Mother Knows Best?

Mother and I have always had a complicated relationship. And I used to be, without a doubt, the most difficult teenager on Planet Earth. No, I never smoked, drank or ran around with the “wrong crowd.” In fact, my morals were the one thing my mother wasn’t worried about. But we used to fight-no joke-every single day. Every single day.
We fought about my attitude, my grades, my moods, my lack of friends and, especially, my weight.
I Couldn’t Communicate
Junior high was terrible. I had such a problem communicating my feelings to people, especially mother. I still have the most trouble talking about emotions I don’t want to recognize in myself-weakness and need. I kind of have this idea in my head about the “ideal” person, you know, and whatever emotions don’t fit into that mold, I don’t want to talk about.
I also didn’t think anybody would understand me. I considered myself a complete nerd. I was overweight, wore glasses, had braces, yadda yadda-you know, I had everything that the typical popular teen doesn’t have.
I kept to myself most of the time. I liked to read and write, and I didn’t socialize much. I never went to parties (not that I was invited). In the 8th grade, I had a group of about four good friends, and I really didn’t talk to anybody except them.
My Mother Wants the Best For Me
My mood swings were definitely a problem, too. I could be cheerful one moment and furious the next. I took everything the wrong way. I was paranoid, hateful and lonely. No, I wasn’t crazy. (Though it kinda sounds that way, doesn’t it?) I just had a lot of personal problems.
All of this made my mom worry about me. My mother wanted me to have a better life than she did. She grew up in a small town and felt really trapped there. She was her high school’s valedictorian and won a scholarship to college because, as she says often, “that was my only ticket out of my town and into the world.”
She likes raising her kids in the city because we have so many more “opportunities” than she did. She wants us to be better off than she was. And, yes, she also wants me to be pretty. She thinks that being pretty will help you in life, and it will generally make you feel better about yourself.
Food Became a Battleground
But I was overweight. I redefined the term junk food addict. I ate cookies after school, a bowl of ice cream practically every night, and candy bars throughout the day. So from ages 12 to 14, mother and I fought about food.
I think back, sometimes with fondness, to the days when I didn’t care about how I looked. When Mother and I passed a Lotto newsstand, I would always beg her to let me buy some Skittles, Snickers, Jujubes or whatever fit my mood.
My pleas for junk would lead to hushed arguments on the street, both of us speaking sharply through tightly pressed lips, until Mother gave in, slapped a dollar into my palm and tapped her foot angrily as I skipped into the newsstand to purchase my sweets.
No wonder I was fat, right?
Sick of Being the Same Old Nerd
My mom didn’t approve, especially when my bad eating habits started to show. I paid no notice to her or to her worries about my weight and my health -I didn’t care, so why should she?
But she did. Besides my looks, she also didn’t want me to get fat for health reasons.
Mother always said that when I got older, I’d hate her for letting me eat so badly as a teen. She was partly right – except that I turned my hate on myself.
By 9th grade, I was sick of being the same old nerd. I was determined to create a new image for myself. I changed my hair, got rid of my glasses, tried to stop being so shy, and went on a diet. I knew I could look better, do more with myself.
Finally, I wanted to stop eating junk-not because my mom wanted me to, but for myself. So I decided, “You know what? I’m gonna lose weight no matter what it takes.” I was determined, but realistic.
Weight Loss Was Hell
Usually, when people go on diets, they say, “OK, I’ve gotta lose 20 pounds, or else!” But I didn’t feel that way, at least not when I started.
At first, I just thought, “I’ll see how this goes. I’ll just see.” I wasn’t even really unhappy with my weight yet, so I didn’t feel an enormous urge to change my body. But I figured, why not?
As anyone who has gone through the hell of weight loss can tell you, it’s not easy. Mother, however, was thrilled by my efforts. I joined the nearby gym, and although my working out did show good results over time, “hell” is the only appropriate word to describe it.
I worked hard, though, and in one year, I lost 40 pounds.
Have I Really Changed?
I used to think that if I lost weight, my whole life would magically improve. I was right, but also wrong. Sometimes now I think, what has really changed?
Guys didn’t flock around me then, and they don’t flock around me now. My friends liked me for who I was then, and they like me for who I am now. If you think about it, my life hasn’t changed.
But I think I have. I feel more confident around people, especially around guys. I feel better about myself knowing I’ve transformed my body, as my mother always tells me.
I also feel better because I’ve come out of my shell a lot, too. In 6th grade, I had always kept mute-fear of rejection overwhelmed me. I was always afraid of being laughed at or stared at incredulously if I said something dumb.
People Actually Listened
Slowly, though, I made a few friends, and when I realized that they were willing to listen to what I had to say, I began to want to say a lot more.
They gave me the confidence to speak up in class, too. When I started high school, I told myself, “All right, so what if they laugh at you? How much will this matter in 10 years?” And it worked.
Getting thinner also made me feel more confident being in the spotlight, and having people look at me. My reformed appearance coaxed along my reformed personality, and vice versa. The two went hand in hand.
Now people describe me as loud, outgoing and funny. If you had told me four years ago that I would soon get pegged with these descriptions, I would have laughed and gotten out the straitjacket.
Mother is thrilled by my transformation. She says that when she sees my 7th grade picture (which is displayed on her dresser, much to my dismay), she can barely recognize me. I love hearing this. It reminds me of how much I’ve changed.
‘Just 20 More Pounds’
Even so, losing weight has had its drawbacks. Around the middle of last year, I started to feel like my weight had become a full-blown obsession.
My idea went from, “I’ll just get thinner than I used to be,” to, “I must get thin, period. Not thinner, but thin.”
Now my mom tells me that I don’t have a realistic sense of how thin I am if I still want to lose a lot of weight. But I don’t believe her. I’m still going at my diet. “Just 20 more pounds,” I tell myself, “and then I’ll stop this dieting and these relentless workouts.”
There’s part of me that wants to slap my former self across the face. “How could you?” I want to say. “You ate so much crap and it wasn’t worth it. Mom told you that you’d regret it, why didn’t you listen?” If I had listened, maybe I could have felt better about myself a long time ago.
I’m Not Perfect, But I’m Better
Before, I was never happy with anything about myself. I was annoyed at myself for not being more popular, having guys like me, and so on, but I never seriously thought about my body like I do now.
Truthfully, I still can’t look in the mirror without cringing. I know I’m prettier than I used to be, but then again, I don’t think that says much.
But even though I may not love myself now, I do feel more confident about who I am-both physically and emotionally.
My relationship with Mother has definitely improved. I don’t eat terribly anymore, so she has no reason to yell at me for my food consumption. I am getting good grades, which satisfies her, and I have friends and a social life, which relieves her.
Because she doesn’t have to worry about me as much anymore, I feel I can get to know her more as a person. And I know my mom trusts me.
I’m not one of those sullen pseudo-James Dean type kids. We have a pretty good relationship. My mom and I go to movies, shopping, stuff like that. We’re not best friends, believe me, but we hang out, and sometimes we have great conversations.
My Mom and I Can Talk
Recently, I finished reading Gone with the Wind (the movie is one of my favorite classics), and since the novel was my mother’s favorite as a teenager, we could really talk about it. That made me feel like my mother sees me more like an equal now, and not just a kid.
I’ve matured, too, and can better judge what is worth a fight. I know that if my mother is in a bad mood, it’s got nothing to do with me, and I let her vent. But I do retaliate when she hurls direct insults at me.
I’m happy to say that Mother and I have not been in a screaming fight in months. But it’s the little things that really bother me. A few weeks ago, I got a B on a physics test for which I’d studied extremely hard. (If you haven’t had the privilege of taking physics yet, it is a hard class.)
When my mother asked me what grade I got, I told her, figuring that this was not a grade I had to hide.
When she heard my grade, her face scrunched up, and she responded with a careful, “Oh. Is that all? I guess that’s fine, I don’t know, I guess I assumed you’d do better.”
In a way, her comment was flattering (she said she thinks I can do better than a B), but it infuriated me.
Instead of Blowing Up, I Think
“You know,” I said, “I was pretty thrilled with my grade, considering the difficulty of the test. And I don’t think you should talk, since I’m sure that if I gave you the test questions, you would have no clue how to do them.” (An immature argument, I admit, but one I use often.)
I’d rather Mother just say “That grade sucks!” than be all wishy-washy about it, using phrases like, “It’s good, but…” I have absolutely no patience for the “well, um” strategies that she uses to “spare” my feelings-what she says still hurts.
But now, instead of blowing up, I try to keep my feelings to myself and keep the peace.
I haven’t exactly come to terms with the word love, at least regarding Mother, but hate is no longer in my vocabulary when I’m around her. I like to say I’m neutral. I can be civil, and no one gets hurt.

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.