisible and stared straight ahead before she noticed that my eyes were filling up with tears. I said nothing because I wanted to disregard the wounding words I heard from my stepmother’s mouth.
One year, the entire family’s most treasured gift was a beautiful gold cross pendant from Elizabeth.
I remember sitting there while everyone admired their crosses, burying my face in my stocking and saying to myself “Woohoo! Bootleg batteries!” hoping that I’d seem as excited to have received batteries as they did their crosses. This was my frail attempt to crush the slowly growing lump in my throat because I knew I’d never be the same as everyone else in the family.
Try to Ignore Obstacles
But I’ve tried to ignore episodes like these. I don’t want to let our religious differences be an obstacle in the development of my relationship with anyone in the family. I feel privileged to have family in my life, so it’s important to me to stay connected.
I continued traveling back and forth between my parents’ homes until I was about 13, but the visits to my dad’s started to taper off after I turned 9. As the years went by, I had less time at home because I got busy with gymnastics and school, so I saw my dad less, which meant I also saw Kat, Daniel and Elizabeth less.
Now, at 16, I only get to see them on holidays and if I go on the annual family vacation. In the past three years, I’ve gone on only two vacations with Dad’s family.
Less Connected
This makes me really sad, particularly not seeing my siblings. While most siblings have the privilege of living together for their entire lives as young people, I have to work extra hard to maintain our relationship.
When I saw Kat and Daniel this past Thanksgiving and Christmas, I was so psyched to see them. I hadn’t seen them since June. We usually don’t speak unless we’re together, but every few months I’ll speak to them on the phone or online.
But from the moment they picked me up in the car, I felt like there was nothing to say. There wasn’t enough knowledge of one another’s current lives to catch up on, and my fear of intruding overcame any desire to ask what was new.
Will We Talk as Adults?
Sometimes I question if we’ll talk as adults, not because we may not want to, but because not talking for such lengths makes the few times when we do see each other awkward.
However, I believe the likelihood of that is small, simply because we are siblings. I force myself to be confident that the familial connection will keep us together.
But it’s not easy. I think that though they consider me their sister, since I’ve always been the one visiting and coming to them, I’m expected to do the work of maintaining the relationship. So even though they want to maintain our bond, it’s my job to make it happen.
It frustrates me that this is left in my hands because they can call or e-mail me any time, and Kat could arrange to see me if she tried. But I don’t think that ending my efforts is worth ending our relationship.
Regardless of what happens in the future, I feel that I’ve had the best of two worlds: that of the middle child and that of the only child. Though it’s an uncommon sibling relationship that Kat, Daniel and I have, I cherish it close to my heart.
Family Ties
About These Stories
YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.