They Can’t Ban My Banjo!

For a few weeks last summer, I was a subway musician.
I covered some punk and folk songs along with some original blues on my banjo in front of the center track of the 42nd St. shuttle stop under Grand Central Station.
I decided to play in the subway for a variety of reasons. I’m an independent person who’s never done well with traditional schooling or fast-food type jobs and I needed to make some money. I also knew performing in front of strangers would help me build confidence. I figured New Yorkers would let me know how I was doing-either they wouldn’t give me any money, or they’d put it to me straight and say, “You suck, kid. Go home.” On the other side, I can’t deny having hopes of being “discovered” by some music industry big shot. But mostly I just wanted to be self-employed.
‘Yes Sir, Officer’
It took me a little while to find a good spot to play. I was looking for stations that were busy because I figured they would generate a better income. The first ones I tried were Atlantic Avenue and Borough Hall in Brooklyn, and East 86th Street in Manhattan. All of these stations are transfer points from one subway line to another. The Atlantic Avenue station also connects to the Long Island Rail Road. I spent about a week just testing out different spots. Some of them were too crowded or noisy. I also had some run-ins with the law.
My very first day out, in fact, the transit police told me to pack it up and leave the Atlantic Avenue station. They didn’t say why, and I assumed that I was breaking the law by playing there, so I left without an argument.
At East 86th Street I got a summons for blocking the turnstile even though I was well away from the turnstiles and the token booth (it’s illegal to play within 25 feet of a token booth). At that point I still didn’t know my rights as a subway musician and just accepted the summons passively. (Even after I educated myself on the subject, I wound up having to pay the fine because I overslept and missed the court date.)
My Personal Spot
At Grand Central, I first played in the tunnel between the shuttle and the 4, 5, 6 and 7. I didn’t realize that I was playing in front of the station manager’s office until he came out and asked me to please play at one end of the tunnel or the other.
I finally decided to make the space in front of the middle track of the shuttle stop my personal spot. It wasn’t too noisy or too crowded, and it certainly wasn’t empty. I wanted to be consistent; I figured I stood a better chance of earning fame and fortune if people saw me in the same space every day. I would arrive by 7 a.m. to catch the morning commuters on their way to work and get their extra spending money before they had a chance to give it to somebody else.
When I left my house in the morning, I would only take $1.50 with me for the train fare there. With no money on me, it was easier to calculate my daily earnings.
‘Where’s Your Permit?’
One morning, I had just started playing when a police officer-let’s call him Officer O-came up to me and told me that if I didn’t have a permit I’d have to leave. I told him that I’d only earned a dollar so far, but if he’d let me play until I received another 50 cents I’d leave the station and try to get the permit.
“I can’t do that,” he said.
I explained that I couldn’t leave without the money to get home, and asked if he’d donate the 50 cents.
“No.”
After little further discussion, he finally agreed to leave me alone if I went somewhere else in the station. So I moved to the other end of the tunnel, set up and played long enough to earn about $10.
I had broken a string but was continuing to play when a woman police officer approached me. She told me that I would have to go because I needed “a permit and some lessons.” (Everybody’s a critic.) That pissed me off and knowing my mouth would only get me into further trouble, I decided not to say anything. Instead, I left the station to go buy some strings.
Going Quietly
Keeping my word to Officer O, I went to the office of the Grand Central Security Alliance (they’re a joint law enforcement effort that combines Metro-North, transit, and surface police units) and asked where I could apply for a permit. They told me to call the New York City Transit Authority, and they directed me to Music Under New York (MUNY), the organization that issues permits to underground performers.
I called MUNY and spoke with the director, Gina Higginbotham. She gave me the lowdown on how to audition for a permit. It turned out that MUNY only auditions once a year, in May. It being July, I had missed my chance until 1997. But Gina told me as long as I wasn’t using an amplifier, I didn’t need a permit to play. She also informed me that the location I had been using at the shuttle stop was an official MUNY performance sight, chosen specifically because it didn’t obstruct turnstiles or violate any other rules.
I’m Not Breaking the Law
Hot dog! That’s what I wanted to hear. Even though this meant that I might have to give up my spot to anyone officially scheduled to play there, at least I wouldn’t have to leave just because the cops said so. I gave Gina my home address, and she said she’d mail me a copy of the state law that guaranteed me that right. Boy, was I happy. I bought my strings, tuned up, and went right back down to my spot.
It wasn’t long after I’d started to play again that the same woman cop came back. “Didn’t I tell you to leave?” she asked.
I explained the process I’d gone through and how I’d learned that I wasn’t breaking any laws by being there.
She didn’t want to hear it.
I told her I didn’t want to argue with her. Why didn’t she come with me to the public phone a few steps away so we could call Ms. Higginbotham together and I could prove to her that I was within my rights.
“There’s no argument here,” she said. “I’m telling you to leave.”
“You’re right there’s no argument,” I replied. “I’m not breaking the law. I don’t have to leave.”
A Physical Threat
“You must really want me to break your f-kin’ head,” she said. (I love when cops use colorful langauge.)
That’s when I got raw. “DID YOU HEAR THAT?” I started to shout as loud as I could. “THIS COP TOLD ME SHE WAS GONNA BREAK MY F-KING HEAD! I’M NOT BREAKING THE LAW. IT’S PERFECTLY LEGAL FOR ME TO PLAY HERE, BUT SHE THREATENED ME BECAUSE I WON’T GO!”
I didn’t attract a crowd, but two young men stopped and watched (thanks, fellas). “WAIT,” I yelled to them. “DON’T LEAVE, ‘CAUSE THIS COP IS GONNA KILL ME FOR PLAYING THE BANJO!”
They stayed. The cop left. Believe me, I was as surprised as you are. I couldn’t believe it: I stood up for my rights, and it paid off. I played the rest of that day without further interruption and returned the next day, confident that my newfound knowledge would protect me from these pigs.
Knowing Your Rights Is Not Enough
I was wrong. I hadn’t been playing 20 minutes when Officer O came along again and this time he wasn’t alone. He told me that I had to leave. I explained what I had found out about my rights but he wasn’t a good listener. He told me that if I didn’t move, he would take further action against me. Fearing a broken banjo, I left. But I didn’t go home. I went to the city clerk’s office.
I figured if MUNY was sending me a copy of the law that guaranteed my rights, then I could find it in the law books on my own. (Mama didn’t raise no gump.) After a little research, I found it and photocopied it.
State of New York Official Compilation of Codes, Rules, and Regulations, Chapter XXI, Section 1050.6 (c) reads as follows: “The following nontransit uses are authorized and permitted by the authority, provided they do not impede transit activities and they are conducted in accordance with the rules governing the conduct and safety of the public in the use of the facilities of New York City Transit Authority and Manhattan and Bronx Surface Transit Operating Authority: public speaking; distribution of written noncommercial materials; [and] artistic performances, including the acceptance of donations.”
That evening when I got home I found the copy of the same law that Gina Higginbotham had sent me. The next day I went out armed with my information, and my banjo. When Officer O came along for the third time (now with not one but two other officers) and told me to leave, I showed him my photocopy of the law, as well as the typed version that Higginbotham had sent me.
“This is a photocopy,” he said. “It doesn’t mean anything to me.” He accused me of obstructing pedestrian traffic and I pointed out that I was playing in a designated MUNY space with a huge MTA logo painted on the floor.
“You can’t ask for money from subway riders,” he said next. “That’s illegal.”
“It says right here that I can accept donations,” I said.
“Accept, not solicit,” he said pointing to my open banjo case on the ground. “Leaving that open is soliciting.”
A Trip to Headquarters
There was no arguing with him. I feared these cops would set me up by saying I got irrational or physical with them, and since it would be my word against theirs, I decided it was best to pack it up. I asked what police district they worked in, thinking I might file a complaint. District Four, they said.
At the time the Transit Police was still a separate entity and District Four’s headquarters was at Union Square station. “It’s not us who want you to leave,” the desk sergant explained. “It’s the station manager. We don’t do anything until the station manager calls us and asks us to remove you.”
The station manager was on vacation for the week, but there was an acting manager in his stead-the same guy who’d asked me not to play in the middle of the tunnel. “I just don’t want you playing in the walkway,” he reiterated. “Play at either end.”
“The desk sergant told me that the transit police don’t ask musicians to move unless there is a complaint called in by the station manager,” I said.
“I didn’t call anyone.”
I asked if I could tell the transit cops this the next time they bothered me and whether he would come to my aid. He said no.
Too Tired to Fight On
I wanted to play my banjo, not fight the system. I probably could have taken further action- maybe gotten the media or a lawyer involved-but I didn’t have the time or energy to make this my personal cause. Sick of the runaround I was getting, I decided it was no longer worth my while to play in the subway at all.
Since then my attitude has changed. I no longer view what happened to me as an isolated incident. I now see the bigger picture. This is an issue of civil rights which affects not just me and other subway performers but every other citizen as well. United States citizens are guaranteed by law the liberty to express themselves freely without fear of arrest or imprisonment.
It’s important for all of us to stand up for our rights whenever they’re threatened. While I doubt that I’m going to make a career out of performing in the subways (I have more responsibilities and heavier financial needs now), I also realize how important it is for me to go back out there and assert my rights.
We Can’t Allow Them to Control What We Say and Do
By ceasing to perform-or even by applying for a special permit to do something which is my legal right to begin with-I’m sending the message that it’s OK with me for the state to regulate my freedom of expression.
I now feel I have a social obligation to go back down in the subway and perform this summer. And I know when I do I’ll be the only 20-year-old playing punk songs on a banjo. (Look for me in my old spot in front of the center track of the shuttle stop at Grand Central.)
But what about you? It doesn’t matter if you’re not a musician or artist. Let’s say you’re just an average teenager sitting on a stoop or standing on a street corner with you’re friends, exercising your right to peaceably assemble. You’re not bothering anyone or doing anything illegal, and all of a sudden a cop comes along and tells you to move. What are you going to do about it.

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.