(All names have been changed.)
I am gay, but I couldn’t always admit that to myself. When I was younger, I thought being gay was a horrible thing and that I would be ridiculed all the days of my life if I came out of the closet. But becoming comfortable with who I am has changed my perspective.
When I was in elementary school, I thought gay people were placed on earth to be mocked, because I never heard anything positive said about them. I grew up in Brooklyn in a Caribbean family with strong religious beliefs. They believed gay people were of the devil and would be burned in the fires of hell.
They also believed that “real” men showed no feminine behavior, and that was (and still is) very hard for me. I talked and sang in a high pitch for a boy, and I was really neat. It was natural for me to be feminine because I grew up surrounded by women.
I Grew Up Around Women
Besides my mom and grandma, I had all girl cousins, and they were my playmates. At school, I would play double-dutch, hopscotch and hand-games with the girls instead of playing with the boys.
The men in my life were my grandfather, my father and my uncle, but they never taught me “manly” things such as sports. I guess they didn’t know how to play the sports that were most popular in this country.
Looking back, I think that my feminine behavior was the result both of being around so many women and being born gay. I think that my gayness allowed me to relate better to girls.
My Femininity Got Me in Trouble
My ways got me in trouble sometimes. For example, once my mother saw me with a limp wrist and said, “Don’t do that. It looks too feminine!”
I told her, “OK Mommy,” but at the time I was confused. My limp wrist was something that felt normal to me.
I was discriminated against at school as well. I can still hear the taunting voices of all those boys who called me “sissy” or “f-got,” making fun of how I played at recess. They hurt my feelings and shot down my self-esteem. There were many days that I cried.
I think what happened to me was unfair because I don’t think that anyone should be mocked because they’re different. Still, I never told my parents what happened, and I never let them see me cry. I didn’t think that they would understand.
My First Crush
But thank God I had the best 3rd grade teacher. She told me to laugh at the times when anyone hurts your feelings and don’t let them see you cry. As silly as that might sound to some, it worked.
When some of the boys said “f-got,” it still hurt, and I wanted to cry. But I remembered my teacher’s advice and forced myself to laugh with them. They ended up with puzzled looks on their faces, I guess because they thought their jokes weren’t getting to me.
Around that time I also met Michael. On the first day of school in 3rd grade, the teacher announced that we would be getting a new student. I didn’t pay any attention, until he walked in.
Michael Wasn’t Feeling Me
Michael was a very handsome, dark-skinned 9-year-old. He had a rugged appeal to him. (I guess even when I was a child, I knew my type.) It was my first crush on a guy.
I hoped that we would hit it off and become friends, but he didn’t like me. In fact, out of everyone in my class, he teased me the most.
“Look at him, he doesn’t like football, and he always plays with the girls. He’s a f-got,” he’d say. If it wasn’t for my teacher’s advice, I would’ve cried.
I began to develop a love-hate relationship with him. There were times when I liked him because he was so cute and I was determined to make him like me. But sometimes I couldn’t stand his guts because he made me feel so worthless.
Eventually, because I just laughed at all his insults, Michael realized that his making fun of me was pointless and he had no choice but to accept who I was. We became friends (while I maintained my crush on him).
I Hid My Feelings for Guys
Looking back, it was the first time I realized that I did have sexual feelings for males. But I knew that it wasn’t cool to be gay where I grew up.
So, as the years went by, any time I found myself attracted to a boy, I would keep it to myself and try to hold back those feelings. I couldn’t handle identifying myself as gay. I wasn’t mature enough to handle all the obstacles that came with admitting that.
My attraction to guys was hush-hush for the rest of elementary school and junior high. I felt as if I had to be undercover because I didn’t want to offend anybody (particularly my parents) by being open about what I was feeling and I didn’t want to give people ammunition for their insults.
Thankfully, in junior high, I wasn’t ridiculed as much and I even had a best friend who was a guy. The only time I usually got called f-got was when I was having a conflict with someone.
I Dated Girls
But I was still scared of really being perceived as gay. I thought that my family and friends would disown me. It seemed like it was better to be feminine and straight than to be straight out gay.
That’s why I always pretended to be interested in some girl. But then I put myself in the place of my last girlfriend in 8th grade and thought about her emotions. I didn’t want to hurt her or any other girls by pretending to be something that I wasn’t.
By the time I entered high school, I decided to no longer date girls to cover up my attraction to guys. Still, I feared that the same discrimination that I experienced all through junior high would follow me through high school as well.
At first, I didn’t talk to many people in high school because I figured that they would ridicule me for my behaviors, but I slowly got into the “in” crowd. I still held back my feelings for guys. But that changed in my sophomore year.
A ‘Phoine’ New Face
One day, I went to my friend’s 7th period dance class during my lunch break. I walked in and was like,
“Day-amn, who is this cutie wit da bootie? Oh my goodness, he is phoine!”
Well, at least that’s what I thought in my head. This fine work of art had a beautiful butterscotch complexion and a thuggish style. The first thought in my head was, “How come I didn’t see you freshman year?”
As a freshman, I had seen some guys that I thought were cute, but no one could compare to Dante. Lawd knows that from then on, I couldn’t wait until 7th period to go to my friend’s dance class.
The first time I spoke to Dante, I was on my way to a class we both had. (I didn’t realize we had a class together until after I saw him in dance class.) We were walking in opposite directions and I felt that I had to break the silence between us. So I said, “Dante, isn’t class located in the opposite direction?”
“Don’t worry about me, get your ass to class,” he replied. He said it with such cockiness and a sly smirk on his face.
I Fell for Him
After I found the courage to talk to him, I thought to myself, “There go those damn feelings again that I thought I got rid of when I locked them up in the basement of my heart.” I still didn’t feel comfortable liking a guy, but I couldn’t help trying to get to know Dante better.
We developed more of an acquaintance than a friendship, though at the time I imagined we were closer than we really were because I liked him so much. It was hard for me to stifle the warm fuzzy feeling that I got in my heart every time I saw him or he talked to me.
I started to base my whole ideal of what I wanted in a boyfriend on a straight boy that I fell too deeply for. But, oh my goodness, after seeing how he adored his girlfriend when they were going out, I couldn’t help myself.
He knew how to make someone feel special, loved and wanted as a partner. I wanted that for myself.
I acknowledged to myself that I had fallen in love with Dante in my junior year.
Dreams of Love
Loving Dante made me admit to myself that I couldn’t stifle my feelings for guys any more. I thought of how I wanted to spend the rest of my life wrapped up in the arms of a guy who loves me for me, even though I was in love with a straight guy who showed no signs of loving me back.
At least I had a new best friend. I got to know Dionne during the summer after my sophomore year. I’d never met anyone that I clicked with so quickly. There were times we would finish each other’s sentences or say the same thing at the same time.
With Dionne, I felt like I didn’t have to disguise who I was. That’s why I felt it was necessary to come out to her.
Coming Out for the First Time
I tried to tell her one day as we were walking to the subway. I didn’t know how.
“Dionneâ¦You know how you umâ¦have feelings for certain people?”
“M-hm.”
“Well, um, what I am trying to say to you isâ¦um”
Before I could finish, she said so calmly, “Are you trying to tell me that you have feelings for men?”
I was surprised at her response, not because she knew before I told her, but because she knew and had already accepted me.
I was relieved that my first time coming out to someone went so smoothly. I went home happy. I figured that if I could tell someone who’d been my friend for only four weeks, then I could tell people I’d been close to for a much longer time. But that theory proved to be wrong.
Betrayed by Another Friend
Dionne and I decided to tell my secret to Sharon, who I’d been friends with for eight years. Sharon seemed perfectly cool about it when we told her, saying she knew all along. I told her not to tell a soul. I trusted Sharon with my secret because we had been friends for so long.
But a teacher soon told Dionne that Sharon was spreading my secret to others. And, to make matters worse, Sharon told Dante that I liked him!
After finding this out, I felt disgust, embarrassment, twisted love and hate, and a whole bunch of other rough emotions all wrapped up in me like a burrito. I was bitter and depressed.
Dante Becomes Distant
Dante became distant. He stopped saying the casual “Hey” when we crossed paths in the hall and that hurt me. I wasn’t ready to tell him that I liked him. I didn’t want to end the acquaintance that way. It was supposed to be my decision, my right to tell him myself!
It was like I gave Sharon a piece of my heart that I wanted her to keep close to hers, but she betrayed me. I felt as though I couldn’t trust anyone but myself.
Also I worried I would never get the chance to find real love since my first love didn’t love me. But Dionne really supported me. She assured me that when the time is right, love will find me, and that if everything else fails, I’ll always have a friend in her.
Writing in My Journal Helped Me
I don’t trust Sharon anymore, but it’s been hard for me to let Sharon go as a friend because of all the years we’ve had together.
After Sharon told Dante about my secret, one of the only things that made me feel better was writing in my journal. After a couple of months of writing and re-reading what I wrote, it hit me that the more I tried to hide my sexuality, the more embarrassed I became about it.
But when I put it on the table for most people to see, it became easier to deal with.
Revealing the truth about myself to Sharon and Dionne had given me such a sense of relief. It’s like I was finally able to breathe after holding my breath for years.
Not Quite In, Not Quite Out
Despite this realization, one might say I’m standing in the closet’s doorway because I’m not quite in, but I’m not fully out either. I’m not ready to talk with my parents and most people at my school about my sexuality because I’m scared some of my bonds with people could be broken.
But I do hope to be more fully out one day. In the meantime, I’m learning about myself and what it means to be gay. I’m reading Black gay literature by James Earl Hardy and E. Lynn Harris and making gay friends, like Eugene, a writer at NYC who’s fully out. I’ve also become a cyber pal with James Earl.
Even though I’m comfortable with my sexuality, I’m still a baby who has a lot to learn from the gay world. But I’ve already learned how to creep, so now I think it’s time I learned to walk.
I’m Coming Out
About These Stories
YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.