Several years ago, when Jinan, 20, was still living in China, his grandfather ran a church that the government didn’t approve of, and Jinan encouraged his friends to go there.
In China, the churches are run by the government, and people who try to open their own churches risk being put in jail. Jinan was caught and was going to be sent to a juvenile jail.
Because he didn’t want to go to jail, Jinan decided to escape from China and come to the United States. But he didn’t have any papers, so he came illegally.
A Long, Hard Journey
Jinan’s friends helped him contact people who could help, but the journey was not easy. Because he was crossing borders illegally, he had to go wherever he could, making a path between different countries, like Thailand and Guatemala, in order to get here. His journey lasted about one year.
Now that he is here, Jinan lives with his uncle, who is his only relative in this country. His family is still in China.
Jinan is in high school, takes computer classes, and works part time in a grocery store. He and his uncle live in a small apartment with a lot of people; there are nine beds in one bedroom.
Some of the people work upstate and on Long Island, and only use the apartment during holidays. But when they’re there, Jinan even has to share his bed because it is so crowded.
New Hopes and Dreams
Jinan hopes to achieve his goals in this country and take advantage of the opportunities it offers him to work and study.
“I want to be a doctor because they can save lives. And also I [would] like to study computers,” he said.
He is also hoping that one day he may be able to receive his papers in order to live here legally.
The United States sometimes gives permission for illegal immigrants to stay in this country legally-it’s called being granted asylum-if they can prove that they have been victims of persecution. Sometimes they also simply grant a certain number of illegal immigrants the right to stay here, without proving anything. This is called amnesty.
Jinan is hoping that the United States will grant him asylum or amnesty, too.
Right now, though, he does not know if they will, so he is living here without legal documentation.
Even though Jinan does not live in very good conditions, he says he likes living in this country: “This countryâoffers a lot of opportunities, and also freedom.”
Many immigrants come to the United States because their countries do not offer them the opportunities they dream of. Often they cannot support themselves or their families, or they want a better education.
Teresa, 18, came here four years ago from Guatemala, where the only good schools are private, which she could not afford; in the public schools, the teachers were always on strike.
“I came to this country to study and have a career because this is the place of opportunities to those who want to progress and succeed in life,” said Teresa (not her real name), who does not have legal documents to be here.
A Place of Opportunities
Others, like Jinan, come because they are escaping persecution for expressing their religious beliefs or political opinions, or because they are members of a persecuted minority. Sometimes they come because they are living in the middle of war zones and fear for their lives.
Some Come Legally-Others Illegally
These are the same reasons most immigrants come here. But the United States only allows a limited number of immigrants to come here legally and they have to fit specific requirements, like being from certain countries, having relatives who already live here, or working in occupations that the government thinks will benefit the economy.
Many illegal immigrants do not fit these requirements, but come anyway.
About 5 million illegal immigrants were living in the United States in 1996, according to the Immigration and Naturalization Service, with about 275,000 new illegal immigrants coming each year. Still, illegal immigrants make up only 1.9% of the total population of the United States.
That isn’t much, but immigrants settle in large numbers in certain cities or states, like California, New York, Texas and Florida. (About 40% of illegal immigrants live in California.) And in these places, the large number of immigrants can put a real strain on government services like schools and hospitals.
Should Illegal Immigrants Be Allowed in School?
Because of this, some people want to discourage illegal immigrants from coming here.
They say illegal immigrants bring down wages for everyone. (Because they do not have legal papers allowing them to work, and usually do not speak English well, illegal immigrants often accept jobs that pay less than minimum wage.)
Some people charge that illegal immigrants overcrowd neighborhoods by packing people into apartments (like Jinan’s), take jobs that citizens and legal residents need, and receive services-like free education-but do not pay taxes.
And, they say, illegal immigrants are simply breaking the law.
According to John Vinson from American Immigration Control in Washington, D.C., a group that fights illegal immigration, illegal immigrants also bring diseases such as tuberculosis to the United States, and raise the level of crime.
Do Illegal Immigrants Hurt or Help the Economy?
But not everybody agrees that illegal immigrants are a problem.
According to Jane Guskin from the Coalition for the Human Rights of Immigrants, a recent study says that most illegal immigrants contribute more in taxes than they take in services.
She says that except for public education, illegal immigrants don’t receive most government benefits, like social security or welfare, even though they pay sales taxes on everything they buy.
And while it is true that some illegal immigrants don’t pay income tax because they work off the books, others pay the same taxes as citizens because they use fake social security numbers to get jobs.
Advocates for illegal immigrants also say that they take hard, low-paying jobs that citizens would refuse to take-on farms and in small factories, and as caretakers for children and the elderly, for example-and actually help the economy rather than hurt it.
The Laws Get Tougher
But many legislators do not agree with these arguments. And in an effort to stop illegal immigration, lawmakers on both the local and national level have been trying to pass laws that would discourage illegal immigrants from coming here, and would make it harder for them if they did come.
In 1996, Congress passed a bill that increased penalties against people who enter this country illegally, made it tougher for illegal immigrants to find employment, and required government officials to check immigration status before issuing any form of social security benefits or assistance for college.
Some states tried to go even further. In California, lawmakers proposed a bill which, if it had been passed, would have kept illegal children from going to school and would have denied them access to health care in emergency rooms.
Another bill would have denied citizenship to children born in this country to illegal immigrants. (Right now, children of illegal immigrants born in this country automatically become citizens, and have the right to all the same benefits as everyone else.)
Let Those Who Have Come Succeed
The harshest of these laws did not pass, though, because most Americans are not sure how they feel about illegal immigrants, and don’t want to support such harsh measures.
Most citizens seem to want more officers patrolling the borders to keep illegal immigrants out in the first place, and they want to deport criminals.
But they don’t want illegal immigrants punished when they get here, or their children to be deprived of their education.
Like me, many Americans probably know someone who is here illegally, and want her to succeed.
Unwelcome to America
About These Stories
YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.