My Dating Disasters

At least once a week my whole family will be eating dinner when my mom brings up the subject of boys.
“You need to meet people.”
I know exactly where she is heading with that opening line. My parents often ask why I don’t have a boyfriend, and my mother even goes out of her way to set me up with the most peculiar guys in New York.
Amongst the oddest, she’s introduced me to a plumber, a second cousin of mine who barely spoke English, and a guy I suspected of belonging to the mob.
When she gets going, I just remain silent, hoping she will drop the topic.
“I promise you’re going to like Ralph.”
“No, mom, that’s OK. I’ll do fine without Ralph.”
“I’m just asking you to talk to him. What are you so afraid of?”
“Nothing.”
“Good, then I’ll tell him to call you sometime.”
“No, Mom, just leave me alone.”
At this point my little brothers are laughing at me and I’m irritated, but relieved that the conversation is over.
Looking for a Good Jewish Boy
Unfortunately, the following day (and this has happened more than once), I will come home from school and Ralph will be sitting in my living room. I’ll have no choice but to speak to the spastic butcher.
My mom’s concern was sweet at first but now is just plain annoying. She believes that her getting married at 28 was embarrassing, and that I will be making a big mistake if I wait that long.
I constantly repeat to her that she grew up in a different time, and that all of my friends are not married like many of hers were at 17.
However, she doesn’t accept this, and continues on her quest to match me up with a guy-not just any guy, but a good Jewish boy.
One of my mom’s favorite ideas is for me to pick up guys by walking around the yeshiva school on my block during Jewish holidays.
“Helen, go put on that pretty dress of yours, it’s a Jewish holiday.”
“So, we don’t celebrate any Jewish holidays.”
“Yeah, but if you could just walk around the school, you’ll meet some sweet Jewish boys. Just walk around the school a few times, and smile.”
Am I the Only Single Girl?
Not only am I troubled by my mom’s constant prying into my personal life, but sometimes I feel like I’m the only person who thinks that since I’m only 17, having a boyfriend shouldn’t be such a big concern.
All my friends have grouped into couples and my only single friend obsesses about finding a girlfriend and begs me to go around school finding him dates.
This bothers me because I don’t want to lose the last single friend I have, and because girls around school are getting suspicious of my approaching half a dozen girls at once and asking for their phone numbers.
Seriously, though, when I see the way my friends act as a couple, I sometimes feel jealous, but I also feel scared.
Grocery Shopping and Bingo
The other night, I called two of my friends, Eddie and Milissa, who have been going out for a year.
We were supposed to go out that night, so I suggested a concert. They suggested going to the bank and then grocery shopping.
I suggested a movie, they suggestedâbingo? Now that blew me away. Is that what a serious relationship does to people?
They are 18 years old, and a year ago would have laughed if they knew what they would say to me that night.
It’s as if through their one-year relationship, they both gained 20 years.
But frankly, I know it’s not them, it’s me. I just don’t want a boyfriend, because when I try to have one, it doesn’t work out.
A Dating Disaster
The first real relationship I ever had was with a guy named Michael.
He was one of my closest friends and I didn’t know any better, so we risked the friendship hoping to gain something more.
I guess I decided to go out with him because I was struggling with a lot of problems at the time and I thought it would be easier to cope if I had a boyfriend who I could call in the middle of the night.
I believed that a boyfriend could be there for me in a way a friend couldn’t, but the truth was, I didn’t like Michael as a boyfriend.
He was one of my best friends, who I respected and thought was cool, but he was not a guy I crushed after.
I Lost a Boyfriend and a Friend
When I realized I wanted him only as a friend, I ended the relationship, but we remained friends. After we broke up, we spent even more time together than before.
Unfortunately, everyone realized before I did that he was only sticking around hoping I would change my mind.
Once I told him that the situation wouldn’t change, he stopped being my friend at all. I felt rejected, even though my friends said I rejected him.
I guess I didn’t realize how hard it would be to go back to being friends.
Losing a boyfriend and a close friend in a matter of weeks was one of the most painful experiences I’ve had as a teenager, and it made me more cautious about guys.
A ‘Special Relationship’
After that, I didn’t think I should have a boyfriend for a while. Then a friend of mine made me a proposal that seemed perfect. Cory was a distant friend whom I secretly crushed on.
One night on the phone he suggested we try a “special relationship.” This ideal relationship consisted of us hanging out sometimes and fooling around, although we wouldn’t be dating because neither of us wanted to have anything serious.
I figured that since I liked him, I should go for it, so I gave it a try.
This proved to be a terrible experience. When we hung out one wild day, we both got a little carried away. Immediately afterwards, I felt dumb that I had ever gone along with such a foolish idea, when I knew it would only lead to trouble.
After that, I told Cory that I didn’t think we should fool around again. We haven’t spoken since.
Finally-An (Almost) Perfect Guy
Well, it was starting to seem like I would never find someone who would make me want to have a boyfriend.
Just recently, however, I did meet a guy who I actually wanted to have a relationship with. He seemed perfect: a great sense of humor, intelligent, talented and understanding.
I spoke to John on the phone for hours every night. I felt lucky that I had found a guy who I could really talk with.
There was one huge problem: John is 28-that’s 11 years older than me. He also happened to be my guitar teacher, which made things even more awkward.
Despite the large age gap, I thought something could work out, but I decided I should talk to my mother about it. I was pretty sure my mother would be against my dating such an older guy, but I didn’t want to sneak behind her back.
I wanted a relationship which I could be honest about.
My Mom Said No
Approaching my mother was extremely difficult, but one day after school I sat down with her and told her that I needed to talk.
She automatically expected the worst, so she was relieved that I was coming to her for advice about John, rather than telling her something terrible had happened.
Talking to my mother wasn’t as bad and awkward as I had assumed it would be.
She said she didn’t think I was ready to date a guy in his late twenties, and that she didn’t want me to do it. In the end, I decided she was right.
Now John and I are somewhat friends, but realistically, I think our friendship-and our teacher-student relationship-is coming to its inevitable end. For once, though, I don’t think this experience was all bad, because I value the time I did get to spend with him.
Flying Solo
And in a lot of ways, I’m glad that I haven’t been serious with anyone. I believe teenagers shouldn’t get into serious relationships, because they need space to grow up on their own.
Many of my friends in serious relationships have let someone else shape them far too much.
They have given up their friends, let their boyfriend’s or girlfriend’s interests take over and forgotten their own, and they don’t do anything on their own anymore. It’s as if they have lost their own identities.
Most of my female friends from high school now act as if they are married to their boyfriends, and they tell each other what they can and cannot do. It sounds like having another parent.
So even though I sometimes wish that I’d had one good experience, I’m also not sure that I want a boyfriend at all for now. I like having my own space. I like to hang out with all my friends, and I like to be by myself.
Maybe once I find a guy who I really like and can trust, my feelings will change. But I’d like to grow up a little more on my own before making a big commitment.

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.