Was It a Case of Child Abuse?

One day, while working as a cashier in a Brooklyn supermarket, I witnessed a disturbing event.
A woman walked in with her two children, an adorable little girl who seemed to be about 15 months, and a small boy about 5 years old. I’d seen them before and thought they were cute.
The woman put the little girl in the seat of the cart and proceeded into the canned food aisle. Then she let the little boy push it. He was so short, he couldn’t really see past the cart.
Caught on Camera
There was a display of canned vegetables at the front of the aisle and while pushing the cart, the boy knocked his sister’s hand into it. The little girl began to cry.
When I heard the crying, I pressed the control buttons of the surveillance cameras to enlarge my view. I saw the mother hitting the little boy hard.
She was punching and hitting him on his arms and back as though he were a grown man. Was this child abuse?
None of Our Business?
My co-worker Kizzy and I asked the manager to do something, but he said there was nothing he could do and that it was none of our business.
I wasn’t sure if he was right, though, because what the woman was doing seemed wrong to me. But even if we could do something, I didn’t know what it was.
After she beat him, the mother sent the whimpering boy to the front of the store, right near me, until she finished shopping.
I Made Him Smile
I felt bad for him. He had a bruise on his face which didn’t look new, and he kept his head down.
“Hello,” I said, and he reluctantly waved his hand.
“My name is Nay, and I work here,” I told him. I asked him his name and he didn’t respond at first, so I asked again. Then he told me his name and where he went to school.
With Kizzy’s help, I managed to get the boy to relax a bit. I threw a Cream Saver at Kizzy, who was working close by, then asked the boy, “Would you like a Cream Saver?”
He just shook his head no, so I told him, “Good. You won’t get cavities, and have bad teeth like that guy over there,” as I pointed to a man. Soon, the boy, Kizzy and I were laughing about an episode of The Simpsons where Lisa needed braces.
We Got Their Address
But before long, his mother appeared and yelled at him because he was laughing.
I explained that he was laughing because I was joking with him. His mother instructed me to leave him alone because he was in trouble.
When his mother was done shopping, she went on Kizzy’s check-out line. She paid for her groceries and wanted them delivered.
After the family left, when the manager wasn’t looking, we snuck over to the boxes and copied down her address. We didn’t know what to do, but both of us felt bad for the boy.
Report the Incident?
Our co-workers weren’t as affected by the situation. A few of them laughed, and others said things like “Damn, that’s messed up,” or “Somebody should help that kid,” but they felt it was none of their business. Kizzy and I wondered, though, should we call the police or a hotline?
We decided we wouldn’t make any quick decisions because we weren’t sure what the repercussions would be. If we were wrong, and the woman was just having a bad day, calling the authorities might’ve led to situations that we wouldn’t have been able to control.
However, if our suspicions were correct, by minding our business, we were allowing an unhealthy situation to continue.
I felt uneasy. I wanted to help the boy because what I witnessed could’ve been just one incident in an ongoing case of child abuse. I knew that there was a child abuse hotline, but I didn’t know what the consequences would be if I reported what I saw. (See sidebar.)
Parents Said Wait
So I decided to get other people’s reactions. First I talked to my parents. They were the ones who influenced me to hold off on any actions until I saw another instance of abusive behavior by the mother.
My mother, who’s worked in the family court system for many years as a court officer and senior clerk said, “You can call the child abuse hotline and leave it for them to handle. Once a report is made, they have to check it out within 24 hours.”
My father advised me not to do anything right away. He reasoned that if it was an isolated incident, then I’d be “opening a can of worms.”
I’m Watching
I decided the best thing to do would be to stay alert. The employees at the supermarket knew what happened, and Kizzy and I were on the lookout for the family.
If we saw another hitting incident, we were definitely calling the authorities. After all, we did have the mother’s name and address.
I’ve seen the family three times since that day. I haven’t seen any more signs of abuse, and, in spite of his sad demeanor, the boy seems healthy and clean.
I’m still troubled though, and my gut feeling is to say something. One option I’m considering is to call his school. The staff there see him more than I do, and if they notice anything, they are mandated by the state to report it.
I hope I’m wrong about this boy being abused, but if not, I hope the situation can be rectified before he’s scarred too deeply.

SIDEBAR: What Happens When Abuse Is Reported?
To learn what might happen if I reported child abuse, I spoke to family court professionals and called the child abuse hotline. The hotline is the emergency number for the Child Abuse and Maltreatment Center in Albany, NY. The number’s at the beginning of any New York State telephone directory. It’s an 800 number, so it’s free. It’s also anonymous, so you don’t have to leave your name and number.
Call Police in an Emergency
When I called, the operators were friendly. I spoke to the Center’s Pat Cantiello. She advised me that in the event of an emergency-where a child’s life is in danger-to call the police directly, because they would be able to respond quicker than anyone else. But if it’s not an emergency, call the hotline, she said. Once the Center gets a report of abuse from New York City, the Administration for Children’s Services (ACS) is contacted. They have to send somebody to investigate the situation within 24 hours. Better Safe Than Sorry Two-thirds of the time, the cases are unfounded, meaning that the caseworker doesn’t detect a problem. Ms. Cantiello said they’d rather receive unfounded calls from people who suspect abuse than not get called at all. It’s better to be wrong than to leave children stuck in abusive situations, she said. Certain professionals are required by law to report signs of child abuse, including teachers, doctors, hospital workers, police and child care workers. Once an investigation starts, social workers have 90 days to make a case for abuse or neglect. But if they have enough evidence immediately or if the child really feels threatened, they can remove the child and appear in court either that day or the next.
People Can Change
They can also try to solve the problem without removing the child from the home. The social worker may decide to work with the family, and the family may be sent to counseling, anger management classes or other services the social worker thinks may be helpful. According to Barbara Stilteen, a family court lawyer, programs for the abusers and abused can make a big difference. “People have completed these programs and made turnarounds,” she said. According to the Honorable Stewart Weinstein, a judge in Brooklyn Family Court, most of the cases he sees “aren’t abuse, but neglect.” Neglect is not taking care of your children by the standards set by the state for feeding and clothing them, sending them to school and keeping them clean. Abuse is doing something physical, such as hitting, beating or molesting them. If there is physical or sexual abuse, however, “the child will rarely remain with the parent,” said Judge Weinstein.
Foster Care Is an Option
When ACS removes a child from the home, the agency tries to place the child with another parent, if possible, or with another family member. If this doesn’t work out, the child will be placed in foster care. Meanwhile, the family members may have to go to court several times. Through lawyers, the parents and child give their versions of the story. Then it’s up to the judge to decide whether the child returns to the family or stays in foster care. “I would never remove a child because of an isolated incident,” said Judge Weinstein. Judges, social workers and lawyers must look at exactly what occurred. For example, somebody hitting their 15-year-old son because he left a pot on the stove unattended isn’t looked at in the same way as somebody hitting their 15-month-old son because he spit up on his brand new outfit. And spanking a child may be acceptable while injuring a child is not. Some parents may argue that their religion or culture permits corporal punishment, but that logic is generally not accepted in court. “The rules are in place for all to follow, not some,” said Stilteen. As Judge Weinstein said, “A child has the right to live with people who aren’t going to abuse them.” The Child Abuse Hotline number is 1-800-342-3720.

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.