Looking for Maturity

Names have been changed.
As I’ve gotten older and reached the ripe old age of 17, I’m finding my relationships may be starting to have a theme. My last two boyfriends have been considerably older than I am. Not dirty-old-man old, but 22 and 23. I’m not the only one; a few of my other classmates and friends have older boyfriends and some are even engaged.
In some ways, the age of my boyfriends has affected my relationships, but there were problems that I had with them that I don’t blame entirely on age.
First Boyfriend My Age
I’ve only had three boyfriends. My first, Leap, was the same age as I was. We met when we were 16. Leap went to an all-boys school and I met him at one of his school parties. He called me and we got to know each other.
Everything was nice in the beginning. Simple things he did impressed me, like meeting me at my school or giving me cards with cheesy poems signed “Love, Leap.” We also went to movies.
But, now that I think about it, we didn’t have any deep conversations. I didn’t want to talk about basketball statistics and hip-hop lyrics, or sit through some stupid film like Scary Movie. If I suggested something different, like a movie that didn’t contain slapstick and farting, he acted as if I was suggesting we do something outrageous.
Other things I found interesting struck him as ho-hum or difficult. Sometimes I felt like I had to dumb myself down just for the sake of our conversations.
I started to do a lot of listening instead of talking, and pretended to be interested in what he was saying. But I didn’t like holding back my thoughts and feelings. After a while, I grew tired of our empty talks. We both decided the relationship was over after six months.
I came to the conclusion that we had little in common to begin with and that I was more mature than he was, even though we were the same age. But I still wasn’t looking for someone older to get with next. I was just looking for someone more mature.
I didn’t associate age with maturity; I figured there are plenty of older guys who act like they’re 12, can’t hold a conversation and won’t return calls. I just wanted someone I could talk and relate to.
Saw Boys Acting Silly
But after my relationship with Leap, I paid closer attention to boys who looked my age at school, on the street or at parties. I became increasingly disgusted with how they acted. I would see them standing around, not doing anything but cracking jokes on people who passed by.
While waiting in line at one party I went to, I couldn’t believe how rowdy a group of guys were acting. They were jumping on cars, drinking cheap liquor-just acting stupid. The party was almost canceled because they wouldn’t calm down.
I’m not saying that all 16- and 17-year-old guys act stupid and immature, but at the time, that’s all I saw. I even began to feel like I was acting too old or stuck up.
Met Pablo
Then I met a tall, bulky guy named Pablo at the train station near my house. He approached me and told me that he remembered seeing me on a specific street. We started to talk. I liked the way he spoke, so I had no problem giving him my number.
When Pablo told me on the phone he was 22, I was surprised. I’d thought that he was my age, just with some sense.
I was hesitant to start dating him because he was six years my senior. I thought he might try to take advantage of me because of my age. Or that he thought I’d get with him because he could buy me things I couldn’t afford. Or that he only wanted sex.
Despite my reservations, we went out to the movies. Later, we talked about college, our plans for the future, and other subjects Leap never touched on. I was so happy I was able to talk to him without him saying something I considered dumb.
Started to Date
We began to date, and in the beginning, everything was fine. He always returned my calls, unlike Leap, and he took me out to dinner at nice restaurants, not pizza places. Not to say that Leap was cheap; he just didn’t know much about anything outside of his neighborhood.
Pablo made more money than Leap and therefore could afford nice restaurants, but it wasn’t how much he spent that impressed me. It was the kind of places we went, which indicated his level of awareness.
But about four months into the relationship, he became very untrusting of me. He scanned numbers in my cell phone and questioned me about numbers with male names. He constantly called me to make sure I was where I said I’d be.
Put Up With His Jealousy
He didn’t even like me to be around my friends, because he said that they were nosy and never liked him. My friends were skeptical of Pablo’s intentions, but they weren’t around him enough that he should’ve been so sure they were against him.
“Why is it that every time I see you, you have to look in my phone? All the incoming calls are from you,” I asked him.
“Well, if you don’t have anything to hide, then it shouldn’t bother you,” he said. So I didn’t say anything, even though it did bother me that he was constantly trying to catch me doing something wrong.
Scared I’d Leave Him for Younger Guy?
I think a big reason he didn’t trust me was because I was younger than he was. It might’ve been that he was just a jealous guy, but it seemed like he thought I was going to leave him for someone younger when he said things like, “Yeah, I gotta watch out for all those young guys outside your school.”
I felt like walking around or going shopping with my friends was in some way wrong. When I did go with them somewhere, I didn’t tell him because I knew it would turn into a huge argument.
After a year together, I ended our relationship because he couldn’t trust me. After our breakup, I decided that I’d let him take advantage of me by being afraid to tell him how much I disliked his insecurities. I wondered if I listened to and put up with him because he was older.
Hesitated About Dating Another Older Guy
I met my next boyfriend, Jay, a month later at the Gap. I figured Jay was 18, but he turned out to be 22. His age made me hesitate, particularly after Pablo. I knew any guy could be jealous, but I felt that older guys are more likely to be jealous so I’m still skeptical of Jay, and don’t want to let things that bother me go like I did with my ex.
Sometimes I feel as if I’m boring Jay when I talk about prom or graduation. When I ask him if he’s bored, he says he isn’t, but just doesn’t have the same level of excitement I have about those things. He’s past that point in his life, so what’s exciting for me is “been there, done that” for him.
But, for the most part, so far, so good. We’ve been together for two months. Jay seems a little more my speed. Even though he’s older than I am, he seems to be more relaxed than Pablo and not as crazy as other guys.
Gap in Experiences
Even though my current boyfriend is older than I am, older guys aren’t my preference. I simply prefer someone I can relate to and who can relate to me. If I found a guy my age who I could relate and talk to, then there’d be no problem.
I know, sooner or later, I’ll be around guys my age who I’ll like. I suspect this will probably happen in college, because there, I’ll be in classes with guys who have the same interests as I do.

SIDEBAR: What Older Guys Want
(All names have been changed.)
I asked a few guys in their early 20s about why they like younger girls and why they think younger girls like them. Roman, 23, said he likes to get sexually involved with girls who are 17 or 18 because, “they look fresher and have better bodies.” He thinks they like him because as an older guy, he’s more mature and more experienced. J.R. said he believes that younger girls like older guys because, “We are more mature, perform better and have more money.” Martin said he likes girls 18 or 19 because “they haven’t been touched.” Similarly, J.R. said that he could “take advantage of them, trick and lie to them and . . .raise them.” I think this is a very negative way to think about dating younger girls because I don’t think you should go out with somebody you don’t respect. Thankfully, not all the guys I talked to were looking for young girls to manipulate. Ben, 26, said that “Age is nothing; it’s how mature a female is. If a girl is younger and acts older, that’s what counts.” And one guy I interviewed even said he likes older women. “When I go somewhere, I want to know she is taking care of my money, kids and my house, and that’s what I want to do for her as well,” he said. That’s interesting because I think that’s what a lot of girls I know want in an older guy.

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.