Younger Girls/Older Guys: I Want to Be Taken Care Of

Names have been changed.
I’ve observed that many girls like guys who are a few years older than they are. Many girls, including myself, are attracted to older guys because they seem more mature than guys our age.
One reason is the way we see guys our age presenting themselves. My friends and I think that many boys still in high school tend to look sloppy, as if they don’t care about anyone or anything. That’s not appealing.
Another reason is that guys out of high school tend to have jobs, and so have money to buy their girls gifts and to take them places. Boys who go to school often don’t have jobs, so if they have any money, it’s probably from their allowance.
I don’t want to have a guy ask me to go to a movie and then ask me to pay for it myself. My friends and I feel that for that, we can go out with our friends and not worry about the pressure of being on a date.
Looking for a Father Figure?
Some girls I know like the “show and tell” of being with an older guy. They like to walk around their friends with their “man,” then talk about him with their friends when he leaves. They talk about how cute he is and what he gives them or doesn’t give them. They rate his sexual performance or, if they’re not having sex, his kissing skills. I guess some girls show off guys their own age as well, but I’ve never seen a girl show off her “boy.”
I’ve been with two guys who were more than three years older than me. I met Tony when I was 15 and he was 19. More recently, I went out with Bobby, who I met through friends in the neighborhood. He’s 25-eight years older than I am.
I’ve heard some people say that girls who go with older guys are looking for a father figure. Maybe that’s true in my case, because I was raised with no father and have no brothers. And though I’m a strong-willed person, I sometimes like it when my “man” tells me what to do, like when to go home and how to dress. If what he wants me to wear is too expensive, though, I also want him to buy me clothes.
Controlling, Not Abusive
I’m OK with wanting a control freak as long as he’s not abusive when I don’t do what he wants. I guess I’m impressed if someone can both show he’s mad at me and control his anger by not becoming physical.
I’m not sure why I don’t want to have more power in my relationships with guys. I guess it’s because being controlled makes me feel cared for. I think I’d feel weird if a guy asked me what I wanted to do or where I wanted to go because I’ve never dealt with a guy who wasn’t controlling. A younger guy could try to tell me what to do but my feeling about that is, “How’s he gonna control me if he’s controlled by his mother?”
But telling me what to do isn’t the only thing a guy can do to make me feel cared for. If a guy shows interest in talking to me, rather than just sleeping with me, then that also makes me feel he cares for me.
Not Ready to Settle Down
And sometimes guys can get carried away with bossy behavior. Bobby, the oldest guy I’ve been with, wanted to know where I was and what I was doing when I wasn’t with him. At first, I was impressed by his interest and felt that he must really care about me. But he was soon acting like that all the time, and it started to bother me. That’s one of the reasons we’re not going out anymore.
Even though I’m attracted to older guys because I think of them as more mature, sometimes the age difference leads to different expectations about the relationship. Bobby also talked a lot about having a family with me. He was ready to settle down, but I wasn’t ready for that.
And sometimes older guys don’t act any more mature than younger guys. My friend Sandra is also into older guys. A year ago, when she was 15, an 18-year-old guy who sold drugs on her block began to talk to her every night before she went home. She said she was attracted to him because he had game. “Something about the way he walked,” she said. He was bad and the both of them knew it.
When they started going out, she liked being known as his girl. But he never took her anywhere, and that bothered her. There goes the idea that an older guy will take a girl out. I had that problem with Tony, too. I felt that he was embarrassed to be seen with me, perhaps because I was too young.
We Want the Respect
Now Sandra’s man is in jail and he expects her to wait for him. But that’s not her plan. Now that she’s 16, she shows some interest in guys her own age as well as those older than she is. I noticed, in my friend’s case, that an older guy may be a smoother talker and dress better, but that doesn’t mean he’ll have much respect for the younger girl he goes out with.
Even though my friends and I prefer older guys, we also need to remember that just because they’re older, it doesn’t mean they’ll act more mature or more grown-up. And if a guy’s too embarrassed to be seen with his girl because she looks too young, then he should find a girl his own age.

SIDEBAR: Cause for Concern?
I interviewed Angela Maresca, a physician’s assistant and counselor at Vanguard HS, about why girls go out with guys who are sometimes several years older than they are.
CL: How often do you hear about girls under the age of 18 finding themselves attracted to men past 20?
AM: Very often. I think it’s more common now. It’s one of the biggest problems we see and all heath-care providers are concerned about.
CL: What do you think these girls see in older guys?
AM: They like guys with money and sexual experience and they think it’s cool. CL: What kind of girls tend to have this attraction to older men?
AM: Girls who don’t have strong father figures and have issues within their family and with their moms most of the time.
CL: What’s the statistic of this happening? And how many get pregnant?
AM: Anecdotally, girls who have older partners are at higher risks for STDs and pregnancy.
CL: Do any of these girls talk to a parent or guardian about what they’re feeling?
AM: Not usually; they tend to keep it a secret because their parents would disapprove.
CL: What advice do you give these girls?
AM: To use protection and especially if they’re going to have sex with an older guy, to use condoms. I try to encourage them to go into counseling to find out why they like these older guys.

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.