Names have been changed.
Sometimes when you develop a deep passion for someone, you abandon the principles you’ve tried hard to hold onto. I discovered this the hard way through my relationship with Zarah, the closest friend I’ve ever had. I glorified her as something she was not. But, in the end, the truth hurt.
I met Zarah in math class during my freshman year. She sat behind me, and we only talked when she asked me about our homework.
One afternoon during my sophomore year, I was waiting for the #1 train. Zarah and her friend Delilah saw me and said hi. We got on the train together and talked about school. The next day, I rode with them again. This time her other friend Daisy joined us. From then on, riding the train with the three of them became routine.
Subway Stories
I grew more at ease with Zarah because we were able to crack jokes with each other. Zarah lived in Brooklyn, but most of the time she took the train all the way uptown to 125th St. just to keep Daisy company or to go to her house. Sometimes Zarah stayed on till my stop, 168th St., and then transferred to the A to go back to Brooklyn.
One day I decided to keep Zarah company while she was waiting for the A. About seven trains passed that we could take, but neither one of us could break away from our intense conversation.
I revealed things that I normally don’t tell people, like when I stole money from my aunt. She told me about her rocky relationship with her mother and her wild years of junior high.
She’s Bisexual
“I was over my friend’s house for her 13th birthday party and we got a little drunk,” she said meekly. “I was dancing with a bunch of girls and then we went into a bedroom, and it got a little freaky.”
Then Zarah said that she was bisexual. I was a little shocked because she was always the first one to talk about how cute a boy was to Daisy and Delilah, or approach a guy and get his phone number.
Still, I saw nothing wrong with her sexuality. I actually thought it was cool because now I could talk to her about girls too.
After our disclosures, our subway conversations became routine, and the more conversations we had, the closer I felt to her. Zarah and I talked about topics ranging from the people she played to why the sky was blue. There were no dull moments or dead silences. Chilling with Zarah was the highlight of my day.
Because of our subway talks, I sometimes got home two or three hours late and lied about where I was so that I wouldn’t be grounded. She was getting in trouble too, so we switched to talking on the phone.
Why Weren’t We an Item?
We sometimes spoke from 8 at night to 1 in the morning. I believe that if you can talk to someone for five hours, then you’ve really got something going on.
But Zarah and I didn’t have anything going on romantically. As our friendship grew more intense over our sophomore year, people in school started asking if we were dating. We told some people that we were cousins in order to get them to stop bothering us.
But then I started questioning why wasn’t I going out with her, or at least why I hadn’t tried to. I mean, we had these long, interesting conversations and clearly enjoyed each other’s company. And I was single.
By late May, new feelings surfaced. I noticed things about her physically that I’d overlooked before.
Visions of Settling Down
Even though Zarah had a shapely body which could only be described by the word “whew,” the most physically attractive thing about her was her eyes. She had soothing brown orbs that made me space out when I looked at them and think of settling down and having a family.
Still, I felt hesitant about dating Zarah because she wasn’t just any friend, but a best friend. With all the turmoil that a relationship can cause, I didn’t want to end up losing her friendship.
Plus, Zarah often told me about the boys and girls that she was dating or flirting with, and I didn’t want to be just another person whom she was playing.
To make matters more complicated, Zarah had a crush on Daisy, who had a boyfriend. And I had a gut feeling that Daisy liked Zarah too.
Had to Let it Out
So I didn’t ask her out. But I was so anxious. I couldn’t hold a conversation with her without thinking of how attractive she looked or how much I wanted to date her.
It was eating me up inside. I needed to let it out. I figured I’d tell her, she’d turn me down and then I’d move on. So one day in July, I called her. Ten minutes into the conversation, I made my move.
“Um, Zarah, I kind of…um, well, I kind of like you.”
She laughed.
“That’s nice,” she said. But “nice” wasn’t what I was trying to get at.
“Well, um, do you like me?”
“I don’t at the present time, but I possibly could,” she replied.
Plan Foiled!
I was taken aback! My plan to tell her just to get it off my chest and get rejected was foiled by a newfound possibility.
“So what do you want to do about it?” she asked. “Do you want to go out?”
“Well…um, I, I don’tâI don’t want to mess up our friendship.”
I felt like a dumbass. She was intelligent, beautiful and could make me fall out laughing. “Idiot! What the hell are you doing?” I thought.
But then I realized why I couldn’t go through with it. I remembered that most of the relationships Zarah had were short-lived and that despite how close we were as friends, I feared ours would be the same. I valued her friendship immensely and didn’t want to jeopardize it.
Decided to Wait
Still on the phone, I told Zarah about my fears of dating a close friend. Zarah understood where I was coming from, but said that if our friendship was as strong as I thought it was, then it would last even if we dated. After she said that, I began to think that a romance might work out.
But then I remembered Daisy. I pictured me being with Zarah and her thinking about Daisy. So, despite Zarah’s reassurance, I decided to wait.
Nonetheless, I was still intensely attracted to her. About two weeks after I told Zarah I liked her, I called her to see what she was up to.
Dropped a Bombshell
“Guess what I did today?” she said, about to burst.
I took a wild guess.
“You hung out with Daisy?” I asked.
“Yeah, and guess what else?”
“I don’t knowâwhat?”
“I slept with her!” she blurted.
My jaw dropped and my fantasies of dating Zarah died like a slug in salt.
“God really pissed on me today!” I thought. But I continued to talk to her like nothing happened.
I felt like I needed to lock my emotions away until the pain of hearing about their sexual encounter went away, so I acted like it didn’t affect me. I talked to her about the other people she was seeing besides Daisy to convince myself that I could never have a relationship with her.
Zarah had her fling with Daisy, then lost interest in her. When Zarah told me that she was over Daisy, my feelings for her came out of hibernation. But, over the course of several weeks, Zarah shuffled through girlfriends.
Still, I couldn’t let go of my visions of us together. I still wanted to be with her romantically. But I didn’t ask Zarah out because I didn’t want to make things awkward between us or leave myself open.
An Internet Girl
Soon Zarah met a girl named Karen over the internet, and they started dating. Karen was interesting, smart, funny-supposedly everything Zarah wanted in a woman’s personality. But Karen wasn’t what Zarah wanted physically. Zarah thought Karen was overweight and didn’t like the way she dressed.
Zarah’s attraction to Karen fizzled as they became more intimate. Zarah started to shop around for other love interests, and soon dumped Karen.
To Zarah, Karen’s appearance was too big of an issue, and that made me see flaws in Zarah. I felt that if she liked Karen’s personality so much, it shouldn’t matter whether she was overweight or unfashionable.
Would I Not Get Played?
I had a feeling that if we were to date, Zarah would find something wrong with me, or even cheat on me. How would I be different from the other people she played?
But my fantasy of what could be between us was still there, even though we were seeing each other less. By the beginning of our junior year, we were both so busy that we didn’t talk or hang out as much as we used to.
We became distant and that worried me, so I asked her if she wanted to hang out one weekend. So we went shopping and then went to the Promenade in Brooklyn.
The Promenade was nearly deserted. We sat on a bench and talked till the sun went down, and that’s when, out of the blue, things got complicated.
We Got Physical
We didn’t have sex, but I can tell you it was more physical than a kiss. To me, that moment was meaningful, because it was the first time I’d ever been so physical with a girl. And it was with Zarah.
But during our walk to the train station, there was a dead silence I’d never experienced with Zarah before. She put on her headphones. I wanted to talk about what happened and didn’t understand why there was this un-comfortable hush between us.
I Resented Her
We fell back into being busy and didn’t get a chance to talk for weeks. When we finally did, I told her I regretted what we did because it’s something I feel I should only do when I’m in a relationship with someone.
As soon as I finished telling her how I felt, she skipped to another topic, and talked about this girl that she liked and a guy that liked her. I was hurt and resentful that she didn’t respond to what I’d said. I didn’t feel like talking about it any further if she was going to ignore my feelings.
But I couldn’t let it go. A week later, I had a new idea. I’d tell Zarah about the problems I was having with a “nameless” girl, who was actually her, and if she didn’t figure it out, she’d give me the sort of advice that would work for herself.
So I told Zarah that I liked this girl but that she was involved with all these other people. She told me I should casually date the girl, which meant we’d be free to date others. When I revealed that the mystery girl was her, Zarah asked me if I wanted to “casually date” her.
Decided to ‘Casually Date’
I was unsure. It went against the ethics I set for myself in relationships. I never got to see my parents together, so having a relationship with only one other person is important to me. Plus, casual dating removes emotional intimacy from a relationship, and that emotional closeness is what I wanted the most.
Though I opened up to Zarah as a friend, I wasn’t sure if I could do that knowing she was also with someone else. I didn’t want a “casual” relationship, but I’d been longing for Zarah for what seemed like forever. And I didn’t want to be lonely.
So I thought, “Something is better than nothing” and told Zarah, “Yes.” But even after we officially started dating, we hardly talked and made no advances in our relationship.
Couldn’t Handle It
In my mind, I knew that whatever we did that was special to me, like kissing, she was doing with someone else. When I thought of her other people, I felt like I was in a relay race rather than a relationship.
I really liked Zarah and maybe even loved her, but I couldn’t lie to myself and say that I was comfortable with our relationship.
The whole issue bothered me so much that two weeks into the relationship, I called her up to tell her that I couldn’t do the casual dating thing. But she beat me to the punch.
Zarah said that Karen lost weight and was now physically acceptable to her, so they decided to get back together. Zarah assured me that this time she intended to be faithful and wasn’t going to see other people. My feeling that she’d drop me was right.
Just Friends, Again
In the aftermath of the drama I went through with Zarah, I realized that I wanted her to be someone she clearly was not. She had many qualities I was attracted to, but I was looking for someone to settle down with and she wasn’t that type of person. But I couldn’t accept that, and ended up feeling regret and disappointment.
Zarah and I are still friends, and sometimes I still catch myself dreaming that we’re more than just friends. Then I remember all I’ve been through with her and wake up.
Sometimes things are a certain way because they need to be. Zarah’s my platonic friend because that’s all that she can be. After seeing all the b.s. I went through just trying to talk to her about us, I see that a serious romance probably would’ve been far worse.
Me and Zarah…Zarah and Everyone Else
About These Stories
YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.