Are Kids Going Into Foster Care for No Good Reason? Recent Lawsuit Says “Yes”

Under New York State law, children can’t be removed from their homes and placed in the foster care system unless their lives or health are in “imminent danger.” (“Imminent” means about to occur soon.) But that’s not what’s actually happening, says a group of New York City parents.
In a recent lawsuit against New York City’s Administration for Childeren’s Services (ACS), these parents charge that some kids are being taken from their homes for less than good reasons. The lawsuit also charges that the foster care system is failing to provide services, like counseling, which could help keep families together.
Some people think that this alleged problem of kids being removed too quickly had its beginnings in 1996. Back then, in an attempt to reform New York City’s child welfare system, Mayor Rudolph Giuliani’s administration decided it was more important to protect children from possible danger than to keep their families together.
Some child advocates liked this shift from preserving the family to protecting the child. They felt that too often children had been left in homes where they were eventually abused or killed.
But some parents say the city has gone too far. Theresa Logan, who is part of the parent group filing the lawsuit, claims that her kids were taken from her simply because she refused to have one of them evaluated for a special education program. Another parent says she lost custody of her grandchildren because her landlord failed to take care of her apartment’s rodent problem and crumbling ceiling.
The ACS says that children are only removed when there is good reason to believe they are in danger. “In every case, a hearing takes place in family court, and after evidence is presented a family court judge makes a final decision about the removal,” said ACS spokeswoman Leonora Wiener to The New York Times. But some city caseworkers feel the charges in the lawsuit have some truth, saying that they often feel pressure to place children in foster care even when those children appear to be in no immediate danger.
“The message is, ‘When in doubt, take them out,’ ” said Faye Moore, an official with the union representing child welfare caseworkers, as quoted in The New York Times.
Whether or not this lawsuit will go forward remains to be seen. Because of the recent settlement in Marisol vs. Giuliani, a previous lawsuit against the system, the ACS has immunity from new lawsuits.
Source: The New York Times
-Baudilio Lozado

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.