What’s the Charge?

On February 27, 1997, at 1 a.m., I was kidnapped by those who are supposed to serve and protect me. My friend and I were walking home after he bought two forties, and I decided to carry one for him. His plan was to drown his troubles with his two favorite friends, me and the forty ounce.
But half a block away from my apartment on the Upper West Side of Manhattan, we were confronted by two plain-clothes cops. When we passed their parked car, one of them stuck his head out the window and asked me, “What’s in the bag?”
“Just beer,” I said.
“Where’s your I.D.,” he said.
I said I didn’t have I.D. because I was not expecting to use it. Then the cop said that I was the only person he knew of who walked around without I.D. I wasn’t expecting to get arrested for carrying a brown bag also, I thought to myself.
My friend told the cops that it was his beer and that he was 21, so there shouldn’t be a problem. Next thing I know, we’re being searched and handcuffed. By then I was in total shock. I’d never been in trouble before. There I was handcuffed like a criminal, wondering what had I done wrong. Two of New York’s finest didn’t even read us our rights.
They said they were taking us to the precinct to make sure there weren’t any outstanding warrants for our arrests. But before they put us in the car, the officers opened both forties and poured some of the beer on the ground. “That’s odd,” I said to myself.
A Stinking Cell
At the stationhouse, we were herded into the bullpen where there were already five people sleeping on the floor. The officers said that the computers were down and it would be a while before they could check for any outstanding warrants.
That cell was full of people who hadn’t taken a shower in days and it smelled like pure funk. I ignored the stench the best I could. As I saw those people curled up on the floor, I thought I wouldn’t do the same, but after four hours I was too exhausted to care. So I sat on that dirty floor.
From there they took us to another precinct in Harlem, where I was fingerprinted by the arresting officer, Ken Dayley. When he finished he said, “You did good, I’m proud of you.”
I didn’t know what he meant by that. I thought about it for a while and now I think he was proud of me being arrested and fingerprinted. The first steps that could lead to a life behind bars.
What’s the Charge?
Officer Dayley took me to another room and told me to empty my pockets. When I was done, I noticed an unfamiliar folded paper I had taken out of my pockets. When I went to look at it, Mr. Dayley yelled, “Put that sh-t down!”
Cursing back at him crossed my mind, but I knew that the less I said to him, the better for me. I knew he wouldn’t be yelling at me if he didn’t have that gun.
I gave him a dirty look. At that time I would have done anything to have Mr. Dayley drop his gun and fight fair with me. In that state of mind, I don’t think Mike Tyson could have whupped me.
Next stop was another cell to be strip searched. That was the worst I’ve felt in my life. It wasn’t fun having a man look at my private parts.
From there I was held in another cell until 7 a.m., when I was to be taken downtown to see the judge. During the hours I was in that cell, I realized why the cops opened the forties and poured them on the street. They needed an excuse to arrest me.
Carrying unopened beer bottles in a bag isn’t a crime, even if you’re underage. There I was, sitting in a dark corner, asking myself, What’s the charge? I wasn’t even allowed to make a phone call.
At 7 a.m, 19 of us were chained together and put in an armored truck the size of a matchbox for a ride to the Criminal Courthouse on Centre St. in downtown Manhattan.
Through this I remained quiet. I was too pissed off to do anything. All my life I’ve been concerned about doing the right thing, but now I was trapped. I was missing my apartment. I wanted to be home working out while listening to Tupac.
It’s funny, when you’re locked up you miss all the little things in life. Like walking down the street, or sitting somewhere watching the pretty girls go by. Being in that truck was awful. A couple of times I closed my eyes, hoping that it was a dream and that when my eyes opened again I would be home watching T.V. But when my eyes opened again, I found myself chained like a slave.
Unable to Sleep
At the Courthouse I was strip searched again and fingerprinted twice. Then put in another holding cell. I sat staring into space, waiting for my date with the judge. One of hundreds of suspected criminals, all complaining of being wrongly arrested. How could all of them be lying? Was it a coincidence that for every White male, there were 10 Blacks or Hispanics in there?
As time went by, my urge to get out of there grew. For lunch and dinner they gave us salami sandwiches, and we had all the tap water we could drink from the cell’s sink. I didn’t eat anything.
Also, I hadn’t slept for over two days. I took a little nap here and there but I needed to keep my eyes open just in case. At night two guys were fighting over matches, others over a cigarette, and two others over a sleeping place on the floor. With this madness going on around me, I realized prison life doesn’t adjust to anybody. You must adjust to it.
I got to see the judge at around 12:30 a.m. The court’s lawyer informed me the charge against me was drinking in public. She advised me to plead guilty.
If I did, I was going to get released that same night and maybe do a little community service. And the case was going to get thrown out. I told her I was innocent and I wanted to clear my name.
She said that if I pleaded innocent, I would have to make bail money and fight the case in court. Which meant my words against Mr. Dayley and his partner (two White police officers). I knew who the judge was going to believe.
I looked down at my hands. They were dirty from being fingerprinted so much. My clothes and body were smelling funny. I wear contacts, so my eyes were burning and, worst of all, my pride was hurt. I couldn’t go through another day of smelling salami sandwiches.
So I pleaded guilty (big mistake), and was released that night. They told me that as long as I stayed away from trouble for six months, my case was going to get thrown out.
Why Was I Framed?
If I had known the way the system works, I would have never pleaded guilty. If the charge was drinking in public, I should have demanded a blood test.
If you ever get wrongly arrested, don’t plead guilty. Don’t make the mistake I made. Fight it until the end. I didn’t fight it, so now my name is tainted. I can only hope that this arrest will not follow me the rest of my life.
Why did Officer Dayley arrest me? Why did he frame me? He knew that the beer was not open. He tampered with evidence when he broke the seals on those bottles. Maybe he arrested me because he needed the overtime hours, but then this cold chill comes over my body. Maybe Officer Dayley and his partner are racists.
Lost Faith
If not, then what were they doing in their car, looking for anybody who, to them, seemed suspicious in a Black and Hispanic neighborhood? If they are not racists, then why did they frame me? They could’ve given me a citation and let me be on my way. Instead, they arrested me. Maybe they wanted to see a Hispanic man suffer.
When did walking on the streets carrying a brown bag become a crime? I know why Officer Dayley wouldn’t say what I was charged with. The only crime I committed was being born Hispanic in this White man’s world.
No, I’m not ashamed of my culture. I’m ashamed that I actually believed in the justice system once.
Every year Irish people get drunk in public at the St. Patrick’s Day Parade. Do police arrest all those drunks or give them citations? If that many people got drunk at the Puerto Rican Day Parade, I bet all of them would get arrested.
The criminal system controlled me for 21 years. I’ve been a God-fearing, law-abiding man and look where it got me in your world. I played the game by your rules. I trusted you. Yet the first chance you get to screw me, you took full advantage of it. You chained and handcuffed me like some wild beast.
You may say I shouldn’t be walking around with beer in my hands. But you shouldn’t be sitting in a car waiting to kidnap people at will. To us, we are dressed comfortably. To you, our appearances look suspicious and every one of our movements is dangerous. That’s why you’re quick to lock us up or shoot us in the back.
Those 23-and-a-half hours behind bars made me lose respect for the system. Every time I see a police officer, the first word that comes to mind is “pig.” I don’t like feeling this way, but I can’t help it. It’s unfair that one police officer can ruin the reputation of many others who wear their uniforms proudly and who truly serve and protect people.
Guilty as Charged
Since Officer Dayley arrested me without charge, it’s only fair that I use my freedom of speech and charge him. I charge Ken Dayley with kidnapping, tampering with evidence, and disorderly conduct. I charge you with overstepping the boundaries while using your badge as a shield.
How do you plead Mr. Dayley? Innocent, you say? I find you guilty as charged.
Thereby, I sentence you to 23-and-a-half hours behind bars. You will be arrested without a charge and no one will read you your rights. You won’t be entitled to make a phone call, and you will be strip searched and fingerprinted three times. Also, yelled at, handcuffed, chained, and forced to ride in that little armored truck. I want you to feel like a caged animal, the way I did. Last but not least, I sentence you to a day of smelling salami sandwiches.
How do you, Officer Dayley, sleep well at night, knowing that on Feb. 27 you arrested an innocent man? Maybe arresting innocent people gives you pleasure. We both know I’m innocent, yet still I’m guilty.
A Bitter Taste
I was born guilty in a world where I may never be judged by the content of my character. And if I try to get justice by any means necessary, I’ll end up on Death Row. But I won’t fight fire with fire, because you can hide behind your shield and I’ll be the only one getting burned. I won’t give you a reason to claim that I’m violent.
I’m asking you, Officer Ken Dayley, to be a man of principle and erase the bitter taste I have in my mouth and the anger in my heart. Tell them I’m innocent. Stop living a lie. Tell them the truth. Tell them!

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.