As the bus my father and I were on turned the corner of 72nd Street and Riverside Drive, he turned to me and said, “We just passed a statue of Eleanor Roosevelt. Did you know that it is one of only three statues in New York City to portray a female?”
I yawned and sarcastically remarked, “Really? How un-PC, Dad.”
At first, the idea that there were only three female statues in New York just didn’t faze me that much. It wasn’t a huge surprise to me, like my father expected it to be. It seemed just like everything else.
Women have never been truly equal. We have made advances, but little things like this remind us that there’s still a long way to go.
87 Men and 3 Women
But the more I thought about it, the more it bothered me. Was it really true? I did a little research and found out the three statue statistic refers to the number of statues of female historical figures in city parks. (There are also a few statues of fictional females like Alice in Wonderland and Mother Goose.)
Besides the one of Eleanor Roosevelt, there are statues of Joan of Arc and the writer Gertrude Stein, according to Jonathan Kuhn, director of arts and antiquities for the New York City parks department. There are 87 statues of male historical figures in the parks, Kuhn said.
A statue’s purpose is to acknowledge the significant contribution a person has made to our society. Statues remind us of history and help to keep it alive. They help the future to learn from the past. They represent our role models. Statues are memorials to people we respect and admire.
Is It All About War?
So what does it say about our society that in all the parks of New York City there are only three statues of women, compared to 87 of men?
I started thinking about the many statues I have seen in my lifetime, in New York and elsewhere. Most of them were of male war heroes.
Next, I started thinking about possible reasons to explain why that was. All those monuments to war heroes tell us that our society admires bravery, patriotism, loyalty, sacrifice.
The fact that there are so many statues of soldiers partly explains why there are so few statues of women. For most of American history, women were not allowed to serve in the military. But are the qualities we attribute to war heroes the only ones we consider ideal? And is fighting in a war the only way to express those qualities?
More Than One Way to Be Brave
There are other ways to express bravery and patriotism besides fighting. There are even other ways to contribute to the war effort. Why isn’t there a statue of Clara Barton, founder of the American Red Cross, who as a nurse during the Civil War said, “If I can’t be a soldier I’ll help soldiers.” Why isn’t Rosie the Riveter, a symbol of the women who worked in factories, building ships and airplane parts during World War II, cast in bronze?
The “lion’s share” of statues of men in the city parks are of military and government figures, Kuhn said. But there are also a number of statues of male writers, composers and inventors.
If it’s not all about war, there’s even less reason for it to be all about men. It’s not hard to find a lot of women who have made important contributions to other fields.
Why aren’t there statues of great American writers like Emily Dickinson, Edith Wharton, Willa Cather and Zora Neale Hurston? Or artists like Georgia O’Keefe and Mary Cassatt?
Does the Statue of Liberty Count?
After I thought about it, I mentioned the “statue statistic” to just about every person I know. Most sounded surprised and said something along the lines of, “That’s not fair,” and swiftly moved on to the next topic. One person even tried to argue with me, saying, “You guys have the Statue of Liberty, the heart of New York!”
Yes, the Statue of Liberty is a woman, or rather a woman’s body. When I see her, I think of immigrants who came to this country for freedom. Then I think of how ironic it is that when people see this patriotic female figure, freedom is what they think of.
Women have not always enjoyed the freedoms that the Statue of Liberty symbolizes for people around the world. Women have been denied all sorts of things based on their gender-jobs, education, the right to vote, equal pay for equal work.
There are a lot of statues like the Statue of Liberty-statues of women’s bodies, but not of real women. They are used to represent concepts like freedom and victory or they are angels of peace, comfort or death.
Bodies Without Souls
Where do we see real women? On billboards, posters, in magazines, on television, usually selling items. Many of these women aren’t completely real, either-their images have been digitally manipulated. These women too are basically bodies; they’re being recognized for the way they look, not for what they’ve achieved.
Why don’t we recognize women for leadership or community service? If men have been most of the soldiers, women have been most of the teachers, nurses and social workers. It’s true that not many women have been elected to high offices. (We couldn’t even vote until 1920.) But women have played crucial roles in political struggles such as the civil rights movement and anti-war movements.
Some Statues I’d Like to See
It certainly isn’t that women haven’t done enough admirable things. We just don’t recognize them for it.
Marie Curie, the great scientist, won two Nobel prizes.
Juliette Gordon Low founded the Girl Scouts because she wanted young women to have the same opportunities to develop both inner and outer strength that young men were getting in the Boy Scouts.
Biologist Rachel Carson wrote the book Silent Spring, about the damage caused by pesticides, which is credited with kicking off the environmentalist movement.
Why aren’t there statues of them in New York City parks?
Women have been kept out of many things in the past and we’re still being kept out of history. The small number of statues is one way that women’s achievements and contributions are kept hidden.
Women Are Hidden From History
In school, in our history textbooks, there are but a few pages on things like the women’s suffrage movement. The rest of the pages in the textbooks are made up of stories about every single war, despite the fact that other events (such as ones that women dominated) may have had more of an effect on society.
We learn so little about women’s achievements that, even though this is something I’m interested in, I had trouble thinking of specific women who I think should be recognized.
Even though these statues are of people from the past, they have a huge impact on the present and the future. If there were more statues that conveyed women’s achievements, it would change the way we look at ourselves and maybe the way men look at us, too.
Seeing More Than Women’s Looks
We wouldn’t only be seeing women for their looks, which is what happens now, every time a person walks down the street, watches television, or picks up a magazine and sees an advertisement. We would be seeing women who have actually done something for society, not just women who are being used to sell something to society.
Yes, men are also showcased for their looks and bodies, but so many of them are recognized as politicians, heroes and creative geniuses.
If women were more often recognized for these kinds of achievements, then maybe they wouldn’t care as much about their looks and they would start to care about the contributions they can make.
It would be great to see an article in a women’s magazine titled, “10 Women Who Have Given Society a Makeover,” rather than “10 Women Who Have Been Given Makeovers.”
Remind Us What We’re Capable Of
Back home on the day I saw the Eleanor Roosevelt statue, I was reading a magazine to unwind. A Timberland ad grabbed my attention. It said something like, “Statues aren’t made so that we have people to look up to, they are made for us to understand what we are capable of.”
That’s so true. Women are capable of unfathomable feats. We don’t need statues to know that, but we sure do deserve them.
Put Women On A Pedestal
About These Stories
YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.