“Whiteboys”: This Wanna-Be is Off the Hook

Just recently, we went to see the movie Whiteboys, which stars Danny Hoch as Flip Dogg, a teenage White boy who has the illusion that he is a Black person.
The movie is about Flip and his two White friends who act like they’re from the hood: they talk slang and they want to be rappers. They live in Iowa in a small town with only White people, where the main sources of income are a local factory and the cornfields.
But they plan to go to Chicago to see some thugs. Flip really believes what he sees in rap videos, and he wants to live in the hood. He sells drugs, tries to rap and does everything else he can think of to fit that stereotype he has of Black people being gangstas.
No doubt he and his friends have the talk and the so-called act down, but how could they possibly understand what the thug life really means? We discussed the movie afterward.
Cheryl: Flip really thought he was Black! On the inside he really wanted to be Black because he felt sorry for what his forefathers have done to us in the past. Everybody thought he was playing around, but he was really off the hook.
I didn’t like it, the movie wasâI don’t know, I would say it was cornyâ to me.
At some points I felt I took offense. I was like, What?! You know, like the stereotypical Black rapper, with gold chains and guns and the liquor and the violence, and the White boy was just rapping about “Yeah son, yeah son! I’m a thug, I’m rappin’ straight out of the ghetto!”
It was just a movie about stereotyping Black people and White kids in Iowa acting like how they think Black people act.
I’m glad that I didn’t pay for it because I would’ve been uptight! It was really so stupid that it was funny at some points.
Phillip: Yeah, at some points it was funny, like the way that they were talking, and you don’t really expect White people to speak that way in a hick town in Iowa. And they was all on some old hip hop, Master P, ’bout it, ’bout it. I agree with you that the stereotype was just dumb and you could tell they tried to make it funny.
Cheryl: Flip really had me dying because he really looked nice in his clothes! He was all matched up like a regular “Black boy” and I may sound stereotypical about the way a “Black boy” should dress, but I am just using the general view.
He used to have these visions of rappers and guns and girls-that’s the kind of thing I didn’t like, yo. At one point [in his fantasy] he went to jail. They were in the lunchroom and he was with the rapper Snoop Doggy Dogg at this table, getting shrimp and something to drink and all kinds of stuff-in jail!
He’s like, “Guard, come over here, I’m thirsty!” The guard came over and gave him some wine from 1960-something and he was like, “This was a bad year!” And he got up and the pimp slapped the guard in his face. And the whole jail was in an uproar: “Yeah! Yeah!”
Like that’s what Black people do-they hurt somebody and everybody just jump up and be happy about it.
The last 10 minutes really did it up. They had their fame because they finally got the nerve to pile up in a car and go to Chicago.
Flip really wanted to sell cocaine and be a drug dealer and have drugs and guns and b-tches! He wanted to live the lifestyle of a Black gangster rapper. But when they got there it wasn’t at all what they had expected it to be like. Everyone else suddenly became kind of on-guard, but Flip remained himself, just chillin’.
They wound up truly in the middle of the ghetto in these projects, Cabrini Green. That’s what I didn’t like. Everyone knows Cabrini Green is a bad neighborhood. But this was just like the stereotype! Gangstas on every corner. No regular people going around. The movie was making fun of what was going on there. But it’s also real!
Phillip: He got into trouble with, um, drug dealers and plus, he was White and they’re not used to dealing with White people and they thought he was a cop, so he got beat up.
Cheryl: Because he didn’t have enough money!
Phillip: Yeah, how much did he have? $160.
Cheryl: He had $160 and they took it from him and they beat him up and bruised up his face and whatever, and this Black guy that they met up with when they got to Chicago-finally, after a long interrogation, he agreed to take them to someone he knew so that they could get some cocaine to go back to sell in Iowa-the guy’s friends were the ones beating him up. Finally the guy that brought him there pulled the other guys, his friends, off of Flip.
When he intervened, the drug dealers went in the back to get their guns since he stepped to them. When they went in the back, Flip and the Black guy ran out and once they reached outside, they ran into the hands of police. The Black guy got so scared, he tried to run.
Phillip: Yeah, the police shot him in the back.
Cheryl: The bullet went through to his chest and he died. Flip had a very hard time dealing with what had just happened. He couldn’t understand why it was that when he tried to be Black, Black people called him “Whiteboy,” and they hated him, when he felt as if he could identify with them. In the end the White boy decided to live a regular life. Not one with guns and drugs and whores and money. He realized that he should be himself.
Phillip, you’re not talking!
Phillip: That’s because I’m listening to you talk!
Cheryl: Yeah but you’re not saying nothing!
Phillip: At the end of the movie the writer made the point that acting “Black” was just the stereotype that a lot of people have. I think that the movie was trying to get that point across, but since they used a lot of humor, I think people wouldn’t be able to see it as clearly.
The message to me was that maybe not all White people are “Black haters” because some White people even admire us.
With the last scene where Flip gets beat up-I found another message too. I got the feeling that maybe the author wants us to see what we do when someone wants to hang out with us. They beat Flip up just because he was trying to identify with them and they didn’t give him a chance to explain, maybe, what he was trying to express. There is a two-sided problem that is going on.
Cheryl: At first I thought it was geared to Black people who follow the stereotype. Maybe it will wake them up, maybe they’ll be like, “We really act like that?” I thought it was just pointing fun.
Now I think it’s about how you shouldn’t try to portray the image of somebody you just don’t know.
Phillip: I think it was trying to show how things shouldn’t be put in a race category: “That’s Black music, that’s White music.” And the movie didn’t come out and say that, but it showed that everyone in the movie had this picture in their minds of what a White person should be and Flip or his friends didn’t fit that picture.
Cheryl: None of the things you’re saying have anything to do with what we are talking about. The question is, “Do you think that the movie was stereotyping to show people that it was wrong, or as a joke?”
Phillip: The movie made the topic funny because it made the movie better, but I don’t think they purposely made a joke of it.
Cheryl: I didn’t like the fact that the movie was sending mixed messages. I think the movie didn’t try to break down the wall of stereotype that they had in the movie-they just let it live on. From what I understand, Phillip got the idea that the stereotype did not prevail because Flip’s dreams were torn apart.
Phillip: It showed how stereotypes are mostly wrong-sometimes right, but mostly wrong-or mixed with wrong and right. But there are consequences for stereotypes: misjudging people.

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.