A few weeks ago, some friends and I paid $6.50 for a bus ticket that landed us in the outskirts of New Jersey. We were dumped into what seemed to be some sort of wasteland surrounding a giant concert hall.
Shriveled trees lay at the sides of a small, winding dirt road, where greasy bald men stood gulping beer above a blazing grill. From there, we walked to the back of a seemingly endless line and, for two hours, waited in the freezing cold.
Finally, the entire line was herded like cattle into this huge monstrosity of a building only to face unbearable heat.
But when the lights dimmed and the curtains parted, all past miseries were forgotten. Korn was onstage and the crowd went wild.
Angry Music Gives Release
Now, to be totally honest, I hate Korn. I mean, I completely, utterly despise them. I have always chosen to listen to more upbeat, politically-oriented music rather than bore myself to death with the commercial, hard-core scene. The only reason I attended the concert was because I allowed one of my friends to drag me to see her “favorite” band.
As it turned out though, the concert was a lot of fun. I may not relate to that whole I’m-too-depressed-to-go-on scene, but it was very clear that for Korn fans, listening to the band’s angry music was a release. Seeing the excitement on my friends’ faces was enough to tell me that they were happy.
Plus, the show wasn’t as violent as I’d expected. Besides one man with a bloody eye, I didn’t see anyone get hurt. Yes, the band’s lyrics contained profanity and there was a bit of moshing, but the crowd never got out of control.
A Scapegoat for Society
Music with violent undertones, like Korn’s, has been under a lot of scrutiny lately. With all the school shootings last year, society is looking for answers, and music has become one of the top scapegoats. Many conservatives argue that angry, violent music is a bad influence on teens, corrupting our thoughts and making us immoral.
Robberies and murders are often blamed on what the media considers to be hip hop’s glorification of crime. And how many times have we heard the name Marilyn Manson or Ice-T related to violent teenage outbreaks?
For instance, when Dylan Klebold and Eric Harris murdered their classmates and one teacher at Columbine HS last spring, their interest in Marilyn Manson was immediately blamed as a reason for their violent persuasions.
In an interview in the April 1999 edition of Addicted To Noise magazine, Michigan State Senator Dale Shugars said, “We’re having an alarming rate of killings in school, and youth violence and an increase in drugs. I would say that though they’re not all to be blamed on a shock rocker entertainer like Marilyn Manson, I think he promotes it and can be part of the blame.”
Music Doesn’t Cause Violence
But there is no concrete evidence that music is the cause of violence.
In fact, statistics seem to show just the opposite. There has actually been a “decline in youth violence even as ‘violent imagery’ in the media has increased,” according to the Freedom Forum. Since 1994, violent crime by teenagers has dropped.
Still, many adults believe that if kids really love a band, it’s hard for them not to love, or fall victim to, the hate or anger a band expresses. Many teens report feeling just the opposite, though. They say that music releases their anger rather than inspires it.
Pain Expressed in Songs
As Nonye Gilliard Sullivan, the friend who convinced me to see Korn, explained, “Music is a great way to express your pain, your hurt. Even if you’re not the one to write the lyrics, listening to music is a great way to release all the pain, and I’d do anything to see a great band play because of that.”
Teens like Nonye feel that the violence reflected in songs reflects the discontent they feel. Nonye said she loves Korn partly because lead singer Jonathan Davis releases his rage so well. “When I go home, I can just turn on a Korn CD and it makes me feel so much better,” she said. “It feels like someone else has been through the same [things] as me, which is comforting.”
Although she does admit that certain kids and adults find mosh pits a negative part of Korn’s shows, she feels that moshing and violent lyrics are simply “ways for people to let out and express their anger.”
People tend to grab on to music that relates to them. The same way a happy person latches on to happy music, a depressed person clings to depressive music. To say it’s the other way around-that music determines our entire life outlook-is ridiculous.
Why Are Teens So Angry?
“With the whole Columbine murders, people just immediately assumed that because those two kids liked Marilyn Manson, they would go out and kill people,” said Vanessa Lee, an 11th grader who considers herself a rock fan. “I know tons of kids who like [Manson’s] music and would never do something like that. So it seems unrealistic.”
Unfortunately, when adults scapegoat music for teen violence, they don’t ask the real questions that could get at the root of the problem. Why are these teenagers so unhappy? What is wrong in their lives that makes them feel this way?
We shouldn’t ask what the lyrics say, but why they’re said. I don’t think there are any simple answers, but that doesn’t stop some people from taking the easy route.
Censuring Music
Unfortunately, blaming violent incidents on music results in attempts to censor music and restrict kids. Just after the Columbine massacre, for example, a school in Washington banned students from coming to school wearing trench coats.
Only days after the massacre, a Marilyn Manson concert was canceled. Later, 10 senators wrote to the company that owns Marilyn Manson’s label, Interscope, asking it to stop selling Manson’s CDs or any other “music that glorifies violence.”
City council members in Fresno, California, unanimously accepted a resolution which censures music promoting “anger and hate.” (A censure is an official disapproval of something and has no real power to make anything illegal or unlawful.)
But as Zebe Sakayama, an 11th grader, pointed out, the first amendment protects even violent music. “If you want to talk about killing people [in music], although that’s not my taste, it should be allowed. It’s called freedom of speech,” she said.
Banning violent music isn’t the answer. That won’t help kids deal with the anger they’re feeling. We need to address the real problem by asking why kids are unhappy instead of punishing them for being angry.
As 8th grader Anneke Simone explained, “They need to figure out what’s going on that’s making them angry, because until they fix that, nothing will be better.”
Don’t Stop the Music
About These Stories
YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.