Too Far for Love

(Names have been changed.)
When I was 14, I had a long distance relationship with a girl named Lana. In the beginning of our romance, I thought I was ready to handle the distance, but I was wrong.
I met Lana at a summer camp for artists when I was 12. In theater class we developed a friendly rivalry. We would always try to upstage each other when we were acting or singing. We’d also compete by playing soccer, basketball or softball.
We had fun together and, during the first couple of years I knew her, we’d write to each other after the summer, since I live in New York and Lana lived in Chicago.
A Crush Blossoms
Over time, I developed a crush on Lana. She was really pretty with silky dark hair and brown eyes. She also had long, smooth legs (she’s 5’10”). But I didn’t act on my impulses until the third year we knew each other.
It happened at camp when we were 14. On a field trip to see the movie Mulan, were sitting together and out of nowhere we started holding hands. It felt awkward at first, but as the movie went on it felt more natural.
On the bus ride back to camp, Lana put her head on my shoulder and I put my arm around her. I was nervous, but I went with the flow and tried to be cool about it. I was unsure what to make of this.
When we got back to the camp that night, all my friends were like, “Are you two dating? That’s hot, man.” But I wasn’t sure if we were. It was odd for me to think about us as boyfriend and girlfriend.
I’d day-dreamed about a relationship with Lana before, but I didn’t think it would happen. I wondered if she felt that way too.
Asking Her Out
The next day Lana and I were alone during swim time and I figured I’d ask her about dating and see what her response was. I turned to her and nervously said, “I think we might have some”-I struggled for words-“mutual feelings for each other.”
I felt so stupid, saying “mutual feelings.” What kind of a moron was I? Couldn’t I have said something more suave? But to my surprise, Lana smiled and kissed me on the lips. “I think I’ve got those feelings too” she said.
I was overjoyed. I’d gotten away with sounding dumb and I had a hot girl anyway. We started going out.
Our first few weeks as a couple were terrific. We went out for ice cream, saw movies and went on hay rides. We also shared jokes and secrets and snuck out at night to make out. After a week or two, I felt so comfortable with her that I told her I loved her. She said she felt the same way.
Trying Out Distance
Despite our good times, trouble started when camp ended. We decided that we loved each other enough to carry on a long distance relationship.
We agreed not to date other people, which I thought was cool even though I’d never been in a long distance relationship before and didn’t know what to expect.
I figured that distance couldn’t be too bad, since we were in love at the time, but I was wrong. I didn’t consider that I might not see Lana until the next summer.
After I got back home, we talked on the phone and Internet almost every day, and things went well for the first month. But it soon got hard to have a girlfriend I couldn’t kiss or see regularly.
I missed the Lana I’d known at camp. At first, I thought that maybe I was shallow, that maybe all I liked about her was her looks since I was starting to feel differently now that I couldn’t actually see her. But I soon figured out it wasn’t that simple.
I definitely was attracted to Lana, but I felt like I loved her because of her sense of humor, her singing and how we did things together.
When we were apart, all that was missing. Something about not being near her made it hard to be as open with Lana as I had been.
Wanting Lana in Person
The further away the summer got, the less I had to talk to Lana about. I tried to learn about her friends who I didn’t know by listening to her stories about them, but I found myself not caring.
Without her face, they were just stories. During the summer it was easier to talk because I could connect her words to her face. But when I talked to her on the phone, her words felt like a book on tape, impersonal and foreign.
I’d find myself wanting her kisses and hugs; just the idea of holding her hand seemed like heaven to me. I wanted to go to movies with her again and to introduce Lana to my friends.
But instead, I had to deal with wisecracks from my so-called buddies. They would tease me and say that Lana was “just some girl” I’d taken a picture with. I’d go along with the joke at first and try to give a sarcastic reply, but after a while I didn’t feel like responding.
Distance Created Problems
After three months, our relationship was coming apart. Distance created problems I hadn’t considered.
For instance, my phone bills were about $100 a month, so my parents (who were paying them) limited me to three calls a week.
So we began to chat online only. I’d e-mail Lana and instant message her, but the Internet only made things worse. When I’d try to be sarcastic, Lana would get mad at me since she couldn’t tell I was joking.
Online Errors
I learned that when someone can’t hear the tone of your voice, it’s really not smart to say, “Oh my God, you’re such a loser.” I’d try to tell her that I was only joking, but by then she’d already be angry at me and not want to listen.
We started having fights about the littlest things we’d say online. One time, Lana sent me a poem she’d written and I wrote back to her and told her that it was really good but that I thought she could do without one line.
Lana’s response was “You’re such a jerk! Don’t tell me how to write!” Lana had always been very determined, but she’d never been so defensive about criticism before.
The long distance relationship I’d committed to was becoming hellish. Misunderstandings became the norm and I felt like if I let them simmer, then our relationship would be wrecked for sure.
I Considered Cheating
After we started fighting so much, I even considered cheating on Lana, but I held back. I wanted affection, the kind that Lana couldn’t give me from Chicago, but I knew I’d hurt Lana if I cheated.
Still, I was tempted. In the months between camp and when I finally saw her again, I’d seen two ex-girlfriends and gone back to school where there were plenty of girls.
I found myself being distant with my female friends in order to ease the temptation to cheat. At the time, almost any girl was looking good enough to hit on and I began to think of them as forbidden fruit.
I Decided to Visit Her
I thought if I visited Lana, things might get better. I told her I wanted to come to Chicago and she said it was cool. I bought a plane ticket so I could see her over a four-day weekend in late January. Even though it was expensive, I wanted to try and save what we had.
In the month between buying the ticket and when I went to see her, I kept daydreaming about what the weekend would be like. I dreamed that maybe we’d have dinner at a romantic restaurant, or take a walk by Lake Michigan.
The day I left, it was cold and icy in New York and Chicago was blanketed in snow. On the flight, I felt edgy and anxious. I was wondering, “Will Lana accept me? Or will she be cold and distant?”
Unfortunately, when I got off the plane and saw Lana at the gate, things were strained. I hadn’t seen her in five months and it was a shock to be looking at her after so long. I gave her a passionless hug and tried to smile, but it just didn’t feel right.
Nothing Deep
I spent three days in Chicago. Lana and I went out for dinner, watched movies, looked at photos and talked, although that was mostly superficial. We didn’t share secrets or tell stories like the summer before. Our conversations were solemn and serious.
By the third day, I didn’t feel like I loved Lana anymore. Our relationship felt more like a friendship to me. When the time came to go, I knew what I had to do.
Before I left Lana’s house to go to the airport, I told her that I still wanted to be her friend, but that the long distance thing wasn’t working. I felt horrible saying it, since I didn’t want to hurt her, but it felt necessary. I’d rather she heard it from me in person than from an icy letter or phone call.
Lana seemed a bit sad, but acted like it wasn’t that big a deal. “I guess it’s better for us,” she said. I was happy she agreed, and I believed she was really OK.
Pissed Off!
In truth, Lana must have been pissed off at me because, after our breakup, she told some girls we both knew that I was a jerk and a cheat. Girls I’d known from camp and even friends of mine from New York City who’d met Lana were giving me lip about cheating even though I kept telling them that I hadn’t. They’d say stuff like “Jon, I thought you were so honest,” or “I can’t believe you’d do that to Lana.”
I was mad. I called Lana to tell her to stop lying about me, but she’d hang up or refuse to talk about it. It wasn’t right. I hadn’t done anything wrong.
I felt depressed. I wanted to stay inside for days. I was withdrawn and hardly talked to anyone. I started thinking that maybe it was my fault, that I hadn’t done enough to save our relationship. I kept asking myself, “Was it really so bad that I couldn’t stand being in a long distance relationship?”
Writing About What Happened
It took me a couple weeks to come to terms with what had happened. I wrote about our relationship in poems or free-writes in English class. Seeing my feelings on paper helped cleanse me of all the anger and bad feelings I had about the relationship.
My mood got better and I stopped moping around. And two months after my break-up, I met a new girl. Being with someone else took my mind off Lana and I realized I could be happy without her.
Lana eventually called me and apologized for lying, but the damage had already been done. I told her how I felt.
I said that she had a right to be angry with me, but that she should stop spreading rumors about me behind my back. She said she just wanted to be friends again.
Looking Back
It’s been two years since our relationship ended, and I talk to Lana every now and then, but what she did really pissed me off. I don’t trust Lana the way I used to and it’s hard for me to be open with her.
I thought I loved Lana, at least in the beginning of our relationship. But now I question if really I did. I think our breakup would’ve affected me a lot more if I truly loved her.
What I do know is that being apart tested our relationship and it just couldn’t stand the strain. Not being able to talk to her face to face ruined what we had together. I missed Lana, and I still do, but getting out of our relationship still feels right to me. I’m not sure I’d want to be in a long distance relationship again.

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.