Welfare. It’s a system put out there to help the people. A lot of us need welfare. A lot of us also abuse it, scamming the system or just growing lazy.
Either way, if you’ve ever been to the welfare office, you know that most of the people who work there treat us-the people on it-like garbage.
I say us because I too receive welfare, and it’s tough. I don’t receive it myself. My grandmother gets it for me, because she’s still my legal guardian. But soon I may start receiving it myself, when I move out of her house and start going to college.
You’ve Got Two Options: School or Work
Now the government has created a new system called workfare, so you have just two options-school or work.
In theory, it’s a good idea. Everyone should work. In practice, it’s more complicated.
If you choose school, you’re lucky if they say OK, ’cause they don’t always.
If you choose work, they want you to look for a job on your own that can maintain you and a family. But sometimes that’s impossible, when mainly all that’s out there if you don’t have an education are minimum wage jobs.
How can you survive off of that if you have to feed more than two mouths?
If you fight with the system, you’re given more appointments to return to the Begin office-the workfare office, where you’re supposed to find a new beginning.
A Workfare Office-A View From the Inside
Recently I visited a Begin office to see it with my own two eyes, and it wasn’t a pretty sight.
Some of the case workers had real attitudes. Other times, it was the welfare recipients who depressed me.
It scares me to know that soon I’ll have to do this myself, when I’m already trying to handle school and any part-time jobs I can find.
So here’s what my eyes, ears and mind opened up to:
I go to the Begin program on 55 Willoughby Avenue in downtown Brooklyn.
Inside it is crowded. I see a lot of Black women, some Hispanic women and a few White women. Almost all of the chairs are occupied.
Near the reception desk up front a TV plays the Jenny Jones show. A lot of people are engrossed in the program.
Mothers call their children back to their sides. Kids play with one another or stare aimlessly. One child screams just for the attention.
All around me I hear fragments of conversations.
Frustration in the Air
A Jamaican lady tells another lady, “Sweetheart, I’m stressed and this place ain’t helping any.”
A Hispanic woman with short hair says, “They have attitudes. If they don’t want to do their job, they shouldn’t be working.”
A case worker walks through the door. He seems frustrated. He’s Black and bald with a mustache. He calls out “McKenzie, Jones.” Everyone looks up but no one responds.
The phones are ringing off the hook. People keep arriving. Some get mad and just leave. At the reception area you hear numbers being called out.
You become a number.
I fidget in my seat. I don’t like being in this atmosphere. Some of the people I see are so laid back, as though they had no worries and all the time in the world to spend in this office. One lady behind me relaxes, with her eyes closed, calm.
Waiting All Day
I hear a mom call her daughter, “Tamika, come here, come on now.”
Every time a case worker calls out a name from the files in her arms, Tamika’s mom calls out, “Next, next. Call me. I been here all day.”
Her older daughter’s also there and I think to myself, “Now why isn’t that girl in school? Isn’t school still on?”
The room is stuffy and hot. I ask the lady next to me, “How long you been here?”
She says about an hour-since 12 p.m. She says that it’s always the same.
“You could have an appointment, but you’ll still wait forever ’til they see you.”
The lady’s name is Donna. She’s 30.
She’s a full time college student, and a mother of a 6-year-old. “Between school and raising my daughter, I don’t have time to work,” she says.
‘I Don’t Want to Make Minimum Wage’
Welfare pays her tuition, but, she says, they’re giving her a hard time. She wants a bachelor’s degree and they don’t want to pay more than two years of college expenses.
“I look at it as an investment,” Donna says. “I have to sacrifice so that when I get my degree I can make more money. I don’t want to make minimum wage.”
After I interview her, I notice a happy, chatting group amidst the frustrating atmosphere. I approach one woman. Her name is Angie. She’s 38. I ask her why she’s here, if welfare sent her to work.
She says, “I work. They didn’t send me to work. I’m on welfare to get a subsidized check-a partial payment every two weeks of a lousy $80.”
I can’t believe it-what could she possibly do with that?
Angie says, “The money isn’t great…but the medical coverage helps.”
Angie has three kids and she’s been receiving welfare for five years.
I tell Angie I came over here because she and her friends looked so cheerful.
“That’s because we talk to each other,” she says. “If not, forget it. Welfare is a hassle.”
People Sigh, Babies Cry
I go back to my seat and voice my frustrations. Donna says she heard the receptionist snap at the ringing phone, “Why they have to call to make appointments? Why can’t they just come in person?”
For what? To sit around and wait?
Donna adds that some lady had asked for help and the case worker told her, “Not now. I’m hungry. I’m going to lunch.”
Someone behind me complains about a young mother with three kids who just walked through the door.
“If you know welfare’s like this, why keep having children?” she says.
Another replies, “They like to spread the legs. What they gonna do when welfare is extinct?”
I look around me and it’s like a buzz starting up. I hear sighs and yawns. Babies cry. Children ask, “Mommy, when we leaving?” Tamika’s mom calls, “Tamika come here, come now.”
One lady stretches and yawns and starts muttering, “What they think, I got all day?”
‘These People Treat You Like Garbage’
I look over, and I tell you, she looks good, like she’s doing well financially. She’s got on name-brand clothes, her hair just recently done, long fake acrylic nails.
Then I look at her toddler in the carriage and her baby in a dirty sweater stained with juice, jeans that don’t fit-they’re so loose-one sneaker off and a gray sock that I assume was once white.
What did she do with the money? Doesn’t she know she’s receiving it for that child? I just stare at her.
Michelle, 21, who has two kids, says, “You know these people treat you like garbage and you have to take it.”
Tamika’s mom leans over and says, “It’s stuff like this that make you wanna hurt ’em, kill ’em. They know you here all day and they make you wait, wait, wait. You get so frustrated and disgusted, you want to leave and you just can’t. You need to feed your family.”
Do Workers Want Us To Leave?
It’s two hours since I’ve been here and I’m frustrated like the other women in this room.
It’s like this department wants these people to actually get fed up and leave-giving them reason to terminate cases and cut off needed public aid. After all, this is the welfare reform program-they want these women to work.
But many mothers are here with their children, and there is no one else to watch them.
There aren’t enough daycares or licensed sitters. Daycares with openings refuse these women services because of too many late government payments.
Our mayor promised to spend 28 million to open new daycare slots so that welfare recipients can work. What happened? It seems to me that our mayor’s promises are full of holes.
“The welfare treats us like cattle,” Donna says. “They are inconsiderate to mothers and their children.”
It’s true-you sit in this stuffy waiting room all day, waiting to be seen, and don’t know if you’re going to hear good news or bad.
The truth is, though, I’m confused.
Why Should Welfare Help Us?
Why should welfare help with so many out there abusing it? A lot of these people cry about wanting to go to school, but they dropped out a long time ago. Now they want an education?
Then there’s the young mothers who also try to apply for S.S.I., pretending that their children are disabled. Don’t these mothers know the label they’re placing on their children? Disabled: Can’t work. What’s that?
And don’t forget the ones who receive the welfare check, yet work 40 hours off the books. These are the ones who cry that they can’t work. Of course not, where are they going to find the time?
Is It Our Fault We Don’t Have Money?
Maybe that’s why these people in this office are tortured this way-maybe the government wants you to think about the reason you’re here.
Welfare is getting very strict and things are getting harder. Maybe they need these long screenings and check ups to see who deserves help. But the government shouldn’t be cruel and turn people away, threaten and hassle us when we need help.
I’m on welfare-I want it to help me, so I don’t abuse it. I want to be given the option to choose for myself if I’d rather work for little money or go to school and learn to be a better, stronger, more independent person.
I don’t know. Is it our fault that we live in a rich society but we don’t have money? The world is a hard place to make it. Everyone struggles, not everyone makes it to the top.
We are like salmon in the river. The strong survive. Others die trying to make it up the stream.
Well, this is welfare: Either take it or leave it.
One Day In a Welfare Office
About These Stories
YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.