When you first see Angelica (not her real name), you’ll see a quiet girl who likes to sit back and observe. But if you talk to her, you will see beyond the reserved look she carries in those sad brown eyes.
Angelica and her older sister were raised by their mother, who left her abusive father and struggled to raise her children without a job. Her mother didn’t start working until two years ago. You can imagine the stress rippling through this household without money.
Angelica admires and loves her mother for keeping everything together.
“I give her respect because that wasn’t easy. She would always find the time to take us places, whether it be to the playground or the museum. I don’t think I would’ve been able to do something like that,” Angelica said. “My father was a drunk who used to hit her. She had the sense to get out of that. She’s a good person.”
However, Angelica’s household wasn’t always a home sweet home. They used to fight constantly. Simple arguments would culminate disastrously in full-blown fights.
No One Knew When To Stop Fighting
“Things would be thrown. Everything just kept escalating, no one knew when to stop,” Angelica recalled. “I was either hit by a belt, smacked in the face, hit in the leg with a broomstick. Twice my mother choked me.”
Afterward, Angelica said, she felt terrible. She would wonder why this was happening to her. “I wanted to die. I felt a complete emptiness,” Angelica said.
The fighting drove Angelica to move in with her father when she was 12. Half of the time her father was drunk, so he really didn’t know or care about what was going on in Angelica’s life. He gave her unlimited freedom, and she took advantage of it.
“I would stay out late. I even started experimenting with drugs, mostly pot,” she said.
Now, two years later, after her father got them evicted, Angelica is back with her mother. Like most families, they have their ups and downs, but they have both matured in many ways.
Once in a while they’ll still have fights, but never like before. Still, when her mother gets angry, a whole list of names pops out of her mouth.
“I try to ignore that, but sometimes I do wonder if I am what she says I am: ‘Good for nothing,’ ‘Piece of sh-t,’ ‘I don’t care if you never come home,’ ” Angelica said.
Sometimes Angelica thinks hurtful words can be more abusive then hitting.
“Name calling can be real deteriorating,” she said. “A bad word will stay in my mind, but a scab will fall off.”
Although she thinks she was abused as a child, and in some ways is still being abused by her mother, Angelica said she understands where her mother is coming from. When her mother was growing up, her parents used to hit her a lot, too. That was the only form of discipline she knew.
“It was just passed on from generation to generation. It’s like a cycle,” Angelica said. “There are parents who did get hit by their parents when they were growing up and who don’t hit their kids, but sometimes it’s hard if that’s the only form of discipline you know.”
Still, Angelica’s mother was hitting her because her own emotions were out of control. That’s abuse.
Many people consider it abuse if you ever raise your hand to your child. Others think that if you don’t get physical, you are not giving the child proper discipline. But what is the difference between abuse and discipline, and where do we draw the line?
When I was growing up, my mother would slap me into reality once in a while. I think her method of discipline worked like a charm (I mean, just look at me-joke). But first, she would always talk to me about the problem.
“Rubie, you know I don’t like when you do thisâ” She’d leave it at that.
Then, a week later, when I would make the very same mistake: “Rubie, don’t you know how to listen? I’m letting you off easy this time. But I’m warning youâ”
A couple of days later, terrible child that I was, my mother was either prohibiting TV or spanking me with the belt. Never did she make me bleed or leave a mark, though.
I think if she didn’t hit me, my behavior would have gotten worse over time. She had to correct that-and she did. But I know that other people might say my mother’s hitting me was wrong.
Respect Without Fear
Many people believe that any kind of hitting can and should be considered abuse. From interviewing other teenagers, it seems that kids whose parents didn’t hit them believe that children can be disciplined with milder punishments and turn out fine.
“What can a 5-year-old do that’s so bad you have to hit them?” exclaimed Sylvia.
And Alexis said, “My father didn’t hit me, so I respect him, not fear him.”
These teens disagreed with any type of physical discipline. Instead, they suggested other methods that would get children to think about what they did wrong, and teach them a lesson at the same time.
They thought parents should punish kids with earlier bed times, extra chores, shortened TV time, time out, and by explaining why what they did was wrong.
“Try to have an understanding of where the child is coming from. I think it is important to understand why they’re disobeying you,” Jane reasoned.
Some teens said that hitting a young child might make kids think that it’s OK to hit another person when they don’t do what you want. They also believed that hitting a child may cause them to resent their parents.
In Our Cultures, Hitting Is the Norm
When Melanie and I were interviewing, we were surprised that some kids felt that way, because we see our parents hitting us as something they did for our own good. In our cultures, discipline was mandatory, respect was expected, disobedience not tolerated, and hitting was the norm.
It was hard for us to put ourselves in the shoes of teenagers who have had a different upbringing.
Likewise, it’s difficult for them to imagine being hit or screamed at, and to believe that a parent could hit a child and still say, and mean, “I love you.” People have different values, different opinions.
It’s hard to know what kind of effect hitting a child has. If you hit your children, will they walk the straight and narrow? Or will they become the rebels, the violent ones? The same question can be asked for kids who aren’t hit: Are they more likely to get along with their peers, not bring their parents pain or heartache? Or will they run wild?
Communication Is the Key
These are questions we can’t answer. But we can say that there is definitely a difference between discipline and abuse. Parents should never hit kids when the parent’s emotions are out of control. And if a parent is constantly hitting the child for any reason, then it’s abuse.
Regardless of how we were brought up, the one thing everyone we talked with agreed on was that communication is the most important factor in child rearing, because it builds trust. Children should feel like they can come to the same parents who disciplined them for support or advice when they need it, without fearing their parents’ response.
Instead, parents should make it clear that everybody makes mistakes, but that broken rules result in serious consequences. In other words, home should be practice for the real world. Kids should be praised when they’re good.
Even little “angels” act up now and then. But parents who treat their children with respect, by taking time to talk to their children and explain why they should or should not do something instead of saying, “Because I said soâ” will be respected by their children as well.
And parents should be consistent: once they make a rule, it stays a rule. Otherwise, kids can think they’re being disciplined not for doing something bad, but because the parent is in a bad mood. That doesn’t teach kids the difference between right and wrong.
Consistency and communication are important whether or not parents think hitting is OK.
When Is Physical Punishment Too Much?
Still, once parents start hitting their kids, it can be confusing-for parents and teenagers-to know where to draw the line between appropriate and excessive punishment.
When Moises Lopez was growing up, he used to beat up other kids at school and talk to girls a lot. If his mother found out, he would get hit by the belt.
Moises’ mother always talked to her son and gave him lectures about the wrong things that he did. But when he got out of control, she never hesitated to physically punish him. Moises believes that without this discipline, he would’ve been a criminal.
“I would’ve felt like no one can stop me. I would’ve done whatever I felt like doing,” he said.
But in some of the examples Moises gave, the punishment sounded excessive.
One Saturday, when Moises was at the table with his family, he asked his mother if he could go out with his friends that day. She asked him if friends were more important then family. Moises, angry that she didn’t want to let him go, said yes, his friends were more important.
His mother was so shocked and angered by his response that she slapped him. Then she went and got the belt, brought it to the table and sat down. By that point, Moises was so upset that, even though he was hungry, he said, “I’m not going to eat no more.”
His mom said that if he didn’t eat, she would hit him.
Ignoring her warning, Moises pushed the plate of food away. His mother hit him with the belt.
Learning by the Belt
After that, Moises went to his room and began to think about what he had said, what he had done. He realized that what he had done had hurt his mother’s feelings, that next time he would be more cautious expressing his anger. Moises believes he learned this by being hit.
“Parents should use the belt when the child says something stupid, make them think about what they said, make them understand that what they did was wrong,” Moises said.
But if Moises had been grounded, couldn’t he have learned the same lesson? Maybe, maybe not.
At times while he was talking about his mother’s discipline, Moises seemed confused about whether or not it was right for her to hit him.
He recalled a time when his mother used to punish and hit him often. At that time, it seemed like his mother was hitting him not because his behavior was worse, but because she was under stress.
“She could’ve at least taken away my privileges. She didn’t have to hit me as much,” Moises said.
Moises’ opinion seemed to go back and forth. At one point, he said that hitting doesn’t work, it just makes things worse.
“I wouldn’t hit my child except if the child is acting pretty bad and not listening. I would probably just take stuff away that he likes,” he said.
Other times, Moises said that he’s glad that his mother disciplined him the way she did. His mother hit him when she felt it was necessary and now look, he’s a good guy.
In the end, Moises’ confusion is our own: We would like it if parents didn’t feel they had to hit their kids, but we understand why our own parents taught us lessons with the belt, and we’re not sure whether this cycle-even if it is not as dangerous as the one Angelica saw in her own family-can, or should, change.
Getting the Belt: Is it Discipline or Abuse?
About These Stories
YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.