Turned Off By Teen TV

Teen-related shows are all over TV; the entire WB line-up, for instance, is aimed at teenage viewers. Shows like Dawson’s Creek and Roswell supposedly reflect our rebellious teenage years. But are these shows realistic?
TV teens tend to be consumed with romance, when in reality we’re focused on so much more, like jobs, education and family issues. How many times do you see a character who works so hard she rarely gets enough sleep? Practically never. How many times do you see that in real life? A lot.
Many Real Teens Work
Like my friend Tanya, who works at a Brooklyn library, and Allajah, who works at K-Mart, many teens have jobs after school and on weekends. Some people like me have internships lasting six hours a day, plus the commute. And then there’s schoolwork.
It’s rare to see TV characters doing the work of everyday life. And TV teens rarely face cultural or religious tensions, or live in poverty or foster care.
Supernatural Teen Struggles
I can understand the recently popular supernatural shows, such as Dark Angel, not being realistic, since they’re about superheroes and aliens and vampires and witches.
Sabrina the Teenage Witch, an obvious teen-oriented show, got the ball rolling in 1996, followed by Buffy the Vampire Slayer (1997) and its spin-off, Angel. The WB had so much success with the last two shows that it aired more like them, like Roswell, and this season’s new entry, Smallville.
These superhero-like characters find themselves struggling to both save the world and be a normal teen. Even though I highly doubt I’ll fall for a 240-year-old vampire, I can relate to the struggles of the teen protagonists to fit in. I also enjoy these types of shows for the action, the drama and the paranormal beings.
Fun, Dumb Comedies
I can also understand when comedies like Popular, That 70’s Show and Undeclared aren’t realistic. For example, Popular’s Mary Cherry, who’s crazed about fashion and beauty, had plastic surgery on her lips, but they ended up almost four times their natural size. It was really funny; she’s such a half-wit, I can’t help but laugh at her remarks and actions.
Even though the portrayal of comedy teens as dumb bothers me sometimes, it’s obvious that it’s unrealistic. Because Popular is so over the top, it’s understood that the show isn’t closely based on real life.
Growing Up With Full House
Although silly comedies were my first favorite teen shows-I was a TGIF follower when I was 9-as I grew older, I liked shows like Full House, which seemed more truthful about life.
I could relate to Stephanie Tanner, the middle child who felt she didn’t get enough attention. After my brother was born, I felt the same way.
I also appreciated the high school plots on comedies like Saved by the Bell and Boy Meets World.
The first of the straight dramatic teen shows I got into, when it premiered on WB in 1998, was Dawson’s Creek. I enjoyed it because the characters were around my age and spoke intelligently.
Tired of Boy Meets Girl
But I started to realize that after the first season, I didn’t relate to Dawson anymore. The second season didn’t have the clever twists and turns of the first.
Worse, the theme of boy gets girl, boy loses girl, boy chases girl, and boy gets girl again has been repeated for the last three seasons. I mean, seriously, how many times can Dawson and Joey break up and get back together?
Dawson and other shows, like Felicity, spend so much time basing each episode on love and relationships that they forget the other aspects of life. What about fitting in with school cliques or the stress of deciding which college you want to go to? (Yes, I’m speaking from personal experience.)
These shows should reflect a range of growing-up experiences, but many of those problems are out of sight.
What Happened to College?
In Felicity, for example, the frustration of college work isn’t shown nearly as often as Ben and Felicity breaking up. The first season, Felicity was getting adjusted to New York City and school. This gave us a peek at her college experience, like when she dropped pre-med to major in art. Or when she and her friends crammed for midterms.
But soon, the college plots became less important because of her suddenly all-consuming love life. Ben, Felicity and Noel’s love triangle quickly became the centerpiece of the show. Even the last episode I saw, in November, had Felicity afraid to tell Ben that she cheated on him with Noel, which is how the second season began.
Then, it was a fun concept; I wanted to know who she’d end up with. Now, it’s the fourth season and we’re there again.
Trying to Get Respect
Similarly, Dawson’s dream of becoming a film director, which was important in the show’s first season, lost out to the infamous love triangle between him, Joey and Pacey.
This season’s premiere was our first look at his experience as a film major with an internship. But that plot died when he got fired that very episode for speaking up for himself when the director, his boss, acted like a jerk.
I enjoyed that scene. Finally, a teen show showed the struggle of a teenager to get respect in the “real world.”
These are problems we face when we make important decisions in our lives. And these are the kinds of problems I want to see more of on TV.
Dawson 90210
Obviously, romance is an essential part of a show. Viewers tune in to see which characters have gotten together. Even I enjoy that. But it becomes really old when you have the same scenario on every show.
Look at Beverly Hills 90210, which started as a teen drama and became a soap opera, and see the similarities between it and Dawson’s Creek. They’re both based on a group of friends, with several characters in tangled relationships with each other.
The main character of both shows fought over a girl with his best friend, which caused friction in the friendship (Dawson and Pacey over Joey; Brandon and Dylan over Kelly). In both, the parents eventually left the show and the main characters stayed on their own.
Where Are the Parents?
Romance-obsessed teen shows tend not to include parents in their characters’ lives, which is unrealistic for most teens.
From ages 15 to 18, most of us are influenced (or nagged) greatly by our parents, so they should be an important part of TV teens’ lives too.
The first two Dawson seasons dealt a lot with Dawson’s parents divorcing and getting remarried. But now his mother’s rarely seen and his father died this season. I think that the parents of the show are written off through a number of tragedies-jail, insanity, abandonment, death-so that the characters can live more on their own.
In the last four years-even before they got to college, there were only about six episodes that included parents of the other main characters. Grams, Jen’s grandmother, is still a series regular, but I’m talking about parents.
Family Dramas Keep It Real
So instead of watching these pointless romance-centered teen shows, I’ve been turning to the more wide-ranging and realistic “family dramas,” like Once and Again, Gilmore Girls and 7th Heaven.
These shows feature many teenage characters, but unlike the teen shows, parents are in every episode and play big parts in their children’s lives. To me, that’s more interesting to watch.
Once and Again is a great show about post-divorce life for two families, an experience that many kids can relate to since 50% of U.S. marriages end in divorce. A middle-aged divorced man, Rick, and a middle-aged divorced woman, Lily, get married and move their four kids together into one house. They have a hard time becoming “one big happy family.”
The show’s also thought-provoking, like when Jessie (Rick’s daughter) had an eating disorder. Her family and friends didn’t notice until she fainted in the school locker room.
Gilmore Girls, a dramatic comedy, portrays a single mother and her teenage daughter, another common relationship. With extremely witty writing, it shows the friendlier side of a mother-daughter
relationship, rather than having the mother always arguing with the daughter about her expensive clothes or latest boyfriend.
Joining the Adults
I can still somewhat relate to the teen shows on TV, but for the st part, the teen shows I used to watch are getting older than I am. I can still get a hearty laugh out of Maybe It’s Me, and hang on to the continued dangers of vampire-slaying, but for the kind of teens I can really identify with on TV, I’m giving up so-called teen dramas and joining the adults.

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.