I recently finished reading the novel If Beale Street Could Talk by James Baldwin and let me say just two words: great book! It is such an amazing piece of literature that I think everyone, not just teenagers, would enjoy it. It has a great mix of drama, intrigue, passion and suspense.
The story takes place in New York City in the ’70s. It centers around two teenage African-American characters, Clementine Rivers (whom everyone calls “Tish” for some unknown reason) and her boyfriend Alonzo Hunt (whom everyone calls “Fonny” for another unknown reason). Tish is pregnant by Fonny, who’s in jail on a rape charge. Tish narrates her life as it is now, and how it was before Fonny was put away. She flashes back to the first time she and Fonny met, to the first time she visited his loft, to the first time they made love.
A Family Feud
Tish’s family is very supportive of Tish’s pregnancy. They will stick with her through thick and thin, and I think that’s wonderful. They all took the news well, which is more than I can say about Fonny’s family. Mrs. Hunt, Fonny’s mother, is very religious so she, of course, throws God into the argument. After a vicious confrontation, the Rivers and the Hunts become enemies.
Then Fonny is accused of raping a blond Puerto Rican woman named Victoria Maria San Felipe Sanchez in the vestibule of her home on Orchard Street. Officer Bell, the cop who arrested Fonny, claims that he saw Fonny run from the scene. But it’s just about impossible to run from Orchard Street (which is near the East River) to Fonny’s home on Bank Street (which is near the Hudson), especially if the police are behind you. Still, Fonny is later arrested at his home.
Victoria flies to Puerto Rico not too long after the rape but that doesn’t stop the Rivers from seeking out the truth to know whether Fonny really did rape her. Sharon, Tish’s mother, agrees to fly to Puerto Rico to talk to Victoria to see if Fonny really did rape her. Victoria says that she was raped by a Black man, but when she is asked to point out her attacker from a police line-up, Fonny is the only Black man there!
Did He or Didn’t He?
Not only that, but Officer Bell is known for being a racist. He had a confrontation with Fonny a while back when Fonny almost beat a man to death who was trying to sexually harass Tish. Luckily, an Italian woman told Officer Bell why Fonny was attacking him and the officer let him go with a warning. So for all we know, Officer Bell probably set Fonny up. He had to have been off-duty that night because his beat is on the West Side, not the East.
In my own opinion, I think it was a setup. I don’t believe that Fonny raped Victoria. He seems like the type of guy who has respect towards women. Besides, he loves Tish too much to ever do that to her. I do believe that Officer Bell set Fonny up.
How it does turn out I’m not going to tell you. But I will say this: If Beale Street Could Talk is a great novel and once you start reading it, those 213 pages will just fly by-they did for me. I would definitely recommend this book to everyone I know, including you!
“If Beale Street Could Talk”
About These Stories
YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.