Shopping for Respect

The first time I entered Saks Fifth Avenue, I was wearing these faded-out, oversized Calvin Kleins and an off-white T-shirt that read “Life’s a b–ch and then you die.”
I was with four of my friends from school, and they all had on baggy jeans and T-shirts too. One friend’s shirt had O.J. Simpson’s dog on it and it read “Free the Juice.” Another friend had on a shirt with Tupac’s face and the words “Death Row” written across it.
It was a Tuesday afternoon in the middle of spring break, and we had decided to bum around Manhattan and window shop. We didn’t usually dress like this-we usually dressed more classy-but today we had decided to just hang out and feel comfortable. We didn’t have much to do so we were just wandering in and out of stores looking for some excitement when we saw Saks.
I Imagined Floors of Gold
I had never been to Saks before, but I imagined floors paved with gold, walls made of pearl, and rich White people everywhere. I pictured short White men following me around with walkie-talkies, and middle-aged White women mistaking me for a sales clerk.
I had heard rumors of these things from friends. One of them told me that in Bloomingdale’s, a store clerk kept following her around, and when she decided to leave, he asked to check her bags.
We decided to see how the clerks and the customers at Saks would react to us. Usually when we went to a deli or another clothing store, the clerks would watch us. It was always amusing, seeing the uncertainty in their faces, them worrying whether we had stolen anything. It made us feel stronger that we could get to them but they couldn’t affect us. Anyway, it was way better than sitting home and watching TV or hanging out at the mall where there wouldn’t be much action.
Dressed Like Hoochies
When we entered the swirling doors of Saks, things went pretty much as we expected. As soon as we walked in, four old ladies who were heading in our direction began staring at us. When we got closer, they hesitated, then changed directions. Then the women behind the cosmetics counter started looking and whispering.
My friends seemed satisfied with our first response, but I began to feel really uncomfortable. I looked around and saw all of these people dressed in tan Dockers and Ralph Laurens, and I felt angry that we had decided to look so bummy. I couldn’t shake the feeling of anxiety and humiliation. After all, we had gone in to prove that these people were racist, but then when I saw everyone looking at us, I felt like we were the ones trying to prove that all Black people were hoochies or hoodlums.
We Didn’t Belong
When we entered the Calvin Klein department on the second floor, a White woman with shoulder-length brown hair and a high voice asked if we needed assistance, letting us know by the tone of her voice that we didn’t belong there. My friends seemed to be enjoying all the attention and decided to dig deeper, aggravating these people by trying on $700 jackets and expensive gowns.
I wanted so bad to feel angry-angry at my friends for not noticing how silly we looked, and angry at the store clerk for treating us as if we had just landed on earth-but instead I felt really embarrassed. I felt silly, like I was performing live at the Apollo, performing the act of the stereotypical Black teen. The people at Saks saw me as a troublemaker. They refused to accept me even though I hadn’t done anything except wear some old faded jeans.
When I thought my pride couldn’t get any lower, I headed for the door, my ears burning and my tail between my legs, leaving my friends to go on acting like clowns.
My Elegant Return
Months later, I decided to return to Saks to write this article. As I entered those same swirling doors for a second time, all the feelings of being misjudged returned, giving me goosebumps.
I felt I had given the people at Saks the wrong impression of myself the first time. They had looked at what I was wearing and immediately thought that I was a thief or a hoodlum. This time I wanted them to see me for who I really was.
I had prepared my clothing the night before. I picked out my navy blue bell bottoms, the ones that are really tight at the thighs and give me more curves than I actually have. I decided to wear my brown tank top with it. I thought it would really make me look more elegant. I wanted to let them know that not all Black people are gangster rappers or hoochies.
Though I knew I looked good-I could tell from the looks I was getting on the street-when I got to Saks I still didn’t feel like going inside. I didn’t feel like dealing with a bunch of ignorant old people who probably thought that I was going to start a riot or something. I didn’t want them shoving their opinions and attitudes in my face as soon as I walked through the doors. Still, I summoned my courage and walked in with my reporter’s pad in one hand and my other hand clenched in a fist.
‘Girl, You Look Good!’
The entire first floor of Saks looked like a casino. Clerks with separate counters were scattered all over the place like little ants. They were swarming around selling makeup and perfume and people kept asking if I would like a sample or a smell.
I got caught up in all the excitement. I went over to one of the counters and tried on a free sample of gloss. The flavor was “chocomatte” and I thought this would really match my shirt. A salesclerk smiled at me and said, “Marvelous, that really matches your skin tone.” With his long ponytail, he looked like one of those famous hairstylists in those expensive salons. He fluttered his hands while he spoke and said things like, “Girl, you look good,” “You have a very unique look.”
Though I wasn’t sure if his whole attitude was a gimmick, what I was sure of was that unless money fell from the sky, I would not be paying $12 for any gloss.
All In the Attitude
I received the same treatment and the same tired old lines from other clerks. Still, I had to admit, I liked the attention and I felt like I was on top of the world. The way I had dressed really made me feel good about myself. I didn’t feel like anyone was better than me.
I felt as if I had discovered a new secret. It was all in the attitude. I had dressed well because I wanted them to know how sophisticated and classy I was, and, sure enough, they were treating me as if I was a customer and not a thief.
Slowly my attitude toward Saks began to change. I felt like maybe my friends and I had had something to do with the way they treated us. Maybe, I thought, they just weren’t used to baggy jeans. I questioned whether I would have treated them like aliens if they had come into a store like G&G with a Versace suit or an Armani sweater.
Still Angry, Just Not As Much
I still didn’t want to excuse them for treating my friends and me like criminals. After all, all we had done was wear baggy jeans and a couple of T-shirts. We hadn’t stolen anything or caused any real trouble, and we weren’t planning to. I still thought how they treated us was racist, and I was still angry. I just wasn’t as angry.
The longer I stayed at Saks, the more comfortable I felt. Though I didn’t feel like I fit in-I still wasn’t rich-I didn’t feel out of place either. I wasn’t intimidated by their wealth or even the color of their skin. And because I wasn’t intimidated, Saks didn’t seem so great anymore. Even the clerks who had looked so refined the first time, walking around the store like bank presidents or corporate CEOs, now just seemed like clerks.
It Wasn’t Black History Month, Just Shopping
After a while, rather than figuring out if anyone was stalking me or giving me attitude, I just wanted to shop. It seemed stupid to spend a whole shopping day trying to prove something that I already knew was true-that I, a Black girl, could be sophisticated and classy.
I didn’t want to have to represent my entire race anymore. After all, it wasn’t Black History Month-it was just a shopping trip.
So I roamed around the fourth floor feeling bold, and I tried on a $1,079 suede jacket from Ralph Lauren without the street patrol watching. I couldn’t believe I was wearing a thousand-dollar jacket.
I entered another department and was surprised when no one turned to look at me, as if I was just some everyday customer. I took advantage of this situation and decided to try on one of the fur coats. The coat was heavy and when I had it on I wanted to melt away. I felt so hypnotized and comfortable, until the pitter patter of little clerk’s feet gave me a scare.
No One Will Ever Trust a Black Teenager Trying On a Fur Coat
A blond-haired clerk smiled cautiously at me and asked if she could help. I smiled back and said, “No thank you, but thanks anyway.” I knew these lines well since I’ve had to say them a lot of times to store clerks who thought I was going to rip them off. I also knew that no matter how polite or sophisticated I was or how well I dressed, no one would ever trust a Black teenage girl trying on a fur coat.
After I put the coat back on the rack, I walked off looking behind me to see if she was following or watching. I decided to try my luck again and try on an expensive leather jacket. I modeled it in front of the mirror, all the while ignoring the stares of the store clerks.
She Gently Cuffed the Sleeves For Me
From out of nowhere, an older woman came from behind me. She shook her head and said “No” in a beautiful Middle Eastern accent. I looked at her confused and asked her what was the matter. She looked at me and said the jacket was entirely too big for me. She gently cuffed the sleeves and shortened it. She reminded me of my mother when she used to cuff the sleeves of my shirts in the wintertime because she always bought me big clothing so I would be able to wear it for the next year.
New Respect
She showed me different jackets and talked a little about herself, and her son, and about Iran, where she came from. She didn’t talk too much, just enough to make me feel comfortable. There were times when I wanted to buy something because of how sincere and caring she was, but I didn’t because I wasn’t crazy. I mean I was touched, not mad. I left her feeling really good.
Walking out of Saks this second time, I began to sing the theme song of Pretty Woman in my head. I had come in, and like Julia Roberts, the prostitute in the movie, I’d been wrongly judged. But someone had seen me for who I really was. She had treated me with respect in front of all the other clerks, and in some way, she had made them respect me too. Like Richard Gere in the movie, she had whisked me off my feet.

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.