Cops vs. Teens

Police officers are supposed to serve, help and protect people. People are supposed to respect, honor and trust them. Perhaps in a different place at a different time. But today in NYC, relations between New York’s finest and the public, especially teenagers, are worse than ever.
Teens may have always disliked police officers because they are authority figures, but because of aggressive new police tactics and high-profile brutality cases, those feelings have intensified. Most teens I spoke to said they don’t trust or respect police officers. Many also said they believe that cops are racist.
We Don’t Trust the Cops
Some teens even said they would be reluctant to go to the police for help.
“I really don’t trust them. If I had to go to the police for something it would definitely have to be something big,” said Matthew Mack, 16.
Only one person that I interviewed had a positive attitude towards the cops. Eileen, 19, from Brooklyn, said, “I trust them to protect me because that’s their job.” Eileen is planning on becoming a cop herself.
A more common view of the police was expressed by Simon, 18, from the Bronx, who said that in his neighborhood, “Everybody calls them mother f-ckers.”
I think this is frightening. People need to feel they have someone to turn to in danger. But many people say they think it’s the cops who are dangerous. In a recent New York Times poll, one-third of Blacks said they had been in situations where they feared a police officer. (Only 11% of Whites said they felt that way.)
Brutality on the Rise
This lack of trust is partly a result of media coverage of the Amadou Diallo and Abner Louima cases. These men were both Black victims of police brutality and, justifiably, their cases have stirred up a lot of hatred towards the cops.
But it’s not just these two brutality cases that are making people more fearful of the police. Because of Mayor Giuliani’s aggressive police tactics, more people are being stopped and searched. That’s why, according to a recent New York Times poll, more than two-thirds of Blacks believe that the policies of the Giuliani administration have led to an increase in police brutality.
Statistics back this up. In the past few years, more people have been filing complaints about police misconduct or brutality. In 1994, 1,759 brutality complaints (officially called “notices of claim”) were filed. Three years later, in 1997, 2,266 claims were filed. And police brutality lawsuits have cost the city $96.8 million to fight or settle over the last four years.
Cops Slow to Discpline Themselves
This might be partly because, as a result of the media’s focus on police brutality, more people are speaking up. It may also be because more people are being brutalized by police officers. Even so, the police department and the mayor do not seem to be trying hard enough to resolve the issue.
Police Commissioner Howard Safir has been criticized for being “slow to impose discipline in cases” of police misconduct and “for failing to act in many cases in which the review board found credible evidence of misconduct,” according to the Times.
I had read about brutality in the paper and heard about it on TV. But when I interviewed teens in New York, I was surprised to learn that some teens have had negative experiences with the cops first-hand.
Hearing about their experiences made all the talk about cops and race become more of a real issue to me. For the first time, it wasn’t something I only heard about on the news.
‘They Treat Their People Better’
Victoria Alverez, 17, from the Bronx, said she’s witnessed how some cops are racist. “My brother got arrested for something unfair. And when he was getting beat up, other cops saw and did not do anything to help him because he was Hispanic,” she said.
Another teen, Rafael, said that he had been treated unfairly by the cops because he is Hispanic. “I ask them for directions, they tell me to go one way. A White person asks them, they give them different directions. Get the hell out of here,” Rafael said.
Both Victoria and Rafael felt that race was the only reason for the unfair treatment.
Other teens agreed that race plays a big part in how cops treat people. “Most cops are White and they treat their people better,” said Margie, 17, from Queens.
“They protect, but they get away with murder,” said 15-year-old Michael, from Staten Island.
Media: A Reliable Source?
While some teenagers, like Victoria and Rafael, have had personal experiences with the cops, others form opinions based on what they see on the news or hear other kids talking about. I don’t think these are always the most reliable sources. The media is a billion-dollar business that makes money off of people’s tragedies. Of course it blows things out of proportion!
So while I think the coverage of Diallo and Louima was deserved, I also think the media gave them extra attention because their stories would get strong reactions from people.
I’m not sure the media covered all sides of these stories, but it’s their coverage of the Diallo and Louima cases that has shaped many people’s opinions. Matthew Mack said that, because of what he’s seen in the media, he doesn’t think police officers treat Whites and minorities equally.
“I don’t have any first-hand knowledge, but from what I’ve hear I would say no,” Matthew said. “They’re always stopping Black people driving cars. That’s what I’ve heard. I don’t really see it.”
And 20-year-old Stephanie, from the Bronx, said, “When you watch the news, they don’t be treating them equally.”
Show Bad Cops and Good
Because the media can so easily ignite feelings of hatred and anger in people, I think it has an obligation to be more careful.
Lately, it seems like the media has been attacking the entire police department because of the Diallo and Louima cases. Now reporters constantly question Mayor Giuliani about police brutality and focus on his relationship with the police force. Many websites are devoted to the victims of alleged racism of police officers, and newspapers frequently poll citizens about their feelings towards cops. All of these things are important.
But the media can also try to pay attention to the positive things individual police officers do, so that the negative actions of a few cops don’t unfairly influence how we feel about the entire department. What about all the good things police officers do?
Police officers gamble their lives for other people every day. By focusing on some heroic things the police department has done, the media would give people the opportunity to judge police officers on both the good and the bad.
Solving the Problem
In the end, though, the media can’t really solve the problems between cops and teens, they can only influence how we feel about the problems.
So what can be done to improve the relationship between police officers and teenagers? This is a question that needs to be answered because in some neighborhoods, especially minority communities, young people hate the cops. So how can this problem be solved?
The cops have created some programs that help bring community members and the cops from their precinct together to discuss people’s feelings toward the police. These programs can help break down stereotypes-either about the cops or from the cops-by opening communication.
Many teens feel that without communication, there can be no understanding between police officers and young people. “The police need to make people aware of what they do, and just talk to them,” said Nii Ato Bentsi Ebchill, 16, of Roosevelt Island.
Others said that it’s not just communication that needs to be improved, but that police officers need to start treating people-especially minorities-with respect. “If they stop harassing people, maybe people will start respecting them,” said Jasminda Johnson, 17, of the South Bronx.
Obviously, it’s a big problem when some cops use their power to hurt rather than protect. This makes everyone feel a little less safe.
And when the actions of a few cops make us believe that all cops are racist, we can start to see racism in everything they do, even if that’s not exactly fair.
Don’t Stereotype All Cops
I have never been stopped by the cops myself, but I have had an experience with the police that makes me doubt if I can trust them. My father was once attacked by two guys on the street. A police car was parked on the same block, occupied by two police officers who saw the whole thing but didn’t do anything to stop it.
Finally, someone ran over to the police car and started yelling at them, so the officers reluctantly got out and broke up the fight.
Their reluctance to help was not race-driven, because my father is White and the police officers were White. But if my father was Black, I probably would have felt that the officers didn’t help him because of race.
When a few cops brutalize minorities, it can change the way we perceive all the cops.
Are some cops racist? Yes. Is police brutality real? Yes. And yes, the victims of police violence are often Black and Hispanic. But I think we need to be careful not to stereotype all cops the way we think they’ve stereotyped us.

SIDEBAR: ‘Driving While Black’: Cops Admit to Targeting Blacks
Many teens say they believe cops are racist, and when I asked them why, they usually mentioned Amadou Diallo and Abner Louima, two Black victims of police brutality. Unfortunately, there is another reason to believe that cops are racist: profiling. Profiling is when cops stop and search people purely because of their race. Many people say police stop minorities for “Driving While Black.” Blacks have often said they’re both angry and embarrassed to be treated as constant suspects because of their race. And recently, that suspicion was confirmed by Federal Justice Department investigations in Maryland and New Jersey.
Cops Told to Stop Black Men
In 1992, Maryland State Police officers illegally searched and jailed Robert L. Wiliness, a Black lawyer. This violated his constitutional rights-because the officers had no reason to search him-and it became a highly controversial case. When the Justice Department investigated, Maryland agreed to keep detailed records of all stops and searches of drivers and vehicles. These records showed that 77% of the drivers who were stopped and searched between 1995 and 1997 were minorities. But these drivers were no more likely to be guilty of anything than the Whites who were stopped. “The officers were following department guidelines that explicitly singled out Black males who drove expensive cars and carried beepers-a description that fit doctors, lawyers and businessmen,” according to The New York Times.
Black Cops Profile, Too
It wasn’t just White cops who profiled, either. “I see a 16-year-old White boy in a Benz, I think, ‘Damn that boy’s daddy is rich.’ I see a 16-year-old Black, I think, ‘That boy’s slinging drugs,’ ” said Robert Richards, a Black police sergeant from Baltimore, quoted in The New York Times Magazine. Profiling has more damaging effects than embarrassing its victims-if more minorities are searched, more are likely to end up behind bars. That may be partly why Blacks make up only 13% of the country’s drug users, but they are 74% of those sentenced to prison for drug possession, according to David Cole, a law professor at Georgetown University.

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.