High school is more than just tests, studying and crowded hallways. It is a fashion display of some of the most up-to-date styles and some of the cheesiest clothes you have ever seen.
Typical clothes there are not. Everyone has her own fashion and sense of style. Some think that halter tops and minis are it, while others feel more comfortable in baggy jeans and large sweatshirts. It’s hard to know what to put on in the morning!
But there are students who don’t agonize over what to wear to school every day.
At the Frederick Douglass Academy, a public school in Harlem, every student wears a navy blue skirt or pair of pants with a white shirt, every day.
Uniforms Help Students Focus On School
Over the past year, there has been a lot of talk about school uniforms, and some public school students in New York already wear them.
Many parents and educators say uniforms are good because when students don’t have to think about clothes, they can focus on more important things-like getting an education. Uniforms also might keep students from judging each other based on what they wear.
In the last year, President Clinton has pushed schools across the country to consider uniforms, and in his newsletter this summer, Schools Chancellor Rudy Crew encouraged more New York City schools to adopt uniforms.
Already, many elementary schools in New York have uniforms, and 80% of city parents think their kids should wear uniforms to school.
With all this talk of public schools getting uniforms, I decided to see what people thought of the idea. As I expected, most students who don’t wear uniforms think nothing should change.
What About Individuality?
At McKee Vocational HS on Staten Island, Jeff Hammond, a senior, joked, “I would keep things the way they are, because morale is high, bowling averages are up, golf scores are down, and violence is at an all-time low.”
But seriously, most students said it’s important to be able to express yourself, and teenagers express themselves through what they wear.
Punk rockers show their personalities by wearing colored hair and black clothes. Then there are the preppies dressed in clothes from the Gap, trendies in bootleg pants and platforms, and hip-hop kids in big shirts and baggy jeans.
“I know uniforms are easier, but it takes away from individuality,” said Vanessa Raimondi, a McKee senior. “I would say ‘hell no’ to having uniforms because in public school, choice equals democracy. If you’re in public school, you should have the choice.”
You Can Wear a Uniform With Style
But the students I spoke with at Frederick Douglass said they don’t mind wearing uniforms.
“I’m so used to uniforms that it doesn’t faze me,” said Crystal Rogers, a senior. She said it took time to get used to, though. “I knew why they wanted me to wear them. I just didn’t like it.”
The girls there said teenagers can express themselves without wearing casual clothes.
Students at Douglass individualize their uniforms by wearing short or long skirts, or by wearing shirts in different styles.
Despite uniforms, students can find ways to show their personalities.
“Don’t think guys can’t find ways to look like hoodlums, and girls can find a way to look kind of slutty,” said Katherine Duncan, also a senior.
Uniforms Can Make Life Easier
Some students who don’t wear uniforms do have mixed feelings. They tend not to want the uniforms, but at the same time they think uniforms would cut down on some problems like theft.
“It’s corny to wear uniforms, but it would stop kids from stealing other people’s stuff,” said Manny, a junior at McKee.
At Douglass, students said uniforms make life a lot easier. LaWanda Stewart, a Douglass senior, said she’s glad she can just pull her uniform out of her closet without having to think in the mornings. And wearing a uniform is definitely cheaper.
“With uniforms, you don’t have to worry about designers. They would be wallet breakers,” said Katherine. “And if I had to spend twenty minutes picking out my clothes, I’d get to school too late, miss class and mess up my grades.”
Even Principals Can’t Agree
But a lot of teenagers seem to care more about getting to class in style than getting to class on time.
You might think a school principal would definitely want uniforms in his school. But that’s not true of all principals.
Dr. Stevan Peters, assistant principal of McKee HS, said he thinks uniforms are not a match for New York City students.
“I was a kid once too, and I remember what it was like to want your own identity,” Dr. Peters said.
On the other hand, Dr. Gregory Hodge, principal of the Frederick Douglass Academy, said uniforms keep students focused on school.
“Students understand when they walk through the door that there is a seriousness about education,” Dr. Hodge said. “Uniforms help give kids a sense of discipline and identity.”
The girls at Douglass said uniforms help them focus on school and keep them from caring too much about their appearance. They said they wished they didn’t even have to take the time to style their hair.
“You could tell who does well by the way they do their hair,” said Katherine Duncan, who said good students don’t have time to worry about their hair. “It’s my classes that I’m worried about, not the hair.”
Dress for Success: Do Uniforms Make a Difference?
About These Stories
YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.