Speakout on Speaking Out

Interviews by Anna Borshchevskaya, Latoneya Burwell, Gladys Cortez, Mercene Gayle, Donna Hutchinson, Kenisha Marsh, Nofisat Odunsi, Melissa A. Oliver, Ana Angelica Pines, Jesselin Rodriguez, Adebiyi Thornton and Damon Washington.
How Do You Spell Freedom?
What does the Term “Freedom of Speech” Mean to You? Is It a Freedom You Feel You Enjoy?
Edgar Ruiz, Fannie Lou Hamer Freedom HS: To me it means that you can say whatever you want up to a certain limit, such as cursing at someone or at elders, or hurting someone else’s feelings.
Alfreda Gomez, 15, John F. Kennedy HS: Freedom of speech to me means the right to express myself without consequences.
Frances Aboushi, 16, Edward R. Murrow HS: It means I can speak my mind. I can criticize the government, the president. Yes, I enjoy that freedom, of course. In other countries, if you open your mouth you can get prosecuted. This is the beauty of America.
Cynthia Feliciano: To me, it means to be able to say what you want and to be able to speak the way you want to speak. It’s a freedom I enjoy at times. Whether it’s at home or in school, I like to talk the way I want to talk and I don’t like having someone tell me what and what not to say.
Christina Gonzalez: It means that you can say what you want and you can express what your opinions are. [I only have it] sometimes because in school it’s limited what you can say. They limit what you can say and print in school publications.
Benjamin Fields: Freedom of speech means freedom to express yourself in whatever way you would like to. It’s a freedom that you take for granted because you’re so used to having [it.].
Tiffany Bailey: Freedom of speech is the right of expressing all of your thoughts and feelings about important issues and important people like any political leaders. Yes, I enjoy it because I have a big mouth and I would die if I couldn’t say what I wanted to.
Vinita Hardat: I have the privilege and the right to say and express what I feel. No one of authority can say what I’m saying is wrong or scold [me] for how I feel…I could enjoy the freedom if it was actually given to us and [not] just words in the Constitution. Because even though it is said to be given to us, we are still not free in what we say.
Alecia Hylton: To say whatever you want and to speak out for whatever you believe. Yes, because you get to voice your opinion on anything you want.
Damien Zervos, 15, HS for the Physical City: I think it means that whatever you want to express about something, you express it. Yes, because I am using it [right now].
Hashem Eaddy, 17, Hillcrest HS: Being able to express freely-No limitations, walls, bans, nothing to stop you from expressing yourself…If something is bothering me I can go anywhere and find a solution without thinking [about] what people are gonna say or think about me.
Take It to the Limit?
Are There Any Circumstances Under Which You Feel People Should Be Prevented From Expressing Themselves?
Benjamin Fields, 17, Brooklyn Polytechnic HS: Yeah. When it comes to your use of freedom of expression and you begin hurting someone else, then there should be a limit. People can express themselves and can say whatever they would wish to say, but when it affects another person’s safety, it becomes another issue.
Cynthia Feliciano, 15, HS for Health Professions and Human Services: I don’t agree with public nudity. It makes people look low and it’s wrong. I also think racist groups should be prevented from expressing themselves.
Sherita Revander, 16, Prospect Heights HS: The KKKs don’t have a right to do what they do, and trying to end this problem is not possible because people abuse freedom of speech. Freedom of speech shouldn’t be freedom of action…I don’t like a lot of people but that doesn’t mean that I should hurt them; all I can do is to stay away from them. I think actions should be limited. A law should be passed against certain actions.
Sebastian Sol, 18, John F. Kennedy HS: At certain times, for instance in spreading rumors, writing publicly wrong things about other people in order to hurt their reputation, or trying to start a riot.
Alfreda Gomez: I think that people should be prevented from expressing themselves if they are going to hurt other people’s feelings, or if their viewpoint is harmful to others.
Alexis Hooper: Violent protest. Violence shouldn’t be accepted.
Tala Manassah, 15, Institute for Collaborative Education HS: Yeah, I think [certain things are] harmful to a lot of people and should be censored. For every action there’s a reaction, and if your action is, ‘All women should be burned at the stake,’ the reaction would be a fight.
Frances Aboushi: Movements like KKK, Nazis…this is America, land of the free, but that’s the problem. Thanks to America, they have the right to march in a Polish-Jewish community…I think there should be a strong limit. I think they should be outlawed. The way they’re expressing it. Don’t tell me no fight is going to start. Everyone knows it’s going to turn into something horrible, abusive. They will say things that trigger fights.
Hashem Eaddy: Yes. I think they should be able to express themselves freely as long as it doesn’t cause violence.
Christina Gonzalez: No. I don’t think so because if you limit anyone’s rights, then you limit everyone’s rights.
Tiffany Bailey: I think that KKK rallies are wrong, regardless. If you have that feeling, I don’t want to hear about it. I think violence against women is wrong because I don’t think they would like any of this to happen to their mothers.
Who’s Stopping You?
How Have You or Other People Your Age Had Your Freedom of Expression Limited?
Alecia Hylton, 15, Acorn HS: At my house if [I] do something wrong and I’m trying to explain what was going on, my mother [sometimes] says she doesn’t want to hear another word out of me.
Christina Gonzalez, 16, John Dewey HS: There was a girl in my school who won the poetry contest but her poem couldn’t be printed because it dealt with suicide.
Tiffany Bailey: Just recently. I’m in the Council for Unity and our principal is trying to shut us up because we want to have a talent show and he doesn’t feel that teenagers can control themselves, but I just think he’s scared that he might lose his job because he’s a new principal.
Hashem Eaddy: Parents and teachers, you know…For instance you think you should be able to have sex and you can’t talk to your parents about it because you know [you’ll] get, like, ‘You’re too young for that.’ Some teachers will let you say what you want but others will look at you like you’re crazy or like you insulted God or something.
Cynthia Feliciano: At home, my parents don’t want to hear what I have to say. My father is the big man in the house. What he says goes. If you go against it, he will punish you and send you to your room.
Frances Aboushi: At home. I can’t volunteer at hospitals, participate in leadership programs. My parents are very old-fashioned. I can’t go to parties or anything. They want to keep their little girl. They don’t want anything from the outside.
Tala Manassah: Actually, my school and my parents don’t limit my freedom of expression. I’m very lucky. Friends that I have feel that their school is a prison and they can’t say what they want to say. I guess this is what people tell them.
Paul Ududec, 19, International HS: When I was first arrested…we went to the precinct and everything, and after I stayed there for two and a half hours, I realized that they didn’t read me my rights, and I got to the point where I didn’t care and I asked them, and they go, ‘You got the right to be a chicken. You can either be cooked, fried, or stuffed.’ And they told me, ‘When you’re going to act like a human being, we’ll treat you like one. Now you’re an animal.’ They did find me innocent.
Anthony Franklin, 15, Boys and Girls HS: I got into an argument with a teacher who cursed at me and I cursed back at her which led to my suspension.
Kayleen Seda, 15, Fannie Lou Hamer Freedom HS: I feel that as a student I sometimes have my freedom of speech limited. Such as in school when you and a teacher have a difference in opinion, they want to be right and sometimes it makes them feel more powerful and then they don’t want to hear your side.
Freddy Estrada, 17, Fannie Lou Hamer Freedom HS: In school, whenever something happens and you try to explain yourself or your opinions on the situation, they don’t let you. So then you end up feeling you were limited and come out feeling bad.
Sebastian Sol: At home I really don’t have any say-so, because my parents make all the family choices. At school we have a newspaper and the principal is the one that has to approve the material that gets published.
Having Our Say
What would you like to see happen that would give teenagers a greater voice and more outlets for their ideas and creativity? What will it take to make that happen?
Tiffany Bailey, 15, Hillcrest HS: First of all, I think teenagers should go to school so they can learn to speak-no ebonics-and so then people will listen to them. Otherwise they’re mute. I think parents should start their children off, but the kids have to do the rest themselves. Get involved with programs in school, like student government.
Alexis Hooper, 16, Brooklyn College Academy: NYC newspaper-that’s a way students express themselves, [we need] more papers…more activities and umm like if they have like recreation things youth can be involved in. I think that would be an outlet for more creativity. Just like [Mayor] Giuliani could stop fireworks in Chinatown…then he could place activities in school. I think the government has a great impact on what could and can’t happen in the U.S.
Ray Soriano, Fannie Lou Hamer Freedom HS: I think that we could start making programs in school and in our community, so that people can see a good side of kids, not always seeing us in some connection to drugs, fighting, and guns.
Alecia Hylton: They should have representatives that listen to teens more often. They should have shows that show the real issues that concern us and not have actors or actresses to pretend. The media should present the real issues and not just put it on for reasons good for the TV. Have some teens that are determined to do these things: write to your community representatives and if it doesn’t work, go further, like write to the mayor or congress. You can petition, but the last thing to do is protest.
Benjamin Fields: Teenagers do not need to have a greater voice, but should be heard and provided more outlets for their ideas and creativity. Teenagers can be provided with more ways to express themselves by conducting themselves and representing themselves in a proper way.
Christina Gonzalez: Well, I would like to see more funding provided for programs for teenagers and a law that will give us the same freedom of speech that adults have.
Hashem Eaddy: A very publicized teen summit like a teen conference where a whole bunch of teenagers get together and discuss all their problems or concerns that they have about their lives and things that are happening around them. I think [teens] should have a protest telling what they want to be done so they can express their feelings freely. I don’t think that by having the conference they should leave out or edit anything that is said.
Cynthia Feliciano: In order for teenagers to rise in society, we have to show that we are strong and have the same rights as anyone else and we can make our own decisions like adults. This will take a lot of strength, self-esteem and power of the teenager. Protesting and revolting could happen and I agree with them because they show society that we can do as much as adults and they won’t put us down.
Frances Aboushi: I think [we need] one of our own people who is a teenager to speak out for New York teens. If he’ll just express views in City Hall, maybe sit at [a special] Student Council, there’s lots of ways…[There’s] a student from our school [who’s a] voice like that. He’s met Giuliani, if there’s anything concerning New York teens, you name it, he’s there.
Tala Manassah, 15, Institute for Collaborative Education HS: I think more youth centers, more youth magazines. I just want to say that if people are given the freedom of expression, they should be responsible and know how to use it. A lot of people are irresponsible, which is why people get censored.
India Branch, 15, Institute for Collaborative Education: It would be nice to have teenagers participate in Congress, in the whole government system…possibly come up with a teen Constitution.
Anthony Franklin: To have a teen show or a news show. This way we will develop a greater voice and have an impact on teenage kids.
A Chip Off the Old Block?
What Do You Think of Recent Efforts to Control What Kids Watch and Listen To (the V-chip, TV ratings, Parental Advisory labels, etc.)? Do You Agree with the Intention? Will It Work?
Dana Wilison, 15, Institute for Collaborative Education: I really do not agree with the V-chip. I think that if parents want to control what their kids are watching, they should do it, and they should have the power over their kids to be able to do that. I don’t think that [v-chip] will work.
Kenneth Bell, 15, HS for Graphic Communication Arts: Well, it’s like what people watch is what they watch what’s on TV is freedom of speech they can say what they want.
Rosy Peralta, 16, International HS: Well, I think that the people who work on TV, they are responsible for what we watch on TV. They should show us things we could learn from, not just violence. But I think [the V-chip] is totally wrong. Well, maybe at home it will work, but they don’t know what you do outside of home. There’s radio, porno theaters…I mean there are ways to see what you want.
Alecia Hylton: If there’s an X-rated movie, kids under 16 shouldn’t be allowed to see it. There should be an age limit for certain things.
Debroh Samoy, 18, Paul Robeson HS: I agree. It influences how the child acts. Once when my sister was showering, my little brother pulled the shower curtain to see her naked. He saw that on TV. Now I tell him, ‘Don’t touch the TV box. If you want to watch a movie, let me know, and I’ll turn on the TV for you.’ He shouldn’t be exposed to certain things because he will start doing them.
John Williams, 16, DeWitt Clinton HS: I don’t think that these ratings are going to do any good. At first I did not even know what they were when I saw them on the corner of my TV set. Even in my house they won’t do any good, because my mother puts the kids in front of the TV so that they can calm down while she cooks or cleans.
Graham Myrie, 17, Paul Robeson HS: Yes. Children should get parents’ consent. They are influenced by sex, violence, and adult language on television. They will start to think that these behaviors are normal, and feel it’s alright to act them out, when it isn’t.
Vinita Hardat: I don’t feel that [Parental Advisory labels] really make an impact on children for many reasons, such as children may not be able to understand the label and they are bombarded with profanity, sexuality, and other situations which cannot be stopped by any parental advisory label if it’s not understood correctly.
Tiffany Bailey: I think it’s the parents’ responsibility to make sure their kids watch good things, but it’s also the station’s responsibility, too. I don’t think 9 p.m. is a good time to put on Unhappily Ever After because I know most kids don’t go to bed before 9 p.m.
Benjamin Fields: I don’t think it’s helped much-a little, but not that much. Yeah, their intentions are good. No, it won’t work.
Christina Gonzalez: I don’t agree with much of this because I feel it’s the parents’ responsibility and these new things are making it easier for parents to slack off in their guidance. I don’t think [it will work] because people will watch what they want and listen to music they want if there is no parental guidance.
Hashem Eaddy: I think it’s good what they’re trying to do. It’s good so parents can see what they’re about to watch so they can tell whether or not they want their kids to watch it. I agree because it gives everybody a chance to see what they’re watching. [But] some parents aren’t home all of the time or they are at work.
Frances Aboushi: They’re hopeless, because if you listen to a tape or, I don’t know, you hear rappers cursing, it’s not like teenagers have never heard a curse before. In fact, with a lot of teenagers, every other word is a curse. No [these proposals are not going to work because] teenagers got access to everything.
Alexis Hooper: I think it’s a good idea because there’s a lot of sex and violence that sometimes is unnecessary.
Kayleen Seda: I think that the ratings are a good idea because nowadays there is too much graphic content on TV for kids to be watching. This way, now the parents have a better view and more control [over] what their kids watch.

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.