Try to remember when you were a tot playing with your friends in the playground, and you were excluded from a game they were playing because of something you were wearing or something you said. The feeling of being left out is something that can break a person down. Lots of times, kids who are gay or transgendered and in foster care are similarly excluded and abused, sometimes every single day.
When I was curious about treatment of gay kids in foster care, I went straight to the source. Gary Mallon, a professor at the Hunter College School of Social Work, started the Green Chimneys Program for Gay, Lesbian, Transgendered and Questioning teens. There are only two such group homes specially for gay kids, the one in New York and one in California.
Mr. Mallon explained that often, trouble starts for gay kids at home. Don’t get me wrong, there are parents who are loving and supportive, but, Mr. Mallon said, often “families send a clear message that they don’t want that [a gay kid] in their family.”
It can be even harder for minorities, who already experience discrimination. Some Black parents of gay kids have even confided to Mr. Mallon, “It’s bad enough we’re [discriminated against for being] Black, I’m not going to have [a gay kid] too. I’d rather have a drug addict as a child, because there’s treatment for that.”
Kicked Out!
Studies show that half of all lesbian and gay youth say that their parents have rejected them because they’re gay, according to an article in the October 1998 issue of Youth Today. Then when they go to school, it’s a bad situation all over again. The same article reported that gay kids are five times more likely to have been absent from school because of fear about safety, and more than four times as likely to have been threatened with a weapon at school.
At Green Chimneys, Mr. Mallon said, about one-third of the kids got kicked out of their biological homes onto the mean streets for being gay. Another third left for lots of different reasons, but often the problems could be traced back to the fact that they were gay. The last third went into foster care a long time before finding out they were gay, Mr. Mallon said.
The Abuse Continues
Once kids get into foster care, lots of times the abuse continues. Physical abuse is a serious issue in group homes. Mr. Mallon said he gets four or five calls a week about gay boys from the New York City area getting beat up.
Mr. Mallon acknowledged that often “kids are mean to kids who are different from them,” but, he said, “the real problems are with the staff.”
That doesn’t mean that all staff are homophobic. Sometimes a staff member really helps a gay kid open up.
But too often, Mr. Mallon said, “[staff] start quoting from the Bible,” or say, ” ‘Don’t talk about that crap,’ ” and take out their own personal issues on the kids. That sets the tone that it’s OK to harass gay kids.
ACS May Get Taken to Court
A January 1999 lawsuit filed by the Urban Justice Center on behalf of gay, lesbian and bisexual youths in foster care charged that because of their sexual orientation, gay kids are routinely subjected to physical violence and psychological abuse in NYC’s child welfare system.
For technical reasons, he lawsuit is on hold, but it helped make the Administration for Children’s Services in New York wake up to the fact that staff need to deal fairly with gay and transgendered kids. Since the lawsuit was filed, ACS has mandated staff to participate in a day-and-a-half of training to help them learn how to treat gay and transgendered teens more fairly.
But to tell you the truth, one and a half days won’t change a person’s mind on an issue of that much importance. More still needs to be done. Everyone should be treated equally, in all group homes. And there should be more group homes nationwide just for gay and transgendered kids.
Because frankly, if gay kids in group homes are getting beat to a bloody pulp, it should not be tolerated.
Sidebar:
How Staff Can Create A Gay-Friendly Space
o Say the words “gay” or “lesbian” as something that’s positive. Kids hear the word “gay” used as a negative word all the time.
o Staff and foster parents can have books or posters about being gay. (Green Chimneys can provide you with posters.)
o Straight kids need to be told that it’s not OK to call people “f-ggot” or harass gay kids. Talk to all kids about accepting differences. When staff set a tone of acceptance, kids are more likely to follow.
o Try to match gay kids with roommates who are accepting of their sexual orientation.
o If a kid tells you that he or she is gay, talk about it! If you ignore it, you send the message that gay kids need to hide.
What Straight Kids Can Do to Help
Sometimes straight kids in care are afraid that if they’re friends with a gay kid, other people will think they are gay, and will harass them, too. Still, plenty of straight kids take that risk. If you want to help your gay friends, you can:
o Speak positively about gay people if you are around someone you suspect to be gay.
o When people are putting down gay kids, ask them to stop.
o If your friends want to talk about being gay, listen. Let them know you are glad they were able to trust you enough to confide in you.
Nowhere to Run
About These Stories
YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.