Siblings in the System

The goal of the foster care system is to help out families in trouble, and, whenever possible, to keep those families together. That includes siblings. But when kids with brothers or sisters go into care, 75% of the time they’re not placed in the same home. That’s a huge number. And it can be a big problem, too-because sometimes kids really rely on their brothers and sisters for support.
To find out why more siblings are separated than are placed together, I interviewed Harland Kessaris, Carmen Veloz and Elsa Neilan, who are psychologists at St. Christoper’s Inc. I also interviewed Maria Troche, a social worker, and Richard Santana, a mental health coordinator, in the same agency. This is what they had to say:
Why aren’t more siblings placed together?
Maria: The reason siblings are split up so often is because there are not enough homes that will accept big families. I think if you have two or three siblings, they can often stay together. But four is the magic number. That’s when it seems like it’s a real problem.
Also, lots of families won’t accept older kids. Lots of homes only want little kids, like from 0 to 5, and it can be hard to place kids who are 10 and older, because foster parents often believe that they will cause more problems. So if there’s one younger sibling and one older sibling, it can be really hard to keep them together.
Carmen: Also, different-sex siblings are harder to place. Two sisters or two brothers can be placed in the same room, but different-sex siblings have to sleep in different rooms. Most people don’t have two extra bedrooms.
Maria: It’s also easier to place females than males because often times foster parents think males are more rebellious, so they’ll accept the girl but not the boy. Sometimes you can convince foster parents to make exceptions. I had a foster mother who had four siblings. They were all teenagers and she didn’t like to take babies. She was working so it was difficult for her. But then the biological mother had another baby. I convinced her to take in the baby also so they could all be together.
But it’s not often that you’ll find foster parents like that. And in the end, because there aren’t enough foster parents in general, they get to choose what they want. But when brothers and sisters are split up, we try for siblings to see each other weekly, or in some cases twice a week.
What are the psychological effects of splitting up siblings?
Harland: The closer siblings are, the more trauma we see when they are separated. Often residents who have the least amount of family are the most depressed and tend to have the hardest times. Those who have more connections, brothers, sisters, aunts, uncles, tend to have more friends in general, get married, have careers. It’s harder to be alone, and siblings can be existential allies.
Carmen: When children are close and they get separated, it’s definitely traumatic. You’ll see it when they come together for their weekly visits. They’ll be clinging to each other and staying very close physically.
You can also see them acting out in their new homes. But that gets tricky because it’s hard to know how much that is adjusting to a new home and how much is being separated from their siblings.
Elsa: My experience working with adults is that there is a tremendous desire later in life to get in touch with brothers and sisters, even if they never had the opportunity to get to know them when they were younger. And particularly if they were brought up in foster care and are now turning 18 or 19 and are on their own without a support system, they want to meet their siblings, maybe spend Christmas with them. They’ll say, “You knew my mother, we had the same mother,” and this becomes the attachment.
Being separated from your parents is a loss. Then if your siblings are divided into different families, that’s another loss. If you’re only 2 or 3 years old, you’re too young to really experience it when it happens. But when you’re 20, you’re going to feel it. From a psychological point of view, siblings are part of your identity, even if they’re negative and you want to get rid of them. They’re part of your history, part of your own self.
Are there times when siblings shouldn’t be placed in the same home or when it makes it difficult for kids when they are placed together?
Carmen: We advocate to keep siblings together. But if they’re fighting too much, sometimes they have to be separated. Sometimes there’s sexual activity going on that has to be stopped. Sometimes they blame each other for the problems in their family. It really can depend on what role each child played getting into placement. For instance, I work with one family where the middle child reported that there were guns in the house and that led to stress with the older child.
Maria: Often when kids come into care, parents tell the oldest child, “You’re in charge.” In the long run, I think kids resent being placed in a role that doesn’t belong to them. And if something happens to those siblings, then the older child can feel responsible and guilty. I think kids need permission to be angry. They’re told too often, “You have to get along.”
Carmen: I had a patient who took care of her younger siblings for nine or 10 years after her mother died. She told me about beating up her brothers and sisters when they wouldn’t eat. She just couldn’t handle the situation. She couldn’t deal with it. So having that much responsibility at that young age can be hard too.
Elsa: When older children are made to take care of their younger siblings it can be too much responsibility too young. It arrests their ability to enjoy being a kid. On the other hand, it can also develop nurturing and care, and they can get love from those siblings by being involved with them, so it all depends.
Harland: With the families I have, often the siblings are not that close. Their parents may have multiple partners, so they may be their half-brothers or half-sisters. They may also be full biological siblings, but that doesn’t mean they necessarily feel like brother and sister. People aren’t always close to their siblings and I’ve come to expect it. Who am I to say that’s wrong.
Sometimes kids have stronger attachments with people who aren’t part of their biological families. I worked with one family where the girl was 4 and her brother was 3. Initially the girl was pulled out of her mother’s home and put into a foster home, and she lived there for the first three or four years of her life.
When her brother was born he went into foster care, but to a different family. Then last year, the girl was pulled out of her foster home because they said siblings should be together. They lived like that for a year. But now the girl is going back to her original foster parents, and she and her brother seem to have little reaction to being separated. They may be biological siblings, but that doesn’t necessarily mean that they feel like brother and sister.
Maria: Part of the problem is that when children are placed in different foster homes where they are different rules and regulations it can be hard to reunite them later on because they’ve grown up so differently. There are cases where initially at least, they have a hard time learning to reconnect and starting to play. They can be distant with each other and they don’t always know how to act and how to play together.
Despite these issues, most people agree that most siblings should be kept together. What, if anything, can be done?
Elsa: I think the ideology is there. The foster care system wants children together. Everyone wants children together. But there are practical problems. Basically, there are not enough foster parents.
Carmen: I think we need more recruitment of foster parents, and I think the licensing requirements need to be revised. There are a lot of people who could be good parents, like older people, but there isn’t enough of a campaign to recruit them.

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.