New Adoption Bill Makes It Harder for Foster Kids to Reunite With Their Bioâ

Which would you rather do: get adopted or return to your biological parents? Whatever your answer, you should know about the federal Adoption and Safe Families Act (ASFA). This law gives extra child welfare money to states that get more kids adopted instead of reuniting them with their birth parents. But under ASFA, the state doesn’t get any money when a foster child returns to his or her biological parents. And most controversial, ASFA speeds up the process by which a parent loses his or her parental rights. Once someone loses their parental rights, they can never get their child back.
It doesn’t take a genius to see what this means-under ASFA, it could be much harder for foster children to return to their biological parents.
The Child Welfare Action Center has been proposing ways to make the law more fair for biological parents and foster kids who would like to reunite. For instance, they suggested that the money gained through adoptions should be used to help reunite other families.
Gays and Lesbians Charge Mistreatment in System
Joel, now 13, already considered himself gay when he entered the New York City foster care system at age 9. Since then, according to yet another lawsuit against the ACS, he has been thrown down a flight of stairs, had his nose broken twice, was hit in the face with a broom and had his shoulder blade broken, mostly because other kids thought he was too feminine. As if that wasn’t bad enough, staff members at several group homes and a large residential treatment center rarely defended Joel or tried to stop this abuse.
So on January 15, with Joel and five other gay teens as plaintiffs, a lawsuit was filed on behalf of gay, lesbian and bisexual teens in New York City foster care. The lawsuit charges that gay, lesbian and bisexual teens are regularly physically and mentally assaulted because of their sexual orientations (a situation which Foster Care Youth United has written about for several years in more than a dozen stories).
Jonathan Cole of Columbia University, who volunteered to approve of Joel’s appearance in the lawsuit (as required by law because Joel is a minor), told The New York Times, “These are youngsters who are at great risk and who in effect are being put out on the street because the city simply doesn’t have any mechanism for handling gay and lesbian kids.” Experts say that this problem is nationwide, affecting children in the system as young as 9 or 10 and contributing to countless runaways and suicides.
Leonora Wiener, a spokeswoman for the city’s Administration for Children’s Services (ACS), said she could not comment on the lawsuit, but told The New York Times, “We are working on the issues concerning gay and lesbian foster children on several fronts.”
The lawsuit calls for foster care facilities to be especially staffed and programmed as “safe houses,” and for staff training to make all placements safe and supportive of gay, lesbian and bisexual children.
Right now, only one specialized program exists for gay foster teens among more than 60 foster care agencies in New York City: Green Chimney’s Gramercy Residence in Manhattan, a group home that serves only 35 boys, ages 16 to 21. Ms. Wiener said the city plans 11 more group home beds and, last year, began staff training on sexual identity.
EDITOR’S NOTE: This case was recently dismissed because the city had made a previous deal with another group that sued the foster care system. Under that deal, the system has immunity for two years from any further class action lawsuits.
Source: The New York Times
-Baudilio Lozado

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.