When It Comes to Dating: Older Isn’t Better

Let’s talk about the dirty secret behind teen sex and pregnancies: The media makes it look like it’s two teenagers getting caught up in the heat of the moment.
Usually, we think teenage boys are getting girls pregnant.
But research shows that many teenage girls are being sexually exploited and impregnated by adult men, mostly men older than 20. This is a major reality of teenage life that has been ignored.
The same people who have made teenage mothers a cataclysmic headline have not said much about the adults who have babies with babies. Now it is time to read the truth.
Exploited By Older Men
Adult men fathered two-thirds of the infants born to school-aged mothers, according to a study in 1993. These men were a lot older than their girlfriends, like 4 to 6 years older.
And men over 25 fathered twice as many births as boys under 18. So it’s not fair to blame teenage boys for a lot of the teenage girls getting pregnant.
Also, many teen births are the result of sexual assault, according to the study.
Well, when I found all this out, I wanted to know more about why teenage girls go out with older guys, so I called a therapist named Gretta Mogel at the Youth Counseling League and asked a couple of questions. This is what we came up with.
Looking For a Father Figure
She said girls who don’t get emotional security at home may crave it, and older guys may give these girls the appearance of this security.
Girls who have been sexually abused are especially likely to look for relationships with older men.
Abused adolescents initiate sex earlier, and often have sex with much older partners and with more partners.
For example, in a study in Washington state, 62% of teen mothers had been raped or sexually abused when they were younger.
What I’m trying to say is that teenage girls who have been sexually abused are especially at risk of getting pregnant by an older man.
Older Guys Are Not More Trustworthy
Teenage boys and older guys both play a part in pressuring teenage girls to have sex. But unfortunately, young girls might trust an older guy more, even if that’s not realistic.
Teenage girls often feel that older guys will be responsible enough to take care of them if anything happens.
I say, come on, do you really think he’s going to be your hero forever? Everyone knows a girl who thought she could depend on a guy but couldn’t. Still, no one ever thinks that the girl could be her. Well, it could be!
A girl should be aware of why older guys would fall for her. Older guys are looking at teenage girls for their innocence and youth. They may want to take care of them, or they may want to take charge. Never let a guy run your life!
Know What You Want
Before entering a relationship with an older guy (or any relationship, for that matter), girls should think about the Dos and Don’ts of a healthy relationship. They should also think about any consequences the relationship could bring.
A girl should know what she wants, and whether he wants the same thing. And she should know the history of his relationships.
Girls should also protect themselves from being emotionally hurt or taken advantage of, just as they would with a teenage boy.
There are many risks that come with dating someone much older. Girls may feel like their boyfriends have everything and they have nothing.
An older man may feel dominant over a teenage girl, which can make the girl feel trapped (like she can never leave him).
Riskier Business
Girls also have to decide whether to be open about the relationship. Teenage girls often have to hide the relationship from their family and friends.
And, of course, you should know if he is married or has children. (You don’t want to break up anyone’s marriage or be called a homewrecker, do you?)
Girls should also be extra careful and responsible with older guys, because girls have a higher risk of getting STDs and AIDS if they are having sexual relationships with adult male partners.
This is not to say that all relationships with older guys are bad. There are benefits (some older guys might actually be more responsible), and a girl can find someone who will treat her right.
Still, she should keep this short list in mind:
Dos and Don’ts
Do:
1) Get to know him.
2) See if you can trust him.
3) Put your needs before his.
Don’t:
1) Don’t do anything you don’t feel comfortable with, even if it means losing the relationship.
(That’s true for all relationships!)
If older guys pressure girls to have unprotected sex, girls need to take responsibility for what is going on, too. The guy can always walk away.
Girls: It’s your body and you’re in control.
If girls think they can have sex with no consequences, well, they’re wrong!
Laws Can Protect Girls
Now, there are laws against statutory rape to protect young teenage girls from having sex with older guys under any circumstances, whether or not the girls give consent. (In New York, a guy who is 21 or older cannot legally have sex with a girl who is younger than 17.)
You might be thinking: Wait a minute! Teenage girls aren’t going to put the brakes on their hormones and postpone having sex just because it’s decreed in law.
So why do they even have these laws? The idea is that physically mature girls of 14 or 16 years old still have plenty of emotional growing to do, so they shouldn’t be having sex with an older guy who could take advantage of them.
Laws aside, it’s hard to know when you’re ready. But even if the older guy you’re dating pressures you to have sex, you need to decide for yourself.
Wait Until You’re Ready
Ms. Mogel said teenage girls may be physically and emotionally ready to have sex when they know how to take care of their bodies (like they know how to use protection!), know their morals, and won’t feel guilty or angry at themselves afterward.
Still, by being with these older guys, I feel you’re growing up too fast. It’s OK to be a kid. And you know what, it’s OK to be a virgin! If your boyfriend doesn’t like that, he’s not worth it.
I know there’s a lot of peer pressure out there, but it’s not always right to follow the crowd. Just be yourself, because you’re only a teenager once-everyone knows time stops for no one.
My main advice is: Think about what you’re doing. This is the ’90s. There are a lot of STDs out there. And you probably don’t want to get pregnant, either.
So keep it real with yourself! Most of all, think about what’s right for you.

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.