I Got My Guy for Christmas: Maybe Santa Does Exist

Three years ago when Christmas rolled around, my mom asked me the same old question: “What do you want for Christmas?”
Usually I would say something like tons of clothes, a television, or some kind of jewelry. This time I barely had a response. My mother thought I was crazy and kept asking what was wrong.
Finally I said that all I wanted this Christmas was to go out with this guy in my class.
She said, “But what do you want from me for Christmas?”
I told her just to pick out something I would like. I didn’t really care.
My Big Crush
It all started at the beginning of my freshman year. I totally adored this guy named Andrew.
He was a sophomore, and every day he would spend his lunch period helping students in my shop class with their work. I could never wait my turn and always looked for a way to get his attention.
I would raise my hand and ask the teacher for help. If he was busy, he would send Andrew over to help me. (Go me!) When he was near my desk, I couldn’t concentrate on my work.
He would explain something and I would say, “Yes, I get it.”
But when he tested me, he saw that I really had no clue what I was doing. So, you guessed it, the next time he came over to my desk, I would try to concentrate so I didn’t look so stupid.
I Wrote Him a Letter
At lunch he would sit one table away from me with his moron friends. I would always stare at him and hope that he didn’t notice.
A girl I knew liked him also.
She was like, “He’s not yours.”
“Not yet!” I said. I sounded serious.
I decided to write him a letter saying that I thought he was adorable.
I was afraid to even write it. I thought that if we ever went out, he would be the one to ask me. But I knew deep inside that if you truly want something, you can’t wait for it to come to you-you have to go out and try your hardest to get it.
Although I am shy, I got a rush of power that allowed me to take the chance. Something told me to go for it, before it was too late! My shyness was overcome by emotions.
A Little Bit Chicken
Trouble was, I couldn’t give him the letter myself. I was scared of handing it to him face to face. I thought he might think I was too forward or, even worse, that I was desperate.
But I was also worried that he would think that I was a chicken for not giving it myself. In the end, I asked my cousin to give it to him, and then I waited forever for a reply.
Winter vacation came and went and, even though we spent a lot of time hanging out together, he still hadn’t responded to my letter. I thought he’d forgotten, but it turns out that he wanted to think more about it and get to know me better.
When we went to the mall or to the movies, I was really anxious. I wasn’t sure how I should act. And I began to think I had made a big mistake by telling him I liked him.
Finally, His Reply!
But finally he wrote back. He told me he liked me and that he was sorry for taking so long to reply! He said he didn’t want to ruin the friendship we had.
I hadn’t even thought about that! The moment I saw him I thought boyfriend, not friend.
He also asked how would we see each other if we went out-I lived in Brooklyn and he lived in Staten Island. I said we could take turns visiting, and he didn’t seem to mind.
Two months after I wrote him the letter, on February 22, Andrew and I went to see a movie in Brooklyn. It was dark and silent in the theater, and of course I was extremely nervous.
“Would you like to be boyfriend and girlfriend?” Andrew asked. I nearly peed in my pants from hysteria! This was the moment I had been waiting for!
Two Months Late, Worth the Wait
Finally, I had my Christmas present. Two months late, but it was the best present I ever got. Now, almost three years later, we’re still together, and you can bet I’m glad I made the first move.
Asking someone out when you’re shy is not the easiest thing to do. Even if you are outgoing and happy-go-lucky, asking someone out can be a major stress you might wish you could swear off forever.
But let me give you a bit of advice: If you and this person are meant to be, nothing can ruin it. Only you have the power to move forward. If you think this person belongs with you, then make yourself take the risk!
Sometimes something wonderful can happen. So, go for yours! Otherwise your Christmas wish might never come true.

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.