Lying for Mom

It is very hard to tell on the one you truly love, even if you know that telling on that person will help protect someone else you love. It seems the more you try to make that person understand that you want them to get better so you don’t have to tell on them, the more that person rejects you. That person is that so-called mother of mine.
I love my mother with all my heart, but she isn’t doing what she needs to do to get my sister out of foster care and back at home. I want my sister to grow up in her home because I know how hard it has been for me to grow up in foster care. So I could lie and tell the social worker that my mother’s life is back in order, but I worry that my sister will not be living somewhere safe if she goes home to my mother. I just want my mother to change and get better so she will take good care of my sister, but she doesn’t seem to care to do that. Realizing this is where my mind starts to get tired and I don’t know what to do.
The first time I lied for my mother was last year, when I was 16. Back then, my mother was doing what she had to do in order to get my sister and me out of foster care and back home. She did everything in her power to get us back. She was fighting with the system and the courts. She finished the rehab program they made her take, and got an apartment that was big enough for all of us-my mother, my sister and me.
Mom Fought for Us, The Courts Denied Her
The courts had promised that after all this was said and done, my sister and I would go home. But that didn’t happen. They said that there were more procedures to follow. This made me very upset. They made a promise that they did not keep.
My mother acted like she wasn’t affected by this, but I knew that way deep down inside she was. She had fought so hard to get us home, and now she had to do even more.
Not long after that she met a man. After that, her focus was no longer just on me and my sister, it was now on her so-called boyfriend. He became her main distraction. This is when everything came falling down-from a simple “I love you” from him. I believe that, combined with her disappointment that the system wouldn’t let us come home, made her give up trying to win us back.
Soon there was a sudden change in my mother’s attitude, her attitude became a careless one, the “I don’t care” kind. She would put off my special events and stop picking up my sister for weekend visits just to sit around and wait for a man who wasn’t worth it.
She Found a No-Good Man
She put that man before the ones who she is supposed to be building a bond with-my sister and me. She also stopped doing the basics around the house, like cleaning and paying the two bills she has, the electric and the phone bill. She also stopped going food shopping.
This made me very upset. I realized if she kept up like this, my sister would never go home with her.
When I would go on my weekend visits at my mother’s house, each Saturday morning I would wake up bright and early, excited for my sister’s arrival at 12 p.m. But each afternoon my mother would arrive home without my sister. She would always have some lame excuse for my sister not coming along with her. She said that my sister’s foster mother did not show up with my sister that day, but I didn’t believe that was true. My sister’s foster mother would call the night before to make sure my mother would pick my sister up. I think my mother just never went to pick her up. I can only imagine how much that hurt my sister.
My Sister and I Came Second
My mother would act like she was sad not to have my sister home, but I believed that deep down inside she wasn’t. It seemed she wanted to spend the weekend with her man instead, a man who didn’t give her a push to go get my sister because he wanted my mother all to himself.
I wasn’t worried about me. I would soon be turning 18, and I could go back to live with my mother because the courts really can’t say anything when you’re 18. But my sister is younger and I didn’t want her to stay in foster care like I have. I still loved my mother and I wanted my sister to be with her, even though I was no longer sure it was the right thing for my sister.
When I told my mother that her not getting my sister for weekend visits would mess up the process of her getting my sister back home, she told me not to worry too much. She said everything would be fine.
My Lie to Save Our Family
I knew it wouldn’t be, so I lied for my mother. When it seemed like she wasn’t fighting for us anymore, I made excuses for her to my law guardian and my caseworker. I told them that my mother had a job and had food in the house, and that she was going to get my sister for every weekend visit.
It made me mad to lie for her. It made me mad to have to choose between letting my sister be with my mother and being properly taken care of.
Soon I found out that my mother’s new man had gotten her back into drinking and smoking. That got me so furious. After finishing her rehab program and getting the certificate that she fought for so badly, she was relapsing because of a man.
I wondered to myself whether she really loved my sister and me. She sure wasn’t showing it the right way. Her home didn’t feel like a home anymore. It made me feel like it was the end of the world for me, like she would go back to her same old ways after she promised she wouldn’t. I felt neglected all over again, like I did when I first went into care.
Was It the Right Thing?
My mother’s life is not as messed up as it was years before, but since she’s started messing up again, the world has made a U-turn for me. For a while there, I thought for sure my sister and I were going home. Now I don’t even know if that’s a good idea. I don’t know if I should keep on lying for her.
I tried my best to help my mother get better. I encouraged her, told her that she is not alone and that I’m here, ready to help her, and that she can make it through anything.
I even talked to her about that no-good boyfriend of hers and how he wasn’t good for her. All she could do is say how she loves him, and then switches up and says she is going to let him go, because he is not doing anything for her. But you must understand that my mother is a person who contradicts herself. She’ll say he’s not doing anything for her and then let him stay anyway. I talk to her until my throat goes sore.
My Sister Wants Mom
The law guardian and social worker have believed my lies, but I’m no longer sure I should have told them. Now my sister is close to going back home to my mother. The court date is next month. But I worry. Is it safe for my sister to go home? I ask myself this all the time.
Part of me thinks, “Let your sister be happy. This has been her wish for the longest. She has been waiting to go home and be with the rest of the family.”
She doesn’t want to be in care any longer and I don’t blame her one bit.
But another part of me knows that my mother is not stable and not quite on her feet the way that she used to be, and that might be bad for my sister. My mother thinks that she will make me be the parent to my sister, but I will not accept that challenge. My mother needs to understand that if my sister goes home, my sister will need her more than anything.
But Is Home Safe?
I think that it’s really up to me if my sister goes home or not. If I lie for my mother again, my sister goes home. Then I will be left feeling guilty because I know deep down that it isn’t the right choice for my sister.
If I agree to tell the truth and my sister stays in care, this would break my sister’s heart.
I think I might not say anything at all. This might leave the problem in the system’s hands, which at least would take the load off my back.

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.