Some would say that getting good grades, being the teacher’s pet and behaving well are characteristics of the Catholic school “good girl.” Now I’m not a bad person, but during my nine years at Our Lady of Lourdes School, I never achieved good girl status, even though I was an honors student.
Catholic school was so rigid that things like my sense of humor, my taste in music and my interest in guys were always getting me in trouble. I had a reputation with my teachers and parents that I didn’t deserve.
My First ‘Crime’
I committed my first “crime” in sixth grade. I wanted to show off this book I had, entitled Spite, Malice and Revenge, so I brought it to school.
On every page was a way to get back at someone. For instance, if you looked up “Ca-Ca,” it describes how to take a dump in front of your enemy’s doorstep. I thought my friends would get a kick out of it.
My friend Lisa wanted to look at the book while she had class in the library, so I let her borrow it. I trusted her to be cool about it. But she was caught with the book by the librarian, and she ratted me out. The school called my parents.
I Felt Like a Disgrace
Miss Kotz, my homeroom teacher, met with my dad at school. When we got home, my dad started shouting at me. I felt bad that I got caught. When I got in trouble, I felt that, in my parents’ eyes, I was the disgrace of the family.
This hurt me but it also made me angry because in my Filipino culture, if a guy gets in trouble, he often doesn’t get punished, whereas if a girl gets in trouble, her world is turned upside down. She’s grounded and, depending on the situation, she may even get sent to the Philippines to live with relatives.
Frankly, I didn’t think that bringing the book to school was a big deal. Still, I took responsibility for my actions by not denying anything, even when my parents called me “an embarrassment.” I knew that the best thing to do was to keep quiet so I wouldn’t get smacked for having a “smart mouth.”
I was grounded for a while. Thankfully, the rest of 6th grade went fine. I didn’t get in trouble again and I maintained my honors-student status. But trouble was around the corner.
‘Bad Boy,’ Bad Times
In 7th grade, I started going out with M., who also went to OLL. He had a “bad boy” reputation. He wasn’t allowed to attend our school trip to Albany because he would get into fights during recess and barely did his homework.
M. told me that he liked me, and I began to feel the same way. Before I knew it, we were an item. I didn’t really care about his “bad” behavior because he was a good boyfriend. M. would call me, give me gifts and always chill with me in school.
All our classmates knew about us, but I had to keep my relationship on the down low from my parents. They didn’t, and still don’t, allow me to have boyfriends because I’m “too young.” And they would have freaked out if they found out M. was Black.
Looking back, I was foolish to be with him because I later found out through the grapevine that he only wanted me for my body (I have boobs). But I couldn’t see that at the time because I really liked him. We would meet at the back staircase in the basement and make out almost every day during our after-school program.
A Risky Tryst Gone Wrong
On his birthday, we were celebrating with the usual kisses, but he wanted to bring it into the boys’ bathroom right across from the staircase. I obliged because we would have more privacy. We were in there for about 20 minutes. It was risky, but I was in the moment, not thinking of getting caught.
BANG BANG BANG!
The pounding on the door startled us. I ran into one of the stalls, while M. ran into the next one. Mrs. Schott, the after-school coordinator, entered the room. She was looking for M. She pushed open all of the stalls, grabbed him, grabbed me and then yelled as she dragged us to the office.
“We weren’t doing anything!” we beseeched.
“Oh please! What else would you be doing in there!”
M. and I received a scolding from both Sr. Josephine, the principal, and Mrs. Schott. It was a nightmare.
Just a ‘Big Misunderstanding’
After Mrs. Schott left, M. and I convinced Sr. Josephine that we weren’t doing anything inappropriate (yeah right!) and that we were just talking. Sr. Josephine promised that she wouldn’t tell our parents because she thought it was a big misunderstanding.
I was relieved that my parents weren’t going to learn about M., even though all the students in the after-school program knew what happened, thanks to M.’s big mouth. His words eventually got me into deeper trouble.
Weeks later, M. wrote me a note saying all the “freaky stuff” that he wanted to do to me. I was offended by what he wrote, but I was even more upset that he had the nerve to show it to all his friends before handing me the letter.
I put it in my bag, but I guess I dropped it somewhere in school and one of my teachers found it, which led to parent conference #2. This time it was my mother who came to school.
A Transfer Threat
One of my teachers, Mrs. Reznick, told my mother about the “bathroom incident” and read the note that M. wrote to me. She also wrongly accused me of co-writing the note and mentioned the possibility of me being transferred out of the school.
I couldn’t hold the tears of sadness, shame and anger inside of me. I had disappointed my parents, my teachers and most of all myself. I had gotten myself into a really embarrassing situation. I didn’t want to go through the drama again.
I denied doing anything with M. in the bathroom and told them that I didn’t write a single word in that disgusting note. I didn’t want my mother to know that we were making out because I knew that she was going to be even more angry and upset.
She was shocked that I had a boyfriend and that he was of another race. I tried to explain myself but she believed that every word coming out of my mouth was a lie, and added, “Wait until your father gets home.”
Terrible Timing
The timing couldn’t have been worse. My father was out of the country because his brother had just passed away in Europe. I felt burdened with grief because my uncle was gone, and guilt because I was adding to the list of my parents’ problems.
After my dad returned home and heard what had happened, he cried out, “My brother just died! I have to send him back to the Philippines in ashes! And I have to deal with you!” My heart just collapsed.
At this point, my parents didn’t trust me at all. I was grounded and, because it was a school vacation, my mother stayed home with me the whole week, which was torture.
Even worse, she told me that she was going to search my room for inappropriate items. She had never threatened to do this before! I felt like a pervert in her eyes. I ran to my room and gathered all my journals, slam books, CDs, anything that my parents might deem “wrong” and hid them in the attic.
Something to Prove
After that, I wanted to prove to my parents and myself that I could stay on track. M. and I broke up. I followed my parents’ advice to behave properly. Plus, I had the bomb grades-all 90% and above.
My parents were proud of me! But I was constantly reminded that if I got in trouble like that again, I would be sent to the Philippines. I didn’t think that they were joking, so I stayed on my best behavior. For a while I felt like I was walking on a string-if I fell, my life would be over.
A month after conference #2, I crashed again. I went to the library and printed out lyrics from a popular song off the Internet. I liked the song, but it had some cursing.
The next day, I brought the lyrics to school. During my lunch period, a friend wanted to see the lyrics and before I knew it, there was a big crowd hovering around her.
Caught Again!
Naturally, the lyrics were confiscated and brought to Mrs. Reznick. She and another teacher yelled at me in front of other students in the cafeteria after lunch. I was sent upstairs and ran crying to my homeroom teacher, Ms. McKessy.
Ms. McKessy had never treated me as if I had a scarlet letter on my forehead. When she found out what had happened between M. and me, she pulled me to the side and gave me advice on how to deal with it, which is what I wanted from an adult.
Ms. McKessy was my angel once again as she eased my tears, but I heard Mrs. Reznick bellow out, “Genevieve is such a sex addict!” for other junior high students to hear. I cried and cried and cried.
Conference #3
That night, the call came. My father and Mrs. Reznick arranged conference #3 for the next morning. After he hung up the phone, I was hit with the usual screaming and smack on the head. I was upset because I could have prevented this if I never brought the lyrics to school.
To my surprise, during conference #3, my father defended me. I had told him about the way Mrs. Reznick scolded me in front of everyone and the hurtful things she said, and he confronted her about it.
“Yeah my daughter made a mistake, but you didn’t have to stone her in front of everyone,” he said. But she retaliated by advising my father to send me to counseling and saying I was on the verge of getting transferred to another school.
I didn’t think I needed counseling. The teachers were overreacting if they believed I was crazy because I liked a song with a few curses in it. My dad agreed to look into counseling, but he never did because he didn’t want my “big mouth” to reveal family secrets.
Trust Lost, Again
Even though my dad took my side against my teachers, my parents’ trust level in me dropped again. I wasn’t allowed to use the Internet or the computer at home.
And they constantly interrogated me. For example, my dad would listen on the other line while I was talking to my friends on the phone. When I was done, he would ask me who I was talking to and what they wanted. I was upset. I felt like a little kid that had to be constantly watched.
I promised myself that I would never again get into so much trouble. I continued receiving 90s and above on my report card, and by the end of 7th grade, I slowly regained my old privileges.
In 8th grade, I was flying high for the most part. But just two weeks before my graduation from God-forsaken OLL, I landed in hell once more!
Almost everyone in my class had America Online. When I got an e-mail containing weird pictures, like naked obese women crushing a poor man to death, I forwarded it to my classmates, hoping they would laugh.
I didn’t think that forwarding an e-mail, something I do regularly, would get me in trouble. I didn’t know that one of my peers, Cassie, would print out the pictures and bring them to school. Inevitably, they were confiscated and caught the attention of the principal.
Cassie, our friend Albert and I were singled out.
Our parents were called and we had to sit in front of the office for over an hour until dismissal. We were “OLL’s Most Stupidest.” Some teachers gave us dirty looks, or expressed their opinion of us.
“What a stupid thing to do!”
“Two weeks before graduation! I guess I won’t see you on June 18th.”
Taken to My Mom
At dismissal, the secretary, Mrs. Whitmarsh, accompanied me to get my mother, who was coincidentally at the school with my little sister. I told my mom, “I got in trouble again.”
My mom gave me the Look. “What happened?”
I uttered, “I sent out an e-mail to my friend with these pictures. . .”
“PICTURES!” Mrs. Whitmarsh shouted. “They were disgusting and horrible! You are one sick pervert, young lady!”
I was shocked. I felt like crap being badgered by another adult in front of my mom. And my mom said nothing, as if Mrs. Whitmarsh took the words out of her mouth. I wouldn’t think that any parent would tolerate another adult yelling at their child.
My father went to the office for conference #4. It didn’t matter that I had been a good girl throughout the whole year because I was in trouble now.
Dad to the Rescue
I was buried in my tears. Mrs. Reznick was scolding me so hard that she looked like she was about to hit me. My dad stepped in and said, “The only person who should be yelling at my daughter is me. Yes, she did something wrong, but she is my flesh and blood and I will love her no matter what.”
That totally caught me off-guard. I cried happy tears. I wasn’t expecting him to defend me since he was so mad.
Even though he stood up for me in the office, when I got home, my dad smacked me on my head and confined me to my room for the weekend. We talked about what happened. He was just disappointed that I got in trouble two weeks before graduation. I felt like I deserved it because I had messed up again.
Finally, Some Understanding
On the positve side, my family hated Sr. Josephine and Mrs. Reznick. Now they finally understood that the teachers and principal wrongly portrayed me as being psycho. My older sister and father even agreed that I shouldn’t have gotten in trouble because I didn’t print out the pictures. But he still grounded me since I was in trouble at school. And my AOL privileges at home were gone forever.
There was yet another conference on Monday morning. Sr. Josephine and Mrs. Reznick wanted to meet with Cassie’s, Albert’s, and my parents to decide if we were going to graduate.
Unlike my dad, Albert’s father laughed about the whole situation. Albert, who’s Filipino too, wasn’t even grounded. It was probably because he’s a guy. Lucky bastard.
(Finally) Graduation!
Still, all that really mattered was that we got to graduate. During our commencement ceremony, I had a big smile on my face. I graduated with honors and a Presidential Award! It was such a righteous moment. I was relieved that I didn’t have to put up with those rigid teachers anymore.
Right now, I go to Martin Van Buren, a public school, and I’m doing my best with a 91% average. The teachers here wouldn’t care about the things I did at OLL. People here commit much worse acts, like throwing bricks at security officers.
A New Perspective
At OLL, I was unfairly attacked, but I still felt guilty because I should have been careful about the decisions I made and given more thought to the consequences of my actions. Now I’m more cautious. I don’t want to have my reputation tarnished again or not get into a good college, or even get expelled or suspended from school because I made a dumb decision.
I also never want to put my mom and dad through all that stress again. My relationship with my them is slightly better since I don’t get in trouble at school anymore. They’re still strict, but they trust me more.
I’m not worried about being sent to the Philippines because I have no intention of screwing up at Van Buren. I’m still not perfect though. I occasionally come home after curfew and get grounded.
A year has passed since I experienced all that drama. One afternoon, I was in the Village and I met the actress Camryn Manheim from ABC’s The Practice. I complimented her acting and asked for an autograph. She wrote me this message: “Break all the rules and raise some hell!” Ha! If she only knew.
Oops…I Did It Again!
About These Stories
YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.