State Can’t Monitor City Group Homes, Let Alone Whole System

Ever wonder how so many kids can get abused in the foster care system with nobody seeming to notice? Well, if you look at the latest plan to reform New York City’s troubled child welfare system, you might start to see why.
The latest reform plan depends heavily on the Office of Children and Family Services. This small, little-known state office is expected to both strictly monitor the ACS and urge the city to cooperate with the reform plan. Now that’s a lot to ask of any small agency, but, as The New York Times suggests, to ask it of the Office of Children and Family Services is like waiting for Mariah Carey to become your foster mom. That is, we’ll be waiting a long time.
In the past, the Office of Children and Family Services has suffered staff shortages and has been unable to carry out it’s basic mission-to check up on foster care in the city. For instance, the law requires every group home to be inspected once a year; but state workers check only about half of New York City’s 400 group homes each year. So many group homes have not been visited, that in an internal memo, the state described the health of thousands of group home residents as “a critical concern.”
As if that’s not bad enough, records show that workers review only 39% of the city’s child abuse deaths within the legal deadline of six months, leaving stacks of fatality reports untouched for months, sometimes years, without any decision made on whether or not a child’s death was the city’s fault.
If the state office is so overwhelmed by its workload, many people wonder how it could possibly monitor the city.
Last month, perhaps in response to this concern, state officials agreed to give the office more staff members, to create a new regional office that would focus solely on New York City, to review all child abuse deaths promptly and to conduct nine audits (examinations) of the city’s operations over the next few years.
We’ll see what happens.
Source: The New York Times
-Baudilio Lozado

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.