Neighborhood-Based Reform: Where Do You Want to be Placed?

Iinterviews by Tara Bonaparte, Shanikqua Crawford, Dwishnicka Decarde, Betty Dominguez, and Eric Edmondson
If you haven’t already heard, let us tell you about Commissioner Nicholas Scoppetta’s plan to change the New York City foster care system: when kids go into care, he wants to keep them in the same neighborhoods they were taken from. The Commissioner and many other people feel that kids shouldn’t be taken out of familiar environments and placed away from family, friends, school, etc. Foster care might be easier for the kids if they’re in the same neighborhoods. This is called “neighborhood-based reform.”
As you’ve read on the previous pages, two of our writers-Baudilio Lozado and Sylinda Sinkfield-have very different opinions about this plan. Sylinda supports the plan, because she felt better being placed in a foster home in her old neighborhood. Baudilio strongly disagrees, because he thinks that placing kids back in the same neighborhoods they came from will only cause them more anguish.
So we decided to take these questions out to you, our readers, and find out what you think about Scoppetta’s plan. Our roving reporters hit the streets and here’s the answers they got:
Nellie Alameda,15 Catholic Home Bureau Placement: Foster Home
Is it better to keep kids in the same neighborhood or put them in a different neighborhood? “It’s better to be in a different neighborhood. Staying in the same neighborhood makes you keep on remembering those things that happened to you.”
Would you rather have been placed near home? “Not really. I wouldn’t want to see the person I had the problems with.”
Michelle Engberg,14 Catholic Home Bureau Placement: Foster Home
Were you placed in the same neighborhood you were taken from? “No. I was in a deserted place. It was real far away. I got beat up. The stores were different, everything was just different.”
Would you rather have been place near home? “I would have liked to stay in my neighborhood. It’s very hard to adjust. To go to a different school and everything. It’s better to just stay in the same neighborhood.”
Edwin Santana,13 Catholic Home Bureau Placement: Foster Home
Is it better to keep kids in the same neighborhood or put them in another neighborhood? “Yes, it is better [to stay in the same neighborhood]. You stay with your friends and in your school. . .It really depends in some cases, though.”
Would you rather have been placed near home? “No, I feel happy I was out of my neighborhood. I got a better brother, a better sister, a better niece, a better uncle, a better mom, a better dad. A better family than I had.”
Derica Mcarn,17 St. Christopher’s-Jennie Clarkson Placement: Group Home (RTC)
Is it better to keep kids in the same neighborhood or put them in another neighborhood? “Keep them in the same neighborhood, ’cause even if they are in the system, they won’t need home visits to see their friends and family.”
What are the advantages and disadvantages of going to a new neighborhood? “The advantages were meeting new people, finding new friends, experiencing new neighborhoods, and learning new things. The disadvantages were if [my] family had problems, I couldn’t just be there to comfort them. I couldn’t be with my people to just chill and grow old with. You know, have life-long friends.”
Would you rather have been placed near home? “Yes, because I would like to see my friends every day like I used toâ[but]â I’m [also] curious to find out about other people’s lifestyles and how they live.”
Maggie Estavez,16 St. Christopher-Jennie Clarkson Placement: Group Home (RTC)
Have you heard about Scoppetta’s plan to keep kids in the same neighborhoods? “Yes. He feels it was wrong that kids were taken from their neighborhoods and placed where they didn’t know anyone.”
Is it better to keep kids in the same neighborhood? “If they were in the same neighborhood, they wouldn’t feel depressed about being in care and being moved from home. But at the same timeâ what if they are moved to the same neighborhood with the same family that abused or neglected them? You don’t know what would happen. The parents can pick up the kids and do whatever. They can kidnap the kids. Sometimes it’s good [to place them in the same neighborhoods] but in other ways it’s not good at all. You don’t know what background the kids is coming from.”
Were you placed in the same neighborhood? “No.” What are the advantages/disadvantages of being in a new neighborhood? “In a way it is an advantage [that I’m not in my neighborhood] because I feel safe. I don’t feel like I’m going to be chased my whole life by someone who abused me. And the place that I am in now, I have met people who were in situations a lot worse than mine. I’ve learned from them, and I feel like I don’t have to worry about tomorrow. If I was home I think I would have to worry about tomorrow.”
Ivon Davis,15 Catholic Home Bureau Placement: Foster Home
Is it better to keep kids in the same neighborhood or put them in another neighborhood? “Take them from their [old] neighborhood because whatever the problem is with their parents could happen to them again if they are staying in the same neighborhood.”
Would you rather have been placed near home? “Sometimes I wish I would have stayed in the Bronx but not in the same neighborhood, ’cause it was a lot of problems where I was. It was hard for me to move from the Bronx because I knew that I was going to have to meet new friends and start all over again.”
De-Asia Holden,18 ACS Placement: Foster Home
Is it better to keep kids in the same neighborhood or put them in another neighborhood? “It is better to put them in another neighborhood so that they can get away from their original problems. If they are in the same neighborhood, then most likely their mother will know the foster mother and will still be in contact with you or try to be in contact with you. Say your mother was beating on you. Depending on how the foster mother is, she can still let your mother be around you, and your mother could still be able to harm you in various ways. That can cause even more problems. If you were in a different neighborhood, it’s less likely that your mother could gain access to you to arouse any more problems. You probably won’t forget about the situation, but being in another neighborhood could help you get away from the situation.”
What are the advantages/disadvantages of being in your old neighborhood? “The advantages of being placed in the same neighborhood are having support from your friends, not having to make new friends or start all over in another school. The disadvantages would be still facing the original problem you were put into foster care for and having everyone in the neighborhood know your business, which at this point would not help you at all. The advantage of being placed in a different neighborhood is that you can get away from your situation semi-completely. It’s still gonna be in your mind, but you don’t have to answer to anyone in the new neighborhood, and they won’t know your business when you get there.”
Ebony King,15 Louise Wise Services Placement: Foster Home
Is it better to keep kids in the same neighborhood they came from? “It’s good to be placed in the same neighborhood but then again it’s not good. It’s good because say that [kids] were taken from they mother over a stupid reason, like somebody just called BCW ’cause they don’t like them or some other stupid reason that would get their kids taken away, then they should stay in the same neighborhood. If they mother was really abusing them and really beating them or using drugs, then they should be in a different neighborhood to get away from their mother until she gets herself together.”
Were you place in the same neighborhood? “No. I lived in Manhattan and I was placed in the Bronx.”
What were the advantages/disadvantages? “There was no advantages. The disadvantages-I missed my mother, it was hard for me to start in a new school, it was hard to make friends. The only friend I had when I moved here was my brother. I ain’t know nobody in my building, and the person I was living with I didn’t know.”
Would you rather have been placed near home? “Yes, because I think that my mother ain’t do nothing wrong, and it would have been easier for me because I could’ve saw my mother daily. I wouldn’t have had to make new friends or start going to a new school.”
Leon Starks,16 Catholic Guardian Society Placement: Group Home
Is it better to keep kids in the same neighborhood? “Both good and bad. The idea of keeping foster kids in their same neighborhood and not have to adjust somewhere else is a good idea. The idea is bad because they might have to see their parents and go through the same problems.”
Were you placed in the same neighborhood? “No, I was moved from Brooklynâto the Bronx.”
How did you feel about it? “I felt like I wouldn’t be okay in the Bronx because I loved Brooklyn so much. The only thing that really affected me was I was away from most of my problems, but moving away doesn’t mean my problems will go away. I still had to face the fact I was in care.”
Would you rather have been placed near home? “Maybeâ If I was near home, I wouldn’t be a stranger but everyone would know my business. If I would leave I could start off fresh but I would miss where I came from.”
Lakimba Banks,15 St. Christopher’s-Jennie Clarkson Placement: Group Home (RTC)
Is it better to keep kids in the same neighborhood or put them in another neighborhood? “I think that it is a good idea to be placed in your same neighborhood because the children don’t have to get re-accustomed to anything.”
Were you placed in the same neighborhood? “Yeah, the first time.”
Did you feel there was anything good about that? Or was there anything bad? “There was no disadvantages. I still got to chill where I used to.”
Would you have liked it better to have been placed in your old neighborhood, the times you were placed away from home? “I got placed away from home four times. I feel that it would have been better if I was near my old block so I wouldn’t have to have been re-accustomed to anything.”
Cristina Rivera,15 St. Christopher’s-Jennie Clarkson Placement: Group Home (RTC)
Is it better to keep kids in the same neighborhood? “It depends on the reason why the child was taken away. Because I don’t think that it makes sense for a child that was abused to be in the same neighborhood so that they could get beat again.”
Were you placed in the same neighborhood? “Nope, never was.”
What were the advantages/disadvantages? “If I would have stayed home, I would have messed up more. [But] I wasn’t around my family when I got moved and that was a disadvantage.”
Gabrielle Williams,16 St. Christopher’s-Jennie Clarkson Placement: Group Home (RTC)
Were you placed in the same neighborhood? “Yes.” Were there any advantages or were there disadvantages? “It was good because it was better for me. I was closer to my family. I’m away right now. I wish I would have stayed in my old neighborhood because it was hard for me to start over.”

SIDEBAR: Guns In Schools
In writing the article about teens and gun violence, it was noticeable that all of the big shootings that attracted media attention took place inside schools. It made me wonder: are kids safe from gun violence anywhere, but more importantly, in school? I asked this question to every teen I interviewed and, believe it or not, I was surprised by their answers. Schools I thought would be the most dangerous turned out not to be, and schools I thought would be the safest weren’t necessarily that way.
Safe in School?
Marteen, 15, goes to Aquinas, which is an all-girls Catholic High School in the Bronx. She said she feels safe in her school because it’s Catholic and all-girls, and she believes that no one is going to pull a gun out and shoot her. Ebony, 15, who goes to Taft High School in the Bronx, surprised me when she told me that she honestly feels safe in her school. I’m not putting her school down, but I’ve heard things about her school that would not make me feel safe if I went there. I heard that there are always gang members in front of her school as well as inside of the school, and that the students are always fighting (and not always with their fists). Ebony explained she feels safe in Taft because at the front entrance, where everybody enters the building, there are metal detectors and three security guards. She also feels safe because she has seen students who’ve tried to bring in weapons get arrested and expelled. Although there are some kids who feel safe in their schools, others do not. Nini, who attends El Puente High School in Williamsburg, Brooklyn, said she does not feel safe, despite the fact that there is a security guard in her school. “I don’t feel safe because if my friend could bring a gun into school without nobody knowing, then anyone could bring a gun into school without anyone knowing,” she said. “There’s a security guard, but she don’t check nobody.” Marcus, 16, who attends Morris High School in the Bronx, also feels threatened by violence in his school, even though his school has metal detectors. He doesn’t feel safe because he says that kids who go to his school are starting to bring in a type of plastic gun that cannot be detected.
As Young as 10
Despite the fact that some teens feel safe in their schools, that still does not mean that the schools are safe. While a recent nationwide survey of students in grades 6 to 12 showed that the number of students who admit to having taken a gun to school has dropped by 36% in five years, that still leaves an estimated one million students who say they have carried a gun to school at least once during the 1997-98 school year. Some of these students are as young as 10. Half of these students claimed they had threatened to harm a teacher and almost two-thirds claimed they had threatened to harm another student. It is not only the students who are wounded or killed who are affected by teen gun violence, but everybody-their families and even other students across the country. When we hear about shootings at other schools, we automatically think, Can this happen in our school? We’ll never know the answer to that question, and that makes us feel unsafe.
Guns Are Too Easy
Feeling unsafe in school leads to other problems. If a child feels unsafe, it could disturb her work and concentration and then the child does not do well. This is really upsetting and unfair. We go to school to learn, not to worry about our safety. Sure, teenagers are wrong for wanting to bring guns to school, but maybe bringing guns inside schools is too easy. Something needs to be done-maybe more security or stricter penalties-so kids can be safe and the terrible tragedies, such as what happened in Oregon and Arkansas, can come to an end.

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.