Abused mom speaks out
Sharwline Nicholson, one of the mothers who brought a lawsuit against the city for taking their children away because of domestic violence, spoke recently at a meeting of the Child Welfare Organizing Project, an organization of birth mothers working to change the child welfare system. Here’s her story:
My younger child’s father came by my apartment one afternoon. He questioned me about rumors that I was with another man, and he became violent. He fractured my ribs, injured my head and broke my arm. I called 911 and an EMS crew came. I left my daughter with a neighbor, who said she’d pick my son up after school. Then I went to the hospital.
Several detectives were there and I gave them the names of relatives my children could stay with. But the next day I got a message: “Miss Nicholson, we have your kids. If you want them you have to report to court on Friday.” They told me they’d filed a neglect petition against me for engaging in domestic violence.
I had no idea where my children were, nothing. When I appeared in court on Friday, the ACS worker was very friendly and wanted to know about the case, but I didn’t want to talk. My arm was in a cast and I was in psychological pain. I wanted to know where my kids were.
My case was postponed because I didn’t have a lawyer yet. After that I went to criminal court to get a restraining order but I couldn’t because my child’s father lived out of state and I didn’t know his address. I went back to court a couple of days later, and the judge ordered ACS to parole my kids to me, but ACS told me I had to find a new address to bring them to. [According to court documents, ACS believed it wouldn’t be safe to return the children to Sharwline’s Brooklyn address in case the child’s father came there again, especially because the original report to the state said he’d had a gun.]
I decided to stay with my cousin in the Bronx. My cousin’s apartment is really small but I didn’t have money. Who else was I going to turn to? After that, I thought ACS would let my kids come home, but they dragged their feet. They said, “Now you need bedding. You need this. You need that.” It was 21 days after they took my children that they let them come back.
But ACS still wanted more visits. My cousin’s place is very small, and I began to take my children to my mother’s house to get out of my cousin’s way. ACS said they visited and tried to reach me on a number of different occasions. When they couldn’t, they put out a warrant for my arrest.
But when I saw my children after they’d been in the foster home, my son had a puffy eye that he said he’d gotten from his foster mother slapping him, and my daughter had scratches and mucus dripping from her nose. I said, “No, you’re not getting my kids again,” and I sent them to my father in Jamaica.
But when I went to the post office to get my mail, two detectives were waiting for me. They put handcuffs on one arm. The other was in a cast. They took me across the street and tried to intimidate me into telling them where my children were. I was not going to tell, because I knew my kids were secure.
I was brought to Brooklyn Family Court. The judge told me to appear in court in another two weeks. I had gotten myself a good lawyer, and after that hearing, I was allowed to return to my Brooklyn apartment with my children. In August, the case against me was dismissed.
Our case is being tried by civil rights lawyers. We want ACS to realize that they can’t deal with all cases the same, and that they need better training for their case workers. The judge has agreed with us that the city needs a lot of practices changed. I figured that by bringing the case, I would be a voice for the many women who are scared to death of the city, and are scared that if they talk about their abuse, they’ll have their children taken away.
Taking on the City
About These Stories
YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.