For years, Black and Hispanic teenagers have said they are unfairly stopped by the cops for no reason except for the color of their skin. I think that’s true. But I always wondered, “Is our feeling right?” Well, a recent report by the state attorney general’s office confirms the suspicion.
The study found that Blacks and Hispanics are much more likely than Whites to be stopped and searched by New York City police officers. In fact, Blacks are stopped six times more often than Whites. Hispanics are stopped four times more often.
Harassing Blacks and Latinos
Blacks make up 25% of the city, but 50% of those who are stopped are Black. Whites make up 43% of the city, but only 13% of those stopped are White.
Most people are stopped in poor, high crime neighborhoods-the ghetto-where most residents are Black or Hispanic. But even taking into account the higher crime rate in minority neighborhoods, cops still stop Blacks and Hispanics too often, according to the report.
When he presented the report, the attorney general, Eliot Spitzer, criticized police for stopping and searching too many people in some neighborhoods, creating resentment and humiliating innocent Blacks and Hispanics in the process.
Denial is No Answer
Of course, the police denied it. The police commissioner, Howard Safir, said the study was flawed.
Officer Tyler, a youth officer in the Bronx’s 52nd precinct, said he does not think that the cops purposely go after Blacks and Hispanics. He said the police will only stop people when they have “probable cause,” meaning they can’t stop you without a real reason.
But probable cause can be something very small. Under Mayor Giuliani, police have increasingly stopped people because of minor infractions, like jaywalking (who doesn’t jaywalk?) or disturbing the peace. Once they stop you for something minor, they’ll search you, looking for drugs and guns.
Teenagers often say they’re targeted just because they’re hanging out on the street with their friends or because of their “thug” clothes. But not every group of kids on the corner is selling drugs.
Since many cops are not from the neighborhood they patrol, they may think people look more suspicious than the people who live there think they do.
We’re Not All Thugs
“Here in the Bronx, most of the kids on the street, hanging on the corner, are Blacks and Hispanics. [We’re not targeting them.] If we stop them, that’s because they look suspicious, like they’re up to something,” Officer Tyler said.
But I think minorities who live in bad neighborhoods sometimes get stopped because the cops can’t always tell the difference between teens standing on the corner hanging out and drug sellers selling.
Who stands on a corner by himself, looking around doing nothing, unless he’s waiting for someone to buy? But a lot of teens just hang on corners because they want to be out of the house, chillin’ with their friends. I can tell the difference, because I know what to look for, since I have lived in the Bronx all my life.
They should train the cops not to jump to conclusions, to observe before they decide to stop someone, and to show respect.
Study Proves Minorities Right: Cops Do Target Us
About These Stories
YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.