Too Much Too Soon

A San Francisco Social Worker Speaks Out
Writers from Foster Care Youth United interviewed Alan Botts, a social worker, about his views on how well kids are prepared to leave the foster care system at age 18. Mr. Botts started his career as a staff in a residential treatment center after college, and later returned to school to earn his social work degree. He is now working as a therapist with kids in care. He has worked as a social worker in San Francisco’s foster care system, where kids are on their own at 18, for 6 years. Here’s what he had to say.
Q: What do you think about kids emancipating at age 18, like they do in California and most other states?
A: I feel it’s pretty unreasonable to expect all young people to be all grown up and ready to live on their own by 18. The world is just too high-pressured a place. Some young people might be ready, but it’s perfectly understandable that others may not be. I don’t think anyone should be made to feel like they’ve got a problem if they’re not ready to leave at 18.
And living on your own can be particularly hard for youth in foster care. Like for me, I wasn’t in foster care, but I was living on my own at 16. Things weren’t working out for me at home and my mom was cool with me moving out. I had a little apartment and my mom helped me out. But I had some problems later on. I ran into debt, I flunked out of college, so at 19 I had to go back and live with my mom. If I didn’t have my mom to fall back on, I might have had a lot of trouble. I might have been very depressed. I could have become suicidal. Lots of young people coming out of foster care don’t have support like I had.
Q: Do you think the age when kids emancipate in California and many other states-18-should be changed?
A: Yes, I think foster care should be extended ’til 21 if needed. Before that, kids should be given more responsibilities and more freedom, because 19- and 20-year-olds don’t want to be treated like kids, with foster parents telling them what to do. But they should also have some support.
The way it is now, it’s too much all of a sudden. It’s, you’re a minor, you’re a minor, you’re a minor, and you have to do what people tell you. Then, on your 18th birthday, you’re responsible for everything, including paying your bills. I think some legislators need to get creative and look at a halfway system.
Q: On a scale of 1-10, how well do you think foster kids in California are prepared to leave the system?
A: On a scale of 1-10, I’d say it’s pretty low. I would say possibly 2, overall in the state, or maybe up to 3. I don’t think it’s great.
Q: What happens now when kids are not ready to leave at 18?
A: For the most part, they’re forced out. Under certain circumstances, youth can continue until their 19th birthdays, but you have to be going to school. Youth with special needs, like disabilities, can continue until 20 or 21. But other than that, there isn’t much leeway.
Q: What kind of support do you think kids could use when they leave the system?
A: I think what youth could really use is some kind of social worker. Now, that might just be my bias, since I am a social worker. But I think they need someone they can call up and rely on a little bit. Not someone they have to ask permission of, but someone they can call, talk to, ask advice.
I also think they need inexpensive housing and help getting into school, whether that’s a GED program, a community college or a different kind of college, because that’s how kids are going to get ahead. And I think they need therapeutic counseling services.
There’s transitional housing. I think there should be other transitional services. There should be more services available over several years.
I do think things have gotten better. There’s a lot of new stuff coming down the pike. For instance, there’s going to be full scholarship money, plus spending money for college. And you have to give props to San Francisco’s independent living program. I think it’s a program with a lot more heart than a lot of other programs. But the money’s pretty limited. I think we have a long way to go.
Q: How do foster kids do when they leave the system?
A: Sadly, if you look at the statistics, it’s not very encouraging. Young adults who leave foster care end up getting in trouble with the law at a higher rate than other young people. A higher percentage become single parents before they’re ready. A higher percentage end up on welfare, and with physical illness or injury. Those statistics are well-documented.
What that means is that foster youth have to work harder to be successful. And some are successful. I know people who were in foster care who are working as chief executive officers, as politicians, in the music industry. And when you’ve been through foster care, you certainly have the knowledge of your own emotional struggle. You know the expression, “If it doesn’t kill you it will make you stronger.” If you make it through the foster care system and are able to find friends, peace, joy in your life, you’ve really shown that you have an amazing capacity.
Alan Botts was interviewed by Patrick Akinnagbe, Chris Brooks, Nitera Coleman, Gisselle Gordon, Erik Johnson and Joseph Johnson.

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.