In family court in many states, a child rarely gets to go before the judge. Only when she is accused of delinquency is the child required to be in the courtroom. But if it’s the parent who’s accused of hurting the child, usually the young person is kept outside.
There’s no law that says a child can’t be in court, it’s just common practice. I wanted to know why that is, when what’s decided in court affects our lives in so many ways. The lawyers I spoke to in Manhattan Family Court said that usually, they don’t even think of asking us if we want to be in court. If we do want to be there, they said, we should speak up. Then it will be up to the judge to decide.
They also offered three main reasons why judges and lawyers assume it’s best to keep us out.
1. They said a big reason is that what goes on in court may be too much for us to bear. Like if a father is charged with sexually abusing his child, but in court he condemns that child as a liar, that could be very painful to hear. It might make us cry, or scream in court. It might depress us for a long time. So for our sakes, they decide it’s best to keep us out.
2. Our lawyers represent our interests and speak for us, so we don’t need to be in court ourselves. Part of the job of our lawyers (or of the social workers or volunteers helping them) is to talk to us to make sure they understand what we want and we understand the consequences or our choices.
Once they’ve done that, they believe they’re better able to convince the judge to get us what we want than we would be, because they understand the law.
3. A third reason is that in cases of abuse or neglect, the parent/guardian, who’s the one on trial, has some rights to privacy. Parents might not want their children to know things about their lives that they might be required to say in court, so they can request that the judge keep us from being there.
After thinking through all their reasons, though, I’m still not convinced that kids shouldn’t be in court. I believe that our lawyers and the judges should always ask us if we want to be there, and give us the opportunity to say yes or no, rather than assuming that we don’t.
Of course if a child doesn’t want to talk to a judge, she shouldn’t have to. Or, if she does want to, just not in front of her family, she should be able to do what they do in Los Angeles [read the article on page 15] and talk privately to the judge in her chambers.
I believe for me, though, not being allowed in court was absolutely unhealthy, unhelpful and painful. I imagine that’s true for some other young people as well. Too often in too many ways, the doors are shut to our pain and anger. We are silenced, by our families, by the system, and labeled as children who know nothing.
Even if they mean well, the courts should not make us feel that they’re doing the same. If we want, we should have the right to speak from our hearts and face those who have hurt us.
Open the Doors and Let Us Speak
About These Stories
YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.