Why Was I Taken Away?

Now that I’m 21 and life gains a little perspective, I begin to look back. And as I look back and as I learn about the way the system works, I wonder if it was necessary for me to go back into foster care a second time.
When I first went into care, I was at the tender age of two. From what I’ve learned, the first time was necessary. My mother had a nervous breakdown, which kept her from being able to take care of us.
But when I think of the second time that I was taken away, I can’t help but wonder if it was really necessary.
Some of you may not believe this, but this is something I remember from when I was young. The reason that we were taken away wasn’t because we were being abused. It was because of the bruises that were on my little brother’s legs that he got when we played.
My younger brother Bobby went to the hospital for problems he had with asthma, which led to the discovery of bruises. Bobby, who was about five, was then taken from the hospital and my mother was accused of abuse. I was taken away also, but I wasn’t questioned like my little brother was.
Not Enough Money
My little brother was the only one who was questioned about the problems at home. We were hit in my home when we did something wrong, but it wasn’t abuse.
It was about my mother trying to maintain discipline in a home with four boys to take care of, including two teenagers. My father would come by and visit me every now and then, but my mother basically raised us without the help of any of our fathers.
Why wasn’t I questioned, instead of being taken away from my home at around 10 or 11 years old? Because if the BCW had questioned me, they would have found out that the problems we had were related to not having enough money.
Family Needed Help
We didn’t have enough food. There was no one to babysit us, so my mother couldn’t go to work or continue her education. I remember when she tried to go to school, but it proved too difficult for her, because she didn’t have carfare. My mother would suffer from real bad depression, because she would worry about how we were gonna eat at the end of each month. She also worried about our health.
If she was given the assistance she needed, the pressure on her would not have been that great and she would have been able to maintain her home a little better. It wouldn’t have been perfect, but more assistance would have helped my mother, who tried to do it alone, and it might have kept us out of care.
But because of the lack of a proper investigation of the real problems by BCW, we were taken away. We weren’t offered the services that may have helped us stay together. Those services may or may not have worked, but they at least should have been tried.
The money that was given to my two foster mothers to raise me would have been better spent in helping my mother try to raise us at home. With a little more financial assistance, some daycare, and carfare to and from school, my mother might have been able to resume a career as a nurse’s assistant or become a registered nurse. I don’t know the whole story of my mother’s problems (I’ve never been able to see my files), but from what I remember, more could have been done to help.
I can remember when I was little, the way my mother would cry when she saw me at the agency. The shame she would feel from caseworkers, who thought they were doing her some kind of favor by letting her see the children she gave birth to. The anger in my mother’s tone of voice when she spoke with the caseworker. The way I knew she wanted to protect me but couldn’t. How she wanted to tell me how much she loved me, regardless of what the caseworkers and foster parents told me about her.
When they took us away, the system broke her will and nearly crippled her with depression and we couldn’t go back home. She held herself together when we were with her. Her children gave her a purpose.
Raising Four Boys Alone
I remember the tears that I would see in my mother’s eyes when there wasn’t enough food in the house. How she would have to ask the neighbors for money. She didn’t use drugs, she didn’t drink or anything of that nature, not to my knowledge. She raised us as best she could. Four boys on her own.
What we lacked in material things we had plenty of in love and companionship.
In a lot of ways, we had the love and companionship that only your biological family can give. This is what foster care says it provides, but this isn’t the case in a lot of the foster homes.
Sometimes I doubt that foster parents really can understand the trauma, and therefore the sensitivity, of a child who enters a new home for the first time. This is what I experienced personally.
Does anyone understand the deep-seated questions that trouble a great number of children and young adults in care? Was enough done to help my family? Why am I in care? Why was I taken away?

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.