In April 2000, a group of women brought a lawsuit against New York’s Administration for Children’s Services to change the way they treat mothers who are victims of domestic violence. They said ACS came in and yanked their kids from them instead of helping them get out of their own bad situation.
ACS said this wasn’t so. They said they took children from their mothers when the mothers weren’t willing or able to remove themselves and their children from a violent situation. But this winter the courts agreed with the mothers and barred ACS from taking children solely because the mother was beaten by her spouse or boyfriend.
One of the mothers, Ms. Sharwline Nicholson, 33, was charged with neglect after she was severely beaten by her daughter’s father [see story, page 6]. Their 1-year-old daughter lay in a crib in the room during the attack. Afterward, Nicholson called 911, left her daughter with a neighbor, and went to the hospital. The next day, ACS officials told her her children were already in foster care. After she was given her children back, she and her lawyer decided to sue the city.
During the trial, ACS argued that witnessing violence hurts children. And that’s true. I watched my mother be beaten, and it made me feel useless and hopeless. In my case, the government never stepped in. I still feel horrible that nothing was done to stop that travesty from continuing.
Always a Good Mother to Me
ACS also says that if a mother cannot protect herself from being beaten, she’s unlikely to protect her children from abuse. And studies have found that in homes where mothers are abused, as many as 60% of children are also beaten.
So domestic violence does hurt a child. But so can getting taken from your home. My mother was the most important person in my life. She needed help to get away from my father, but I needed her. If I had been taken from her, I would have been devastated. It seems to me that ACS doesn’t think enough about the psychological effect on children of being snatched from their homes and put into strangers’ homes. Sometimes this just adds trauma to trauma.
Since the case was brought, ACS has begun to train child protective workers how to better investigate cases where there’s a problem of domestic violence, so they can do a better job deciding when’s the right time to remove a child. I think that’s a good place to start.
Help Moms, Don’t Punish Them
So far, though, the court isn’t convinced that that’s enough. They say that too many kids go into care when their mothers could be helped with them at home. They also say that once kids are in care, moms don’t get enough help from child welfare or from the legal system to get their kids and their lives back together again.
I agree. Sometimes moms fail to do their jobs as mothers and instead put their men first. But other times there’s just so many reasons that women don’t leave an abusive situation-like they’re emotionally or financially dependent on that man.
They Need Shelter And Support
Sometimes women need counseling to get the confidence to leave the situation they’re in. Sometimes they need a place to go. Women and children are turned away from shelters every day. Sometimes they need work and educational opportunities to help them become more independent. Sometimes women stay because everyone who’s ever been in their lives has told them that that’s what they’re supposed to do. Because a mother comes from a culture with those values doesn’t necessarily make her an unfit mother.
As for the men, sometimes what they need is some time in jail and to be out of the children’s lives altogether. Many fathers need some serious help and counseling themselves.
Maybe some mothers won’t be helped. But other mothers will. If those mothers got more help first instead of after their kids were removed, more kids would be able to stay out of the hectic system.
Don’t Add Trauma to Trauma
About These Stories
YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.