Do Caseworkers Listen?

May 20, 1999, was the night that ACS-the Administration for Children’s Services-first came to my house. I was 14 years old, and in the middle of a three day fight with my mother. You see, my mother and I were not really getting along, and she had moved into my grandparents’ house, leaving me a two room apartment all to myself.
When ACS found out about the situation, two caseworkers came to my house to investigate. At that time, I had never heard of ACS and I knew nothing about placement or the foster care system.
I thought the caseworkers were trying to lock me up in some type of juvenile delinquency home, because of the way they were acting. I felt that they were treating me as though I’d done something wrong. They didn’t seem to want to hear my side of the story, and were telling me that I needed to correct my behavior. When I tried to defend myself, they told me not to talk.
I Felt Like Nothing to Them
I felt as if I meant nothing to them, like my opinions and feelings meant nothing. At the time, I didn’t know that they were supposed to be trying to help me-that that’s their job. I thought that they only wanted the worst for me. I felt helpless. If I was about to enter a system where my opinions didn’t matter, how was I ever going to be happy?
Now I live in a group home and I know more about foster care than I did then. I know that ACS is supposed to be the Administration for Children’s Services, not the administration for parents’ and caseworkers’ services. The caseworker is supposed to be on my side.
Foster care is also supposed to be about putting us in a better situation than we would be in living at home. We are supposed to be given every opportunity to become successful. We can’t become successful if we are miserable.
If our caseworkers would listen to our feelings and try to make us happy, then maybe we would be able to focus more on making good lives for ourselves in the future, and focus less on our depression and unhappiness.
Is this fair?
Many of the other teens in my group home have had similar experiences with caseworkers. Like me, a lot of them don’t think their caseworkers take the opinions of youth seriously.
So I went to advocacy organizations who work on the kids’ behalf to make sure we get what we want and need during our time in the system. I wanted to see if the people at these organizations thought children in foster care were listened to enough by caseworkers and, if not, why. They had plenty to say.
Three people I spoke to were Chastity Garcia, who works at the New York Urban League Service to Families, which offers many services to prevent families from being separated through foster care; Karen Myers, who worked as an attorney for children at The Door in New York City; and Julie Dowling, a social worker who has been working for two years at an organization called Lawyers for Children, Inc.
The first topic I brought up to these women was about how placement decisions are made and if the child’s needs and wishes are considered. I brought this up first because when I entered the system, I felt like my wishes weren’t being considered.
Karen said that the teens she works with “are placed wherever there’s space.” This means that most teenagers are not necessarily put in a placement that is good for them. Maybe there’s simply not enough room or time to think about what’s best for each teen in the system. But there should be. The agency should find a way to locate a foster or group home that meets the child’s needs and wishes.
Chastity said that when possible, it is important to try to keep a child out of placement in the first place. But when a child does go into care, it’s important to talk to the child so that all of her personal needs can be met. For example, if a child wants, she should be placed close enough to her school, family and friends so that she can be comfortable with where she lives. Kids should not have to go out of their way to live their lives the way they normally would if they were not in foster care. Then again, if a child wants to be far away from her biological home, that should be taken into account, too. The point is: Kids need to be listened to.
All three of the women agreed that caseworkers don’t listen to the child’s opinions enough. This is probably the main reason why most teens in foster care have trouble with their caseworkers. Some of the women said this wasn’t because the caseworkers don’t like kids, but because they’re overworked and don’t have enough time to devote to each of their clients.
Karen said that she thinks that it is the system that is “dysfunctional,” not really the caseworkers. So here are tips from Chastity, Karen and Julie for agencies to improve the system:
o Always use placement as a last resort. Before a child goes into foster care, the caseworker should first try to have services provided for the family (like counseling or rehabilitation programs) to help the family stay together. The child should remain at home and a social worker should “check up” on the family every other day or so, depending on the case. If the situation still seems to be hopeless after a few months, then foster care should be considered. (Of course, if a child seems to be in any kind of immediate danger that preventive services can’t help, she would go into care sooner.)
o Get more caseworkers so that each one has a smaller case load. Caseworkers are given so many cases that they sometimes do not have time to deal with each one as individually as they should. In the end, caseworkers are only human beings and they can only handle a certain amount of work. Caseworkers, you should complain about this often-but take it out on your agency, not your agency’s children!
o Be more selective in hiring caseworkers and require them to have more than a college degree. Being a caseworker is a very detailed job. Agencies should require that all caseworkers are trained very well before they are hired. Also, supervisors should be trained so they will be able to pass their knowledge on to the caseworkers.
o Get caseworkers who like children. If a person does not like working with children and wants to become a caseworker, then they have chosen the wrong line of work. The foster care system is all about children and working with them! If you can’t work with children, then get out. You’ll do us all a favor.
If children’s living conditions in foster care are supposed to be better than their previous situation, then they should be made better. Remember, the system is supposed to help us succeed, and we can’t fully succeed without happiness. So all I have to say to every caseworker and agency out there is: These are our lives you’re dealing with. When we talk, you should listen!

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.