Many American Companies like Nike Exploit Their Foreign Workers and Overcharge Us, Too. Why Do We Support Them by Buying Their Products?
By Thuvia P. Jones
“Whoa, you got the new Jordans, son?! Yo, how much you paid for them?”
“Yo, those new Iversons are hot-how much they cost you?”
Greetings like these have replaced the regular, “Hey, what’s up, how you doing?” in many conversations in Anyghetto, U.S.A. Questions of how your family is doing, how your sister in college is, or why you didn’t bring your girl to the party last night all come second to the almighty sneaker props.
And so do logical questions about the sneakers like, why the hell do they cost so much? Is it because they are sewn with care or because the companies pay their workers well? In fact, it is neither.
Poverty Pay and Long Hours
Many top designers exploit their workers in other countries and still overcharge us for their products.
Lately, companies like Nike have come under fire for mistreating their workers with poverty pay, long, hard hours, and no benefits.
On top of that, they charge us about 1,000% more than it costs to make the item!
Nike’s practices are a prime example of these abuses-and of how speaking out against unfair companies can convince them to change their policies.
Nike has millions saying “Just Do It,” but workers in Third World countries are being forced to “Just Do It.”
Don’t get me wrong-Nike doesn’t scour the countryside on a big Swooshmobile with a Swoosh-shaped lasso, rounding up some children and taking them off to the factories.
They don’t kidnap workers and store them in underground Swooshshops. They don’t chain workers to the machines in Swoosh-shackles until they turn out 500 pairs of sneakers apiece. Nike really doesn’t have to.
Only Jobs Available
The workers in countries where Nike has built its sneaker factories-Indonesia, Vietnam, and China-face such economic hardship that jobs at sweatshops are the best jobs they can find.
Often, they are the only jobs.
Forget mentally challenging or upwardly mobile work. The workers are desperate for any reprieve from imminent starvation.
But by no account do jobs at Nike free these workers from hunger and poverty.
According to a recent article in Time magazine, the subsistence level for Vietnam, Indonesia and China is $3 a day. That means that each worker requires the bare minimum of $3 a day to pay for basic housing, food and clothing. Anything less will keep them in poverty.
Nike only pays its Indonesian workers $1 a day, and Vietnamese and Chinese workers earn less than $2 daily.
Unfair Anywhere
Most of these workers are glad to get any kind of work and, despite the exploitation, continue working there-there is nowhere else for them to go.
Still, just because they are willing work for these wages doesn’t mean that it is fair.
It’s not like the workers can go on strike and picket the Swooshshops-they would simply be replaced by people more desperate to work. Nike knows their desperation. And takes advantage of it.
You might be thinking, “A dollar a day for 12 hours of hard labor? Dag, with those wages you might as well go on welfare.” Well, in places like Vietnam and Indonesia, there is no welfare.
So, simply put-you don’t work, you don’t eat. The wages may be slave wages, but they delay starvation for another night.
That is why these countries encourage companies to build factories there, regardless of how terrible the working conditions are.
Good For Business, Bad For Us
In many countries, children are allowed to work more and do more strenuous work than kids and teens here in America.
It is perfectly lawful and perhaps expected that young kids hold their own at the factory. Their families are poor and need the income their kids can provide.
So what does this have to do with you and your willingness to spend $150 for some Nikes? It’s straight up Poli-economics (politics mixed with economics).
Nike executive Phil Knight would not dare pull child labor stunts here in America (although there are sweatshops here, too), so he does his business in Vietnam, China and Indonesia.
Setting up shop elsewhere is good for big business but means fewer jobs for American workers.
It would be helping the American economy to have Nike sneaker factories here and to spend $150 on a pair of sneakers (if you still wish to spend that kind of money on kicks).
But if that’s not going to happen, at least the American public ought to benefit from having sneakers made more cheaply.
Unfortunately, I don’t see Nike making any $15 shoes.
So. . .where is all this money going?
Ad Campaigns Give You Nike Fever
Well, a few dollars pays the workers, a couple more pays for the materials. Then companies have to pay for distribution and machinery, and the stores have to pay their rent. A big chunk goes to the expensive and extensive ad campaigns that entice you to cough up that $150. Some of your money pays the salaries of the corporate big willies, and pays the salaries of the big willie spokesmen, like Michael Jordan.
And a portion of the profits goes to corporate stock holders; these are people who have invested in Nike by buying stocks in the company. (When Nike profits, shareholders make a little profit, too).
That was the economic break down. Now for the political breakdown.
The majority of the corporate executives are affluent White people and those with the street credibility, Black.
A corporate mogul pleading with you to buy a pair of sneakers for $150 may not give you Nike fever, but one of the “boys” letting you in on a secret and dropping a little science on the shoes turns you into a Nike fan for life. It’s all in the approach.
Breaking the Rent Fund for Kicks
They’re targeting poor, ghetto inhabitants with the $150 sneaker ads. They know you cannot afford it (or you wouldn’t be living in the projects), but if Michael woos you hard enough, you will break your rent fund, grocery shopping fund, or job interview suit fund for some sneakers.
The $150 you spend is an investment in Nike-although you don’t make any dividends on it (profit on the stocks).
If you were to invest this money as a stockholder, you would at least be able to get the tax you paid on your sneakers back (unless you were slick and bought them in New Jersey).
People of color have “invested” a lot in Nike-they should be getting more back than a pair of overpriced sneakers made in a sweatshop halfway around the world.
“So what do you want me to do?” you might be thinking. It may not bother you that Nike employs kids your little sister’s age to sew sneakers for you and your friends.
You may not care that they’re paying someone your age 1% of what they charge for the shoes. Reading this may only remind you of the Nikes you plan to buy this weekend.
For the rest of us who are disgusted, keep this in mind: No company has total authority over the buying public.
We make these brands into name brands. If you don’t like their policies, all you have to do is withdraw support-don’t buy the shoes.
Despite what Nike thinks, it is not the only sneaker that can be made popular. Invest in the companies that use morals in hiring and labor practices.
If “bad” companies see consumer awareness and support of “good” companies, they will have to convert, or go bankrupt from lack of support.
Let Nike know you don’t like them robbing their workers by paying them too little, and robbing us of our decent (if we’re lucky) wages by making us pay too much.
Make Nike Play a Fair Game
Those corporate execs know the difference between right and wrong; whether they choose to follow it or not is a different matter.
As children, we knew what mama meant when she said no fighting in my house with your brother-so we went outside and fought with him and broke his nose.
You know she meant no fighting at all, and you learned this lesson again when she tore into that behind.
Corporate America knows it’s wrong, but who’s going to whip them into shape? You are, and to some degree, you have.
Just recently Nike gave in to public pressure and changed its labor policies a bit, establishing a minimum age in their factories.
Placing enough pressure on Nike caused them to buckle a little. The fight is not over, however.
Sneaker buyers, like you, can force Nike-and other companies like Nike-to play a fair game.
Nike: Just Don’t Do It
About These Stories
YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.