They Just Don’t Understand

I have two best friends in my school. Gauri is from India and Loan is from Vietnam. Since Gauri and I are from the same country and religion, we have a similar culture, and we know how it is to be Indian and live with Indian parents. South Asian girls like us can’t do anything without our parents’ permission, which always seems to be impossible to get.
But sometimes Loan doesn’t really understand us. She knows that there are lot of things that Gauri and I are not supposed to do-like go to sleepovers at our friends’ houses, hang out with friends after school, go to the mall and shop on our own, go to movies, or stay late in school for school work, school clubs or any other activities. But Loan doesn’t know what it’s like to not have any freedom.
Having to Say ‘No’ to Your Friends
Many times, Loan would want us to hang out someplace, a few girls and guys, but my culture doesn’t allow girls to have guy friends. When Loan makes a plan, Gauri always says no, because she really respects her culture and doesn’t want to disobey her parents.
Every time Gauri says, “NoâI’m sorry guys, I can’t go,” Loan gets really pissed off, even though she knows the reason why. She doesn’t understand what it’s like to be an Indian girl.
Many girls have had this experience: They can be really good friends, like Gauri and Loan, but they can also face problems of not really understanding each other’s culture thoroughly.
And for the girl who says “no” to her friends and follows her culture, it can be hard to fit in.
Support for South Asian Girls
That’s part of why Sayu V. Bhojwani started a group called South Asian Youth Action (SAYA) three years ago-to give South Asian teenagers a place to go where everyone will understand how their culture affects them.
I think it’s important that everyone in the group is South Asian, because I know how lost you can feel sometimes with girls from different cultures who can’t always relate.
Somebody outside your culture may not be able to really feel your situation, and if they don’t know where you’re coming from, all they can do is say, “I’m sorry it’s happening.”
SAYA also runs a group that’s just for girls, which is called Girl Power, because South Asian parents are often less strict with guys than girls.
Shy Around Guys
There are about 100 teenagers in SAYA and 20-30 girls in Girl Power. South Asian teens come from all different parts of Queens, and go to SAYA about twice a week after school for activities, such as: volleyball and basketball, a mentoring program, tutoring, creative writing, a performance workshop and a discussion group.
Some activities are just for girls because, as Aparna Lall, the girls’ group coordinator, said, “A lot of times, girls get pretty shy or uncomfortable when guys are around, so we thought it will be a good idea if we leave some activities only for girls, to give them a chance to express themselves without any pressure or feeling uncomfortable.”
I know that feeling because I used to always feel shy and uncomfortable around guys, which always made it hard for me to present a project in front of the class or to talk out loud in school.
Speaking Their Minds
The girls in Girl Power get a chance to express themselves without feeling so nervous.
Promita Banik, 15, of Newtown HS, is in the conversation group, where the girls get a chance to talk about anything they want, like family issues, school problems, home life, success and the future.
When asked what she gets out of the group, Promita sighed as she said, “Good relief, because sometimes you just feel that you have to let everything out and this group gives you a good opportunity to speak your mind.”
When Promita first joined, after a friend encouraged her to, she didn’t know what to expect. “On my first day we talked about the family life-living with Asian parents and being an Asian, which I thought wasn’t something I get to talk about with anyone,” said Promita.
The members of this group feel pretty strong about being there and having the opportunity to speak their minds and discover themselves. Now, Promita said, “If I had to quit from the girls’ group, I’d feel like I had no place to go to or nobody to talk to.”
Dealing with Discrimination
At SAYA, both guys and girls also talk about discrimination they’ve faced and how to handle it. Last year, a few boys in the group made a video about it.
In that video, a teenage Bengali girl shares one of her experiences with racism. She explains how she and her friend were on the subway when a bunch of Hispanic guys called them names like Hindu and Gandhi.
Her friend got really mad and tried to fight back, but that only made things worse. The Hispanic guys beat her friend up.
“I tried to get help,” she said. “There were a lot of people in there but nobody stepped forward to help. People just stood there and watched while my friend got beat up.”
Expressing Themselves
Aisha Jafri, 17, who attends Forest Hills HS, said that teens who have experienced racism don’t usually get a chance to talk to someone about it. “By being here, I can talk to somebody,” Aisha said.
That’s just one of the things Aisha does at SAYA. When she goes after school, Aisha also does free writing, artwork and poetry. She gets to express how she deals with pressure from her peers and from home.
“I became a part of the group because I have passion in writing,” Aisha said. “Through that I learned to express myself better and also to work with others.”
For information on how to join SAYA, call 718-651-3484.

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.