“You’re being so disrespectful! Stand up and pledge to your country! People died so you can be here!”
That’s what my 8th grade homeroom teacher yelled at me one morning.
Everyone had been sitting around talking when the principal came over the loud speaker and started to recite the Pledge of Allegiance.
We all cherished those 15 minutes of homeroom to catch up on homework from the night before. That’s just what I was doing when everyone in class got up to pledge-except me.
They Made Me Salute
My teacher came over to my seat and told me again to stand up and salute the flag. When I refused, he got the assistant principal and they called me out into the hallway.
The assistant principal asked me whether or not religion had anything to do with my not standing to pledge allegiance. When I told him no, he said that I had to stand up, and he wanted a note from my mother explaining why I wouldn’t stand.
I just stood there wondering when they would let me go. I felt like Bart Simpson in that episode when his teacher Ms. Crabapple was talking to him, and all he could hear was, “Blah blah blah blah…blah…”
We’ve Got Rights
It often feels like as soon as we walk through those heavy metal doors into our schools, we lose our rights to make choices about what we do. But students have many rights that you may not know about.
I know now, for instance, that they didn’t have the right to make me stand during the pledge.
According to the American Civil Liberties Union (ACLU), students have the right to sit or stand silently during the pledge if we choose.
As long as you’re not being disruptive, no one can force you to sing, stand or pledge if you don’t want to.
In the ACLU handbook, The Rights of Students, it says students have a constitutional right “to express your opinions and beliefs in school, as long as you do so in a way that doesn’t disrupt classes or other school activities.”
Can’t Wear Just Anything To School
As part of the right to freedom of expression, students have the right to wear what they want to school and to publish their opinions in a school newspaper. But both of those rights come with some limitations.
School officials often tell us what we can and can’t wear to school. I know people who have been sent home because their skirts were too short or their shirts had pictures of things like guns or marijuana leaves.
I thought they were sent home because school officials found those things offensive. But it was probably because the principal thought those clothes might distract other students from their work.
The most important right students have is the right to a “sound, basic education.” If other students can’t pay attention in class, either because of something you’re doing or wearing, then you’re violating their rights.
Most Clothes Are Acceptable
Debbie King, an attorney from the Board of Education, said you can be sent home if what you’re wearing is disruptive because it’s racist, offensive or demeaning to certain people (in other words, if it puts people down).
These clothes may keep other students from being able to pay attention to their work, because your clothes are upsetting them.
You can also be sent home if you’re so scantily clad that it’s distracting to the people around you.
But Ana Espada, from Advocates for Children, said, “Generally, the principal cannot prescribe the way a student can dress-generally.”
Express Yourself, Within Limits
Another important right is the right to express your opinions in a school paper. This right is limited: The principal also has the right to censor certain articles.
But principals can’t censor anything they want-only articles that would disrupt school, endanger students or violate the educational mission of the school.
When the staff of my school paper wrote about the conditions of the bathrooms-they smell terrible, there’s trash all over the floors and there’s no soap or towels to clean your hands with-the principal complained.
He said it was unfair because it didn’t give the custodians a chance. He also felt it was the students’ job to keep the bathrooms clean.
You Can Start an Underground Paper
But at least he didn’t keep the article from being printed. (And after the article came out, we did get soap and tissue in our bathrooms, but only for a couple of weeks.)
But many principals don’t want to see anything negative about their schools being put into the spotlight, and they often use their power to keep certain issues out of the school paper.
If you feel like issues that should be addressed in the school paper are being censored, or banned altogether, you have the right to start an “underground” paper of your own.
This is your legal right as a student, as long as you produce the paper without any help from the school and don’t disrupt the flow of student activity. (You can’t stand up in the middle of English and start handing it out, or make people late to class by stopping them in the halls to give them one.)
Exercise Your Right To Speak Your Mind
Then no one has the right to tell you what you can or can’t put into your paper. And while rules vary from school to school, one thing is universal: The editor of an underground paper can’t be suspended for speaking her mind.
In 1969, the U.S. Supreme Court ruled that, “It can hardly be argued that either students or teachers shed their constitutional rights to freedom of speech…at the schoolhouse gates.”
So should we just sit back and let them do whatever they want to do to us? Hell no! We have voices and we deserve to be heard. Know your rights, and rock on!
If Your School Is Unfair: Fight for Your Rights
About These Stories
YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.