There is this girl I know, never really cared who she was with, never felt she had a reason to. She had a few boyfriends she liked, but most of them she knew from the start didn’t really care about her.
She never had anything but a string of bad relationships and people who took advantage of her or used her for something like clothes, money she didn’t have, a place to stay.
At a bad point in her life, she met this guy. He wasn’t exactly what you would call good looking, but the way he acted made his looks not matter.
After she met him, they would talk on the phone for hours on end. They’d start talking in the evening and stay up until 4:30 in the morning, even though she had to get up for school two hours later. She liked being with him because he made her laugh and even smile for real. She was actually happy.
Small Things Showed He Cared
What she enjoyed was that someone acted like he wanted to talk to her and went out of his way for her. He would ignore all his beeps and get rid of the calls on the other line to talk to her.
He told her she was pretty and that personality-wise, she didn’t give herself enough credit.
She remembers the times he stroked her face, or the time on his back porch when he asked her why she was out there when everyone else was inside, and why she looked upset.
She just smoked her cigarette and then for no reason he kissed her cheek and went inside. That was why she believed that he cared about her, small things like that.
At first she wouldn’t believe that he cared about her, how could anyone? But more and more she fell for him.
Too Early for Sex
They weren’t a couple, they were never going out, but after only two weeks they started to sleep together. She knew it was too soon, but she didn’t care.
She never saw sex as related to her feelings. She thought the worst thing you could do was put sex and emotions together.
He would always tell her how much he loved kissing her, even if that was all that was going to happen. If they were fooling around and she said she didn’t want to do anything more, he would let it be and not complain.
He never touched her when she didn’t want him to. There were times, though, when he didn’t touch her and she wished that he would.
Sometimes she thought their relationship was just sexual, and would ask him often if he was her friend. When he said yes, she was comforted.
Drinking Away Depression
This girl’s best friend hated the guy, so she saw her best friend less and less. Her friend also hated that she was drunk all the time, especially with the guy.
This girl was always depressed. For years she had bad depression. She drank before she met him, but for some reason she started drinking with him more.
She would drink with friends and, even when she was home alone, she would take swigs from her dad’s scotch and get drunk by herself.
It didn’t help that the guy was f-cked up on something all the time, too.
But none of this mattered to her, because she was still happy with him.
When they were alone he would be so good to her. But after a while she noticed that around friends or at parties, she became invisible.
He wouldn’t acknowledge her existence, wouldn’t even say hi.
He seemed embarrassed to let anybody know that he knew her. Later she found out that he would talk sh-t about her behind her back. Slowly, she began to find out just how dishonest he was being with her.
They were supposed to be open with each other, that’s why it bothered her that he didn’t tell her when he got with this other girl. It wasn’t jealousy that she felt, but betrayal. She didn’t think she could trust him anymore.
He Stopped Calling
If he wouldn’t tell her about just kissing and making out with some girl, she realized he would never tell her that he was sleeping with someone else.
She wasn’t using protection with him and she started to get scared. She felt he was using her just for sex and he wasn’t really a friend at all.
He started to call her less and less. When he did call her to hang out, he wouldn’t say much to her and they’d have sex. And after he stopped talking to her, he always would tell people how insane she was and make fun of her and her body.
Meanwhile he would yell at her if she said that she didn’t believe he cared about her, and he would ask, “What do I have to do to prove to you how much I care about you?”
Some time went on, and he just stopped calling. She called him a few times, to see maybe just, well just maybe he was busy somewhere else.
Embarrassed and Hurt
She knew it was over. It was horrible for her. She would cry often. She never told him how she felt about him and never would.
When she realized that things were actually over, for a while she would rarely leave the house. One time when she went out, she felt like she couldn’t breathe. The friend she was with didn’t know what to do.
Without her even knowing it she was crying on the train. Tears started pouring down her cheeks until she looked like a raccoon from her mascara. When she finally realized she couldn’t stop crying she cried even harder on her friend.
She couldn’t believe that she’d convinced herself that he liked her at all. That is what probably hurt the most. It wasn’t that he was a boyfriend who broke up with her, it was that he was supposed to be a friend who she could trust.
Still Thinking About Him
She tried to hide her feelings from her friends, because she could never admit to falling for a guy who had treated her like that.
She hated him and herself, but couldn’t help thinking about him. She felt out of control, and for a while she was drinking so much, she ended up in the hospital.
There are parts of her that still want him and care about him. Of course she doesn’t want to put herself through that again. Although maybe just to kiss him again would be nice, she thinks sometimes.
She doesn’t think she would ever tell him, though. She has learned to keep her mouth shut and not embarrass herself.
She regrets any little thing that let him know she cared about him. She can feel him laughing at her now.
She stopped talking to him a year ago, but she still thinks about him all the time. All he did was screw with her head and use her, so she doesn’t understand why she can’t deal with it being over.
A Happy New Relationship
This girl has a new boyfriend now. When she met him, she was afraid that the same thing would happen again, but they’ve been together for nine months by now.
Her new boyfriend gets jealous. He’s heard how the other guy treated her, and doesn’t like it.
Still, she often thinks about the old guy, even though she knows he isn’t thinking about her. She wishes that he would feel as upset as she does.
Recently that guy called her, just to talk. When her boyfriend found out, he flipped out, screaming, “How dare you talk to that a-hole after all he did to you!”
But she was happy that they could talk, peacefully and honestly like friends.
That time on the phone he said, “I want to know, when you and me were together, if you will let me say together, that we had a mutual caring and a mutual trust.”
Why was he saying this to her now?
Even so, he never explained to her why it ended. No one could explain it. Maybe that’s why she has this undying feeling for this guy.
Broken Trust
I think it is also because she never trusted someone so much. Most people like someone for what he looks like, but rarely for how he is, and that’s what attracted her to him, they way he was to her before he changed.
Her friend Emma says it is obvious that she still has feelings for him, just by the way she says his name.
One night not long ago she drove by his house and drove by the places where he used to hang out. Sometimes, she contemplates calling his house just to hear the sound of his voice, but then she starts to think how pathetic that would be.
This girl has a hard time accepting that he hurt her so much. And I have a hard time admitting that this girl is me.
Stuck On You
About These Stories
YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.