The first church I remember attending was a Catholic church, St. Brigid’s. My mother took me there every Sunday. We got dressed up nice and neat. I loved to wear dresses as a child, so I looked forward to going to church.
I was too young to remember much of what they talked about, other than some stuff about Christ, saints and the Virgin Mary. But I remember how beautiful the church was because there were pictures of saints on the church’s windows, and I liked the smell of the candles and incense.
I also attended St. Brigid’s Catholic school, which was connected to the church. But I didn’t like my 2nd grade teacher, and switched to public elementary school.
Going to a New Church
Around the same time, St. Brigid’s stopped giving English services and had only Spanish services during Sunday morning worship. So we changed churches as well, because my mom and I don’t speak Spanish.
Our new church, Immaculate Conception, was also a Catholic church. I began to attend Sunday school there. And sometimes after the main Sunday service, I went with another girl from church to a special service for praying to Mary.
I liked Sunday school because I thought it was important to learn the Bible and understand where we come from. I loved listening to stories about Jesus.
I Didn’t Understand Confession
But I didn’t like repenting, or confession, because I didn’t understand why I was doing it. The Bible study teacher made it seem like I had to repent or I would go to hell. At least that’s how I felt.
I went to confession about once a month. We left Sunday school class and stood on a line to a room where a priest was waiting so we could confess to him.
When I went to confession, I didn’t know what to say to the priest. I had to sit there and come up with all my sins of the month, but I couldn’t remember everything I did wrong. I didn’t even know what counted as a sin and what didn’t, so I wasn’t sure what I needed to confess.
The priest didn’t tell me what I could do to make me a better person; he just told me to recite a few prayers to a picture of Jesus hanging in the hallway outside my classroom. If we said the prayers, we’d get rid of our sins.
I knew some kids who thought it was OK to be bad because, at confession, they could just tell the priest their mistakes and God would forgive them. I did that too, but I didn’t like how it seemed too easy to be excused for all the bad things I might’ve done.
In addition to all my Catholic training, I went to a Baptist after-school program
connected to a Baptist church called Graffiti Baptist ministry. My mother put me in this program when I was 6 because all the neighborhood kids were in it.
There I also learned about the Bible, but we didn’t focus on Mary or the saints. We focused on Jesus and how we need to live for and pray to him only.
By 7th grade, I was attending the program’s all-girls junior high Bible study group twice a week. There, I became more aware of the differences between Catholic and Baptist teachings.
I started to think about one of the Ten Commandments that states, “I am the Lord thy God. Thou shalt have no other gods before me.” To me this is saying, “I am the only person you have to answer to and you should not pray to anyone but me.”
That made me question the Catholic practice of praying to Mary. I didn’t feel like I was praying to another god when I prayed to Mary; I just felt wrong praying to Mary when I could’ve been praying directly to God, or Jesus.
I know Mary did a great thing and was chosen to have baby Jesus, but I thought about how God could’ve picked another virgin to have the baby.
Are Saints Idols?
I also asked myself, “Is it wrong to pray to saints?” From what I read in my Baptist Bible study group, it seemed clear that one rule was not to pray to idols. Catholics pray to saints for many specific things, like praying to St. Anthony when you lose something.
My mother does it and it seems to work for her, but in the 7th grade, I decided it didn’t work for me. I’d done it myself and eventually found what I was looking for, but I prayed to God when I lost things and still found them.
So I didn’t think St. Anthony had anything to do with it. Plus, I’ve never lost anything in a place that I wouldn’t eventually look.
I also thought about how the Bible says “confess to one another.” To me, that means you and whomever you talk to about God should tell each other your sins so you can talk about ways you can help yourself and have the willpower not to do those things anymore.
Priests don’t tell you their sins, so there goes the “one another.” I got more out of the Baptist group’s discussions about how to be a better person than I did from confession at my Catholic church.
Mom’s Not Thrilled
So I decided to convert to the Baptist church. After I made my mind up, I told my mom, “I’m going to join Graffiti.”
“You’re what?” she said.
“I’m going to join Graffiti and be Baptist,” I said.
“No, you’re not!” My mother didn’t want me to go to a Baptist church since my whole family followed Catholicism.
I was still in the Catholic church and about to make my confirmation, which is one of the seven sacraments of Catholicism. I told her that she could make me go to her church, but that wouldn’t make me believe in Catholic practices, and that I was old enough to make my own decisions.
She told me “No,” but then realized she couldn’t make me believe in a religion that didn’t seem right to me. And she was the one who put me in the Baptist after-school program.
Confirmation Compromise
So we compromised. She told me that she’d let me convert if I finished my confirmation; I was almost done with my confirmation class anyway.
I was upset that she wanted me to continue practicing Catholicism, but I also understood where she was coming from. Plus, both religions are forms of Christianity, so I stayed in the Catholic church for the rest of the year.
By the end of 8th grade, I’d been confirmed as a Catholic. Now I was able to become a Baptist.
When it came time for my baptism, I was nervous, but my mother came with my two little sisters to see me baptized.
The church I got baptized in wasn’t my familiar Graffiti Baptist but its mother church, Metro Baptist. It’s a pretty church with big windows like my old Catholic church and is as big as a Catholic church. Our church meets in a basement of a building and doesn’t look like much.
Scared of Making the Wrong Decision
I remember my baptism clearly. It was my second baptism; the first had been when I was a baby, in the Catholic church.
I don’t remember the first time, but this time, I was nervous because I was scared I was making the wrong decision. I knew that I didn’t want to be a Catholic, but what if in a few years I didn’t want to be Baptist either? Still, I felt I was Baptist because I was old enough to understand the differences between the two.
My pastor, Taylor Fields, baptized me. We both wore long white robes that stopped at our ankles. He introduced me to the church, saying my name and telling everyone that I was being baptized. I was hidden so that I could see only him; he was standing in a tub of water.
The tub reminded me of a public pool in which people tend to pee, so before I put one of my hands on his arm and the other hand on my nose, I whispered to him, “Don’t pee in the water.”
He didn’t say anything, but his face got red. Then he dunked me and I was baptized. I told my mother what I said after I put on dry clothes and she laughed.
One Family, Two Churches
I’ve been a member of my church for about four years now and I respect the people there. I appreciate my youth group, where we sit and talk about things we’re doing wrong and help each other try to do right with good advice.
Now my house is funny on Sunday mornings, because I go to Graffiti while my mother takes my two little sisters to Immaculate Conception. Afterwards, we meet back home, and then we go out to our favorite restaurant, Apollo, where they serve Spanish and Chinese food.
My mother and sisters get dressed up for church, but my church is casual. It works for me, because I’m not into wearing dresses anymore. Pants, like my church, are more fitting for who I am now.
Making Up My Own Mind
About These Stories
YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.